3 ms·
I keep hearing "IBM is opening POWER", but I still don't see any obvious route to dial up Asus or Tyan and order a cheap ATX motherboard that I can slap a POWER
by mindcrime 13y ago
I keep hearing "IBM is opening POWER", but I still don't see any obvious route to dial up Asus or Tyan and order a cheap ATX motherboard that I can slap a POWER processor on, and build a machine to play with. Until that day comes, it's hard for me to get excited about POWER, as much as I might otherwise want to.
- wmf 13y agoIn that case you should probably avoid the Open Compute Project, too.
- mindcrime 13y agoI don't really understand this comment. OCP, from what I've seen, is mostly dealing with designs for servers built using x86 and/or ARM processors, of which there are plenty of off the shelf motherboards already available. If people are building (or start building) OCP spec motherboards, so much the better. But with POWER, it's always been just short of impossible to buy an "off the shelf" motherboard with a normal form-factor, that uses normal RAM, etc., and put a box together. And, IMO, when an architecture is that inaccessible to the hobbyists and experimenters and tinkerers, it really hinders it. I know it definitely diminishes my personal interest, and I want to be an IBM fan in many ways.
- wmf 13y agoI get the impression that you can buy 1,000 OCP servers but you can't buy one; I wouldn't be surprised if OpenPower is the same way. But if you want one Power8 maybe you can just buy a server from IBM.
- mindcrime 13y agoI get the impression that you can buy 1,000 OCP servers but you can't buy one; Ah, gotcha. Yeah, that's kind of a bummer if that is actually the case. I haven't really looked into buying any OCP servers, so I wasn't aware of that situation.
- hapless 13y agoSME (Sun MicroElectronics) did exactly this in the 1990s. You could buy a standard ATX motherboard with an UltraSPARC II and PC DIMM slots on it. It was called the Ultra AXmp. Unfortunately, the internal cost structure was such that the Ultra AXmp cost only a few percent less than a "proprietary" workstation/server from the parent company. The moral of the story: sticking a high-margin, low-volume chip in a commodity board doesn't put it on a commodity cost basis.
- mindcrime 13y agoYeah, I was gonna say earlier, but got distracted... it would also help if one could call up IBM (or a reseller) and actually buy a POWER chip - for a reasonable price - to plug into said motherboard. In the end, it's the entire ecosystem... it's either affordable and accessible or it isn't. It's sad that IBM keeps coming out with pretty cool hardware (Cell, POWER, etc.) that nobody can afford to get convenient access to. :-(
- TheCondor 13y agoAlpha and sparc both had moderately affordable hardware (atx boards and such). Outside the geeks, what's the compelling story? I owned a couple of those devices, fact of the matter was you paid more to be on an isolated moderately performing island. To be interesting, you need an Atx board or something with a better chip at the same price or the whole thing has to be cheaper. Basically, when cell came out they should have put ps3 spec workstations on the market for $300 or maybe even less. One thing arm really does right is low cost.