2 ms·
No, he presents a valid problem, what if rich people would automatically mean smarter, faster, stronger (harder) people? It would turn the current divide betwee
by jodrellblank 13y ago
No, he presents a valid problem, what if rich people would automatically mean smarter, faster, stronger (harder) people? It would turn the current divide between rich and poor into a chasm.
He presents an irrelevant problem. OK, what if it would? So what?
Right now, do you say "rich people can afford more medicine and thereby live longer, therefore we should not develop medicine for anyone, to keep things fair"?
Do you say "rich people can afford more food and live healthier, therefore we should do away with agriculture and everyone should be a subsistence farmer to make it fair"?
Do you say "rich people can afford more education about health, and thereby live longer. Therefore we should forbid people from learning to make it fair"?
De you say "many poor/working class people have to work as basically indentured servants to survive, therefore they are better off dead"?
No, you don't.
There is a rift between rich and poor.
It's better to have inequality and life, than equality and death.
Obviously.
- Ygg2 13y agoI'm not saying that. I said it's best to have equality and life. Please don't warp my words. The GP has a point, if flawed one at that. Extending life by a certain amount isn't bad, it's bad if only the rich can have it. Also directly extending life is a huge boon, I think it puts many other methods (even if it's +20 years) in the dust. The rift between rich and poor needs to close.
- jodrellblank 13y agoExtending life by a certain amount isn't bad, it's bad if only the rich can have it. And we're back to sour grapes and envy. "If I can't have it, nobody should be able to have it. Hmph". Even if what we're talking about is not a football or a piece of candy, but life itself.
- Ygg2 13y agoI think maybe, just maybe there can be an option between only the rich can have it and none can have it, i.e. all can have it, some sooner than others.
- mcguire 13y ago"It's better to have inequality and life, than equality and death." A great many founding fathers, heroes, patriots, and what-not would seem to disagree with you.
- jodrellblank 13y agoA great many people put all sorts of things that don't exist (ideologies, dreams, wishes) as more important than the suffering and death of real live actual humans who are really here on earth and really alive. They're insane.
- mcguire 13y agoNo. They've rationally decided that the quality of a life is more important than simple quantity. Please realize that, if someone else disagrees with you (even if you don't understand their position), that does not mean that they are crazy. It doesn't even mean that they are wrong.