3 ms·
But this still doesn't explain why Netflix is paying Comcast, not the other way around, or, even better, with noone paying anyone. This clearly shows that Comca
by tomp 13y ago
But this still doesn't explain why Netflix is paying Comcast, not the other way around, or, even better, with noone paying anyone. This clearly shows that Comcast had an upper hand in the negotiations, probably because of its monopolistic position.
- dangrossman 13y agoAll internet services pay for their bandwidth, they don't get paid to be online. Usually that means paying a hosting company, which pays a data center, which pays some transit provider like Cogent or Level 3 to get onto the internet. Netflix was paying Cogent to link it to the internet. Now Netflix's servers are directly linked to Comcast, so Comcast is connecting it to the internet [ed: to Comcast's customers], and that's who they're paying instead. Why would they want to pay Comcast instead of Cogent? Because Comcast's fight with Cogent was resulting in poor performance for Netflix customers. They had the option of waiting for it to get bad enough that one side or the other gave in on the negotiations and increased capacity, meanwhile losing customers frustrated with buffering at peak hours, or choosing an alternate route to get their bits to those customers. It also nicely sets up barriers for entry to new video streaming services, which is something maturing companies tend to do. Netflix has grown big enough to buy transit directly from ISPs instead of through middle-men like Cogent, while startups don't have the capital for that.
- smw 13y agoNetflix was paying Cogent to link it to the internet. Now Netflix's servers are directly linked to Comcast, so Comcast is connecting it to the internet, and that's who they're paying instead. No, Netflix is paying Comcast to connect them to only Comcast's customers, not the Internet. Suggesting that they're paying Comcast for transit is disingenuous.
- srj 13y agoAll internet services pay transit providers but they don't typically pay last mile networks for access to their subscribers. Comcast is able to fight with Cogent while their own customer's connectivity suffers precisely because the customers often don't have an alternative ISP. Netflix argues that if the TWC merger proceeds the situation will get even worse.
- cheald 13y agoNo, what is shows is that it was going to be more expensive for Netflix to buy market-rate transit through another provider than to peer directly with Comcast. (Or Netflix is playing the long game here and taking an unnecessary financial hit by peering with Comcast to put them in a favorable PR position, but I think that's less likely.) Cogent's thing is selling massively cut-rate transit. They've been involved in constant peering disputes over their method of doing so since at least 2002. This isn't new for them - Netflix is just big enough that people really took notice this time.