4 ms·
Is anyone working on something better than signal strength triangulation for cell tower based positioning? It seems crazy to me that we can get accuracy of a fe
by modeless 13y ago
Is anyone working on something better than signal strength triangulation for cell tower based positioning? It seems crazy to me that we can get accuracy of a few meters using weak signals from satellites in space, while the strong signals from nearby cell towers give you only kilometer level accuracy.
- wlesieutre 13y agoGenerally speaking, cell phones today already know where they are with pretty good accuracy. So the most obvious solution would be to have a standardized system for a phone to send its GPS/wifi based position to the 911 center. In some cases the caller is not able to communicate verbally because they're choking, hiding in the closet from an intruder, or any number of other reasons. In those situations, being able to reach 911 by SMS would allow them to give a location. You can't yet, but it's being worked on. http://www.fcc.gov/text-to-911 http://www.fcc.gov/text-to-911
- taejo 13y agoIf you're in a closet, your phone probably can't get a GPS signal, unfortunately.
- wlesieutre 13y agoWhatever positioning source it's using, my phone can place me within around 20 ft while it's in my closet. Not perfect, but about the same accuracy as anywhere else in my apartment. But yeah, if you're in a city with huge buildings blocking GPS signals and 50 floors of little apartments stacked on top of each other, then a rough street address may not help enough anyway.
- Lx1oG-AWb6h_ZG0 13y agoGoogle uses a combination of GPS and nearby wifi signals to figure out where you are, and it is astonishingly effective. I enabled location history for a day and could see data points for different rooms in my apartment. If any random app can access that data, I wonder why they don't integrate it with the E911 feature that's already built into android.
- lutusp 13y ago> Is anyone working on something better than signal strength triangulation for cell tower based positioning? First, cell towers do better than mere signal strength triangulation -- they use signal arrival time and round-trip time to get a pretty good fix on a phone's location. Not nearly as good as GPS, but reasonably good. Second, smartphones have GPS receivers, and some of those allow the GPS position to accompany the outgoing call. That's much better, but it sometimes requires that the call be placed outdoors. I think in the future, all cell phones will have GPS, and a few other improvements will come along to allow much better positioning.
- modeless 13y ago>they use signal arrival time and round-trip time Do you have a source for this? As far as I know this is not true. They use signal strength and knowledge of cell tower antenna locations, but not time of flight of the radio signal, as GPS does.
- lutusp 13y agoJust a handful, and most of them are pretty vague: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_phone_tracking http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_phone_tracking Quote: "Using the SIM in GSM and UMTS handsets, it is possible to obtain raw radio measurements from the handset.[6][7] The measurements that are available can include the serving Cell ID, round-trip time, and signal strength. " http://wrongfulconvictionsblog.org/2012/06/01/cell-tower-triangulation-how-it-works/ http://wrongfulconvictionsblog.org/2012/06/01/cell-tower-tri... Quote: "Within each sector, the tower can make a measurement of how far away the transmitting cell phone is. This is done by measuring signal strength and the round-trip signal time." Neither of the above references is very specific, but I recently read a paper that went into great detail, and showed graphs of the areas with the greatest accuracy, all based on arrival time measurements. Some of it may have been speculative based on future improvements in the system. But I can't locate that specific paper. Here's another reference: http://www.cnet.com/news/feds-push-for-tracking-cell-phones/ http://www.cnet.com/news/feds-push-for-tracking-cell-phones/ Quote: "T-Mobile, for instance, uses a GSM technology called Uplink Time Difference of Arrival, or U-TDOA, which calculates a position based on precisely how long it takes signals to reach towers. A company called TruePosition, which provides U-TDOA services to T-Mobile, boasts of "accuracy to under 50 meters" that's available "for start-of-call, midcall, or when idle."" You know, now that I've read these articles, it sounds more like a future technology than something that's in place right now, except for a few networks.