10 ms·
Burnout Comes in Three Varieties
- kenrikm 13y agoI did not read the full paper so I can't comment on details that are not present, however from the article it seems as if they are attributing the burnout to the individual's own psychology when in fact it's usually a mixture of failures within the organization and the individual combined. I.E an individual may burnout in one company and not another and in reverse an organization is unlikely to burn out 100% of its employees.
- josephschmoe 13y agoThis was a survey of university workers - so I imagine that's less of an issue than at a company.
- theothermkn 13y agoYeah. This was striking to me, too. The article delegitimizes burnout as being only the result of dysfunctional coping strategies. There is no exploitation of labor? There are no dysfunctional organizations? Any job is potentially fulfilling? For better or for worse, capitalism is alienating; It disregards human value and replaces it with the economic value of labor. Pretending that that isn't the case, that labor in service of another for wages is the proper and normal condition of human beings, will help no one either adapt to this unnatural set of conditions or understand how to work at a societal level to ameliorate it.
- JamesLeonis 13y agoFrom my reading of the article, it described three types of burnout because they result from three different coping mechanisms to stress. The article didn't mention where the stress came from. I think you're right about the organization and employee friction being a source, but it was beyond the scope of the paper.
- jmzbond 13y agoA year ago, I would have thought that the antidote to burnout was start-up culture. I'm a little less naive about it now. The reality is that you can burnout in any of these ways whether or not you're a corporate monkey or a start-up monkey. Substitute vending machines and water coolers for fancy free-for-all-cafes and foosball tables, and many start-ups have similar WORK demands of their employees. In other words, no matter how fun the culture, it can't forever mask the fact that you're working toward someone else's vision and mission. I once thought this would be very different in a company of 50 vs 50,000. But even in start-ups, we suffer from an over-emphasis on specialized activities (for efficiency and scale). This creates jobs that lack ownership of the big picture, and therefore may create short term excitement (if the work or team is interesting), but does not equate to long term passion and fulfillment. As a founder with an idea, part of the reason that I don't want to join an existing effort is because I want to build an organization that challenges this model. Is there a way to better distribute ownership of the vision to everyone in the company so that instead of having a bunch of employees working toward your vision, you have a bunch of entrepreneurs collaborating to define that vision? That in my mind is a major part of avoiding burnout. The secondary piece is helping people realize that work/life balance is always necessary. As a founder, I spent one month subscribing to the Valley norm that I should just work constantly. Mentally I was fine, but physically I pinched a nerve (or something) and all kinds of horror happened. Yet this cultural attitude of fast fast fast is so prevalent, I think we should also do more to encourage people to adopt some "slow" principles.
- bowlofpetunias 13y agoI would say that start-up culture is the perfect breeding ground for burnout. #1 cause: lack of a mature organization. No clarity, no process, no structure, constant uncertainty and bosses that clearly have no idea what the fuck they are doing. Collective ownership, treating employees like entrepreneurs even though they are very different people with a different mindset and different coping mechanisms is not just misguided, it's downright destructive. Employees are not entrepreneurs, they have a different mindset and different coping mechanisms. They can handle the uncertainty of a starting company that may very well fail, they can handle long hours, but they need certainty about the nature of their job, what is expected of them and their coworkers. Not having that structure makes them extremely vulnerable to any kind of stress, stress that a startup job is guaranteed to have. It frankly pisses me off how badly employees at startups are treated by not recognizing their needs as employees. No amount of toys, free snacks and other gimmicks will compensate for that.
- jsnk 13y agoAs a developer, on top of 8 to 9 hours of work, I spend 1 to 2 hours reading technical books and coding on a usual weekday. Weekends too are spent on working on side projects. I can do this now as a twenty something, but in my 30s and 40s when there are wife and kids, I am not sure if this is viable. Are there vocations that doesn't require constant deliberate self-improvement? I can understand casually reading up on books and papers to catch up once in a while, but the expectations imposed on developers to always solve problems, learn completely new tools, frameworks and languages seems undoable for me in the long run.
