3 ms·
No it's not like that. You're sort of implying that Netflix/Cogent should get free peering with Comcast because subscribers want to access Netflix. With this l
by MichaelGG 13y ago
No it's not like that. You're sort of implying that Netflix/Cogent should get free peering with Comcast because subscribers want to access Netflix.
With this logic, why should anyone have to pay for hosting bandwidth?
- djcapelis 13y agoHonestly, maybe they shouldn't. The people hosting services offer the content Comcast's customers pay them to receive.
- wmf 13y agoIf you're willing to hand off traffic to Comcast at any and all points of their choosing (aka cold-potato routing), then I'd say you should get free peering because you're doing Comcast such a favor.
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago> With this logic, why should anyone have to pay for hosting bandwidth? Because you still have to get the traffic from the datacenter to the peering point. That's what you're buying when you pay for hosting bandwidth -- transit. You're paying somebody to get the traffic to all the networks in the whole world. The last mile provider isn't providing transit. You peer with them at their facility. The connection from their customers to their facility was paid for by their customers. The connection from their facility to yours is provided by you (or by the actual transit provider you paid). So what would you be paying them for? It's nothing but a monopoly rent you have to pay because there is no other way to reach their customers.
- Touche 13y agoYou're paying for sending traffic one-way. Peering agreements are free when both sides are sending an equal amount of traffic to the other.
- AnthonyMouse 13y agoPeering agreements are free when no money changes hands. Your argument simplifies to "because Comcast said so."
- Touche 13y agoAnd free peering agreements (called settlement-free agreements) only happen when the transit is more or less balanced.
- smileysteve 13y agoSo, if Netflix just increases data that viewers are sending it, it's okay? So if Netflix adds setInterval('EqualizeBandwidth',1000/24) function EqualizeBandwidth(){ $.post('netflix.com/dosbox', {data:randomLongStringEqualtoVideoFrame+1}); } Then comcast will pay them. (And most subscribers will be fine if they only watch < 31 movies a month given an 8gb movie.) But bonus if netflix causes every one of their customers to hit the 250gb cap and therefore hate comcast. Any politician that has family trying to watch netflix would complain of overages then and shut comcast out.