3 ms·
Netflix presumably was paying Cogent a lot of money for all those 10Gbit uplinks. Now a few cross-connects and BGP tweaks later, a traceroute shows Netflix pack
by zaroth 13y ago
Netflix presumably was paying Cogent a lot of money for all those 10Gbit uplinks. Now a few cross-connects and BGP tweaks later, a traceroute shows Netflix packets leaving a Netflix server and going more directly onto Comcast's network. I can only speculate that they turned on some dark fiber to build cross-connects between their cages and Comcast cages. Maybe they were already in the same building...
How much did Netflix's Cogent bill go down? How much of the "work" that Cogent was doing is Netflix now doing themselves? How many hops of the traceroute are owned by Netflix, and how many hops by Comcast?
When I rent a rack in One Wilshire in LA, CA, it comes with power, cooling, and a network link. When I pay let's say $1000/mo for that 1Gbps link, it's not just the link from my rack to their router that I'm paying for. And when I send 1Gbps of packets up through that link, it's not just CoreSite at One Wilshire carrying the cost of delivering those packets.
At some point, yes, I do expect Comcast to get their "fair share" of that $1k/mo. If Comcast is PAID zero dollars for delivering that 1Gbps, then I want this free bandwidth gravy train to propagate all the way back to me. Comcast, please sign me up for 10 of those free 10Gbe links you're giving out, ok? Just tell me where to rent space where I can get those free 10Gbe cross connects to your network.
But then, you can also flip the perspective and ask the question, why doesn't Comcast have to pay for all their bandwidth? Shouldn't they be paying $1,000/mo for their Gbe's?
So why does bandwidth cost money, or more specifically when should bandwidth cost money? Price, as always, is just a means of efficiently allocating scarce resources. Price can only possibly be zero if there is no scarcity. Is it possible there's no scarcity of bandwidth on Comcast's network? Now that would be comical!
I think the answer lies partially in another development. Ask Netflix to chart the cost in terms of Watts and Rack Units to deliver 1Gbps of video streams. My theory would be the cost in terms of space and electricity to generate 10Gbe of video streams has dropped orders of magnitude. This means bandwidth will be an increasing portion of your bill no matter what. It also puts more pressure on scarcity of bandwidth when the ease of which you can generate 10Gbps of useful traffic is down to just a few servers.
- aidenn0 13y ago> If comcast is PAID zero dollars... Comcast gets paid $50/month per subscriber for that bandwidth. It costs Comcast less money to peer with Netflix than to get it from cogent. Comcast wants Netflix to pay to solve a problem that Comcast's customers have. > Is it possible there's no scarcity of bandwidth on Comcast's network? Absolutely! In fact, that's part of what the chart shows; when Netflix peered with Comcast, the video quality (which is a proxy for bitrate to the consumer) went up significantly, which indicates that there was no bottleneck on the Comcast network. > Price ... is just a means of efficiently allocating scarce resources. Not in the case of a monopoly. Comcast has a monopoly on a large fraction of the broadband market. They also compete directly with Netflix, so they will leverage that monopoly to make it as expensive as possible for Netflix to continue to compete with them. This is Comcast creating an artificial scarcity of paths from Netflix to Comcast's customers. On another note, I have referred to Comcast subscribers as "customers" above; if agreements like the above continue, then Comcast subscribers are no longer customers, but rather the product that Comcast charges for efficient access to.
- zaroth 13y agoLets assume Comcast honestly thinks that Netflix owes them money for the bandwidth. I know it's highly generous, but it's a fair starting point. How does it costs Comcast less money to peer with Netflix than to get it from Cogent? Does Comcast pay Cogent too? Of course the whole confrontation was manufactured, I don't think Netflix was ever arguing that Comcast needed to boost its entire buildout just to support their video streams, and by the way they shouldn't pay a cent. Comcast doesn't have to wait till its pipe are full before controlling traffic flows.
- sschueller 13y agoIf Comcast had any competition they would be the ones paying for the better connection to Netflix. It is supposed to be in Comcast's interest to provide their customers with the access they want or the customers would switch to another provider that does offer it. Comcast is selling access to the Internet are they not? Netflix should be paying Comcast ZERO!
- _mulder_ 13y ago>Comcast is selling access to the Internet are they not? There's the rub. As a cable company, Comcast are not just selling internet access, they're also selling access to TV and Movies, infact historically this is all they sold and they're still stuck in this mindset. Netflix threaten to disrupt this lucrative business. Everyone knows cable make money from bundling a whole bunch of rubbish channels together with a handful of high quality channels and charging a lot for it. As soon as someone (Netflix) offers to let you just watch the good stuff, for less dollar, Comcast's profit line is going to take a hit. It's no coincidence that it's Netflix who has to pay extra whilst the non-threatening Google/YouTube/Facebook/Porn get past without hassle.
- maxhou 13y ago> My theory would be the cost in terms of space and electricity to generate 10Gbe of video streams has dropped orders of magnitude Spot on. You can stream video with basically nginx serving static files, you just need a 10G network card with TSO. the CPU power needed is an order of magnitude lower than what you need to run full stack server side frameworks. Just make sure the content fits in your page cache (RAM is cheap), and you will fill the pipe. In the upcoming month, you will be able to do this with an ARM SOC sitting on a 10cm^2 board, for 5W TDP.