- garenp 13y agoBecome a manager. :)
- wahsd 13y agoIt's not viable now, yet you still do it. What will change is that you realize it's not viable. It an abuse inherent in our society and culture that the naive are taken advantage of and exploited by society as a whole, driven by the exponential advantages a few gain from the exploitation of 99% of the rest of us. The only thing that trickles down is the fraud of a ponzi/pyramid scheme. Many people don't realize that our whole society is far more like a ponzi/pyramid scheme than not. Sure, you and I are at various levels of the top tier of that ponzi/pyramid scheme, but even we don't realize the un-realized gains due to us that are being pilfered by those above us on that pyramid. We are just happy we get what we got, which is more than those below us, so we feel good in spite of being defrauded, robbed, and stolen from. If it wasn't about exploitation then our society would shift towards "performance" based work and lower work hours per week with more free time for family, life, and happiness; but all regular people get when they are productive and efficient is more and more work because there is "always someone willing to work harder"...as the wealthy who employ those people who cause that dynamic tell us. The exploitation comes in the lack of limits and boundaries, our wealthy dealers keep telling us we should do more and try a different drug. It's a rather archetypal form of abuse, nothing is good enough and the bar keeps moving higher and higher and is always just out of reach, like that carrot leading a mule on a plow. I suggest you might want to consider doing what most do, just enough not to get fired and spend all that energy you have to develop your freedom and liberty from the rat-race and maybe even do it in such a manner that allows you to offer that opportunity to others you employ. Unfortunately, that is rather diametrically opposed to the interests of the YCombinator and VC symbiotic...parasitic???....relationship, but when you are beholden to someone else who draws 20 ... 30 ... 40 ... 50% of your efforts, gains, and profits.....you can never achieve freedom and liberty. There are frequently warnings of schemes that require you to pay or buy into something, what else are many ...most???... of these VC and incubator programs? Maybe slightly better versions? But they still promise you connections and entry into an otherwise closed community they helped build a fence around.
- moron4hire 13y agoFascinating. I must be worn out and bored. Huh, I think I already knew that. But linking specific behaviors to it is good. Maybe if I take some time off and find something new to do, I won't be worn out and bored.
- lafar6502 13y agoI certainly feel some symptoms of burnout - quality of my work went down, development is no longer interesting, all projects look the same to me. But this is not something sudden, it's been there for years, slowly changing my life. Sorry for such an useless comment, but I'm realizing it will be difficult to recover from this creeping apathy.
- GhotiFish 13y agoBoy, do I get that. :\
- cpncrunch 13y agoHave you considered changing to a new (and perhaps more interesting) job?
- lafar6502 13y agoI have considered a change, but i'm still looking for a job that wouldn't be too similar to what I'm doing now. Which is quite tricky considering the fact that i'm developing software ;)
- r00fus 13y agoIf you have the financial buffer, I'd recommend taking some time completely off work. Sometimes that's a "sabbatical", maybe doing an extended period of WorkFromHome, sometimes it's quitting and just re-evaluating life in general. Taking time off often lets me appreciate my work for the benefits it provides (association with friendly coworkers, the challenge of meeting goals, the recognition of effort taken) after I've had a chance to spend that time off on myself or family. Anything in excess can be toxic, even if convince yourself you can handle or prefer it (addiction?).
- cpncrunch 13y agoWhat about trying to work for a different type of company rather than the usual startup/blue-chip/software shop? I worked for about 6 years in the industry, but I got thoroughly bored in every single job. Either the work was too boring, or I finished it too quickly, or a combination. I never lasted more than a year or two in any job. For the last 14 years I've been running my own business, which is a lot better (more interesting work, less stress, etc.) However I will admit that I got quite lucky in building a niche product that people wanted to pay money for. If I had to get a 'proper' job again, I think I would be in the same position as you - there just aren't that many interesting and fulfilling software jobs out there. I would probably consider doing something completely different, like driving taxis, being a commercial pilot, or manual labour. If you're in a full-time job, consider doing contracting. Depending on what country you live in, it can be very lucrative and easy to find short-term work. The UK has lots of opportunities, Canada and the US less so. Unfortunately most of the work is pretty boring, but at least you only have to do it for a while before moving on. Also consider taking a lower salary but working in a more fulfilling environment. Maybe working for a non-profit or something along those lines. Or going to the other end of the scale, consider working for google. You get an incredible salary and work on fascinating projects.
