3 ms·
"Always wondered how studying Shakespeare feels for native speakers" I wasn't going to chime in, but I think you need another data point. Also, I had assumed t
by leephillips 13y ago
"Always wondered how studying Shakespeare feels for native speakers"
I wasn't going to chime in, but I think you need another data point. Also, I had assumed that collyw was pulling our legs - his original comment seemed so much like satire. But now it seems that he's probably serious.
Shakespeare wrote in Elizabethan English, which is a somewhat archaic form of Modern English. It is immediately comprehensible to any native reader with normal language skills, who can read English at a high school level. Not fully comprehensible, but there is no obstacle to getting the gist, and much more.
I studied Hamlet with Frank McCourt. We had no "translation" and didn't need any. It is helpful when starting out to have a glossary of the archaic meanings of some words used by Shakespeare in a different sense from their most common meaning today. McCourt needed to explain almost nothing - he confined his teaching to sharing his love of the work and simply insisting that we pay attention to the words on the page and think about what the author was getting at. He mostly refused to explicate the frequent sexual innuendo, preferring that we figure it out ourselves.
Studying Hamlet was such an immensely powerful experience of aesthetic bliss that I can remember sitting in that classroom 40 years ago better than most things that happened last week. And I discovered the inner genius of Shakespeare: a blending of his characters' states of mind with the texture of language. This is why the idea of "translation" of this kind of literature is problematic.
Don't close yourself off from these potential joys because it takes a little effort.
- collyw 13y ago"Studying Hamlet was such an immensely powerful experience of aesthetic bliss that I can remember sitting in that classroom 40 years ago better than most things that happened last week." Interesting, that seems like satire to me! I studied more than enough Shakespeare to know I didn't like it and didn't gain anything from it. I don't see how you can describe a "texture to the language" when most of it required reading a translation of it on the opposite page. I guess that much of the modern comedy that I see as being very smart and political may be lost on others.
- leephillips 13y agoMaybe not your fault. A bad teacher can make anything seem dull. I've heard some students even find math unexciting. (I love the scene in Monty Python's Meaning of Life where the teacher is actually copulating on the desk in front of the class, but his students are just bored). "most of it required reading a translation of it on the opposite page" As I said, it did not. And much of the class came from households where English was not spoken.