3 ms·
Serously? I think more emphasis should be put on reduction of suffering rather than number of years lived. It is kind of cool that we are beginning to get rid
by collyw 13y ago
Serously?
I think more emphasis should be put on reduction of suffering rather than number of years lived.
It is kind of cool that we are beginning to get rid of many diseases and people are living longer, but the people doing such research so never seem to give much thought to overpopulation and limited resources.
Imagine for example that no one dies ever, as of tomorrow, do we think the world would be a more pleasant place in 100 years time? More people, more pollution, less resources to be shared. It seems obvious to me that the environment is struggling with the current number of people (climate change, seas being over fished, oil that is going to run out relatively soon....) How will it be if we have even more people?
- JoshTriplett 13y ago> It is kind of cool that we are beginning to get rid of many diseases and people are living longer, but the people doing such research so never seem to give much thought to overpopulation and limited resources. So you'd like to kill 100 people per minute to solve overpopulation and limited resources?
- lutusp 13y agoThat was the conclusion you came to on the basis of the OP's remarks? What about free access to birth control methods? Are you aware that fertility control is a huge political issue in the U.S., complete with the occasional murder and terrorist attacks on doctor's offices? Unless, of course, you regard birth control as "killing".
- JoshTriplett 13y agoAn argument that research into curing mortality is somehow immoral based on overpopulation or limited resources directly suggests that it's better for people to die than for us to have those problems. I seriously doubt that was the intent of the argument, but that's the implication of such an argument. If my response sounded absurd, it's because making the argument was absurd to begin with. Now, if someone wants to look into those other problems too, that's fine; in particular, we do need research into solutions for other causes of suffering, not just mortality, and resource shortage is a fine place to start. But complaining about research into mortality is ridiculous. Doubly so because such an argument assumes fungibility of research resources: the people doing that research are not arbitrarily repurposable towards other issues. The rest of your post seems like an unrelated red herring combined with a vague attack.
- collyw 13y agoI didn't say it was immoral (my comment has generated a lot of straw men). I just think it creates other problems that no one seems to consider. I personally would rather live to 75 and be fairly healthy for most to that, than live to 100 and be in poor health for a significant part of that.
- collyw 13y agoWhere did I say I wanted to kill anyone?
- Domenic_S 13y ago> I think more emphasis should be put on reduction of suffering rather than number of years lived. Oh yes. We already far outlive the end of quality of life with medical intervention.
- jodrellblank 13y agoSeriously? Given a problem that will make your life less pleasant, your answer is "let people die. My comfort is more important than their lives"? Pain is inevitable, suffering is optional. http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/some-assembly-required/201401/pain-is-inevitable-suffering-is-optional http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/some-assembly-required/2...
- collyw 13y agoIts not my comfort I am thinking of. Its everyone’s.