- tristan_juricek 13y agoIt sure seems like most tech jobs would only need therapy as a means of last resort. Keeping a mindful eye towards burnout and adjusting your response to it based on the type seems like solid advice. I see it as: 1. The complainer: sit down and negotiate a way that person can make a bigger impact that's measurable 2. The avoider: simply try to get this person to do something they are excited about 3. The worn-out individual: this person probably just needs a bit of regular recognition (and no overtime) Personally, I find way more people in categories 1 and 2, though category 3 definitely happens in startup land where people work way too much and only see the mountain in front of them is never getting smaller. Of course I'm being a bit of an armchair manager, but it seems like a fairly decent starting point.
- dropit_sphere 13y agoI have a much more succinct description of burnout: Burnout is a broken narrative. Everyone has ups and downs, and everyone expects that. We persevere, however, because we believe, however irrationally, that it will work out in the end. Burnout is believing that no, it probably won't. The way that someone stops believing this is very reasonable---they take risks with the assurance that it will work out ("low salary, but look at the equity! Keep working!"), and then it doesn't (company shuts down). Or perhaps "we promise this is the last crunch" --- and it never is. Don't confuse this with a lack of trust. Healthy people who don't trust their employers leave and start a company/work for someone else. Burnout is when you don't see a happy ending anywhere.
- chmike 13y agoSounds like a depression.
- neohaven 13y agoWhich is why burnout is mostly work-induced depression.
- flipcoder 13y agohow would someone know if it's work-induced? Depression is commonly attributed to things that weren't actually the cause.
- dnautics 13y agodepression is chronic and not necessarily tied to real expectations of real things. Burnout is acute, most people with burnout snap back, although it might take a while.
- dropit_sphere 13y agoWhile this is true, I think "fuzzy forecast of the general future" is the thing that ties them together. That chronic depression is caused by chemicals rather than external data seems to be a minor point (well, not for treatment, but you know what I mean). I'm not sure it's possible to simultaneously believe "in the future, I will be deliriously happy," and be depressed.
- Swizec 13y agoYou know what burnout feels like? It feels like dropping everything you're doing, everything you were hoping to achieve, packing a small bag, and flying away to a different continent for a few months. Burnout is when working at a YC startup during YC feels like a vacation. When waking up at 10am and coding until 10pm feels like rest. That's burnout. You do not fuck with burnout.
- ak39 13y agoNo, this is not burnout. This is overworking. Burnout is when you have zero interest in touching your keyboard, let alone spending 12 hours coding.
- Swizec 13y agoWell I wasn't really so much burned out from working as I was from "startupping". So doing just coding was pretty relaxing in comparison.
- swalsh 13y agoBurnout for me was a self propelling entity. I'd work 12 hours a day, but not get anything done. So i'd work 16 hours a day. Not get anything done. I was depressed, unmotivated, unwashed, my personal life was falling apart, and my professional life was falling apart. The worst part is I didn't actually diagnose it as burn out until I got out of the company.
- a8da6b0c91d 13y agoBurnout is damage from prolonged stress. Stress happens when an organism faces demands beyond its sustainable capabilities to meet. All stress implies a recovery period, because the stress involves digging into reserves. I don't think the exact varieties of stress really matter all that much. It's all just a matter of too much stress over time. I think stress levels can be measured pretty well via biomarkers. Waking body temperature tracks cortisol and adrenalin (higher is better). Resting heart rate (higher is better) and heart rate variability are useful to track. I find when my waking temperature is below 97F it is clearly warning that I am burning out. If possible I might spend a day or two without leaving the couch or thinking about anything. Athletes track this stuff and back off training accordingly to manage stress. I don't think work/career stress is essentially different from athletic training. It's just that so much white collar work stress is psychological and not obviously quantifiable.
- vorg 13y ago> Organizations that want to keep their employees happy and productive may begin to invest in the fight against burnout by helping employees find accessible, affordable therapies for coping with stress. Sounds like an advert peddling employee training sessions in stress management to employers who want to cover their arses legally while continuing to require their workers to, say, carry their mobile phones around at all times to field calls at, say, 3 in the morning to fix problems that wouldn't have happened if the bosses had invested more resources in making sure after-hours problems didn't happen in the first place.
