3 ms·
You haven't had much experience reporting crimes to the police, have you? If you tell a cop that someone cheated you in a transaction involving BitCoin, I'm gu
by logfromblammo 13y ago
You haven't had much experience reporting crimes to the police, have you?
If you tell a cop that someone cheated you in a transaction involving BitCoin, I'm guessing that 80% will laugh at you and tell you to contact your insurance company and fill out an online property crime report with their automated city/county system before hanging up, 15% will actually open an investigation on your gas station for suspected money laundering or tax evasion, and 5% will actually follow up on your report as you seem to expect they should.
- mikeash 13y agoThere are dedicated laws for gas station drive-offs and as far as I know the police take it fairly seriously. In some states you can lose your driver's license for committing a drive-off. If gas stations managed to survive the era of ubiquitous post-pay transactions without being killed by drive-offs, you are not going to convince me that bitcoin double-spends, which are vastly more difficult to pull off than simply pulling up to the pump, pumping, and driving away, are somehow an insurmountable problem here.
- logfromblammo 13y agoIt is not an insurmountable problem, but the solution is not to let the police handle it. The police response does not prevent the station from losing money. It just prevents the same people from committing the same offense many times in a row. The reason you have to pre-pay now when you didn't before is that pay-at-the-pump points of sale make it possible to require it without losing business. Stations that had prepay-at-the-pump could lower their prices below stations that did not. The stations that did not have pre-pay did not die off because all the competition was in the same boat, using the same technology and exposed to the same risk. You can't avoid those economics. Your pay-by-BitCoin technical solution has to be the same order of magnitude time-wise on verifying the payment as credit card terminals. At the least, your transfer should be verified by the time the customer is filled up and ready to drive off. As such, the solution should probably be to take a big transaction to activate the pump, verify it while the pump is running, and issue a refund transaction for the unused amount after that verification and before the customer drives away. If the transaction fails due to a double spend, the person might still be on the premises long enough for an employee to request an alternate form of payment. Or use a coin with shorter transaction verification times.
- mikeash 13y agoOr the solution could just be to not wait for validation. Yes, it will mildly increase fraud, and thus costs, but evidently not a huge amount. It could make bitcoin-gas more expensive than the regular kind, but so it goes. Given the difficulty of carrying out a real double-spend attack, I doubt it would happen with any sort of frequency.
- logfromblammo 13y agoAs long as no other BitCoin-accepting pump can devise a better solution, whatever solution you have that works as well as a credit-card-accepting pump should be just fine.