- TeMPOraL 13y agoI feel like being stuck between the second and the third type of burnout. Honestly, even though coding was my passion since being 13 years old, I had serious troubles at every single programming job I took. My productivity always seems to be at 10% of what I expect from myself; every time I have to think about something I start feeling sleepy (and I need to sleep 8h/day just to be able to get anytthing done), and I procrastinate like you wouldn't believe. For the last two years I thought that maybe, just maybe, it was because I suck at coding and my work troubles are a symptom of me not being really into programming. And then, few months ago, I stared a completely pointless side project. Back came to me the passion and productivity. I can get more done in 1h for my side project that in 8h at my job. Through the last few months I gradually regained the faith in my own programming skills. I realized that I do indeed know how to code; it's that I just can't force myself to work on stuff I don't give a fuck about. I'd love to know what to do about this. I understand that it's easier to work on your own idea than on someone else's. But having like order of magnitude differences in productivity between my job and hobby project... this just feels wrong. </mind-dump> </drunk-posting>
- asdfologist 13y agoThat sounds completely normal, even for things other than programming. I doubt anybody can be even nearly as productive doing something boring vs something they're excited about, especially if it's a mentally-intensive task.
- TeMPOraL 13y agoSo how come that everyone else around me seems to be able to remain productive and happy even though working on things the are not excited about in any way? It's a question that keeps bugging me.
- andreyvit 13y agoSounds very much like myself (except that I'm a freelancer, so can procrastinate much easier). I'm still trying to solve it, but I found that some things help: 1. A cardio workout. (Came highly recommended by a dear client of mine, and indeed significantly increases the amount of energy I feel during the day. Does not solve procrastination by itself, but helps with that sleepiness.) 2. Pair programming. (This is a true deal breaker. Maybe we're just not created for solo work, and that's it?) 3. Eating less, and less carbs in particular. (I've been diagnosed with insulin insensibility, and it really shows; I usually get very sleepy after eating.) 4. Doing work you can be proud of, way before the deadline. Not always possible, but when it is, it can keep me going for a bit. Relax, take those extra few hours to make the code clean, polished and well-documented. In my case (and perhaps in yours as well), it's not really about work being boring or not. I had a very exciting side-project of mine, which is now selling on the Mac App Store for great profit, but I started to procrastinate on it after a few months as well. Feel free to email me to talk some more.
- NAFV_P 13y agoI burned out around six years ago, due to constant insults, being shouted at, sworn at, criticisms (not constructive or analytical in any shape or form), taking the blame for other people's mistakes, threats of being "blacklisted", threats of violence, being treated like a retard, developing an awful cough due to the amount of dust on the premises and the disgusting hypocrisy and double standards practised by many of my co-workers. After eight months of work, I could count the number of positive remarks about my work that I had received on one hand with fingers to spare. The number of "incidents" would require roughly 80 or more pairs of hands to tally. I don't think I fall under any category mentioned in the article, I will furnish myself with a new category: "burnout by feeling terrorised". From my experience reporting these incidents to an outside authority is pointless, the usual response is "well everyone has problems at work". Do not give them a soundbite of what insults/threats you have endured, you might spend the night in a prison cell. From the article: > Treatments that include emotion regulation, increased cognitive flexibility, and mindfulness may help ward off burnout in susceptible individuals, suggests the research team led by Jesus Montero Marin of the University of Zaragoza in Spain. After being released from this job, the only thing I diagnosed about myself was: "I try too hard to be understanding and sympathetic of others". If you find yourself in this situation, my treatment would be: if the tactics of your enemy are more effective than yours, copy and adapt them to make your swords sharper.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- vorg 13y ago> if the tactics of your enemy are more effective than yours, copy and adapt them to make your swords sharper If you start copying the enemy's tactics, they have a way of making it look like you started it. Ultimately they are hypocrites who manage their public image to look good while they themselves do the exact opposite. If they're putting bugs in the code to generate money-making after-hours calls, then they'll accuse you of doing it. If they're bullying you, they'll very quickly and loudly call you the bully if you reciprocate in any way. Although they're monitoring you closely, they'll soon notice and single you out if you try it on them. They'll then present the publicly visible aspects of their own harassment as a proportional response to yours, hiding the full extent of their own, the fact they started it, and how tolerant you were of them at first. Because of the legal situation they made sure you were in, your only choice was to walk away. You don't just decide to copy and adapt their tactics one day - the enemy have spent their entire lives honing their own skills in hypocrisy, bullying, whitewashing, and fleecing you of money.