2 ms·
The problem with the platinum rule is that we have no clear and unambiguous language for advertising how we would like to be treated. In _This Alien Shore_, by
by logfromblammo 13y ago
The problem with the platinum rule is that we have no clear and unambiguous language for advertising how we would like to be treated.
In _This Alien Shore_, by C.S. Friedman, one planetary culture, the Guerans, is essentially a human colony, but one where gestational biochemistry has been mutated to the extent that every adult exhibits at least one type of human mental disorder. They adapted by adopting a system of face markings so that people don't make simple but potentially dangerous mistakes--like hugging someone with an autism spectrum disorder, or holding eye contact too long against someone with a dominance disorder.
The point is that you would really have to either put extensive research into the preferences and personalities of everyone you know, or everyone would have to write key information across their foreheads every day.
Our society, lacking a dire need, does not care to invest in that level of effort and openness. It is far easier to follow the silver rule (don't do things you don't like to others) and the golden rule (do for others what you would like them to do for you), because those do not require extraordinary knowledge of other people's preferences.
In the age of social network oversharing and augmented reality, perhaps we can run an application that will superimpose another person's preferences over their faces automatically. But for now, the platinum rule is going to be pretty hard to use outside the bounds of your own family.
- zentiggr 13y agoOne of my favorite stories... the Guerans always fascinated me as being just a little more forward about displaying personality traits. I have never been quite as strict as Dr. Masada about my external world, but I do definitely share some of those core feelings. Always wish I could get my wife to read it so she could see Masada and maybe draw some helpful parallels. Alas, she reads very little hard SF.
- jrs235 13y ago"we have no clear and unambiguous language for advertising how we would like to be treated" Which is why being actively assertive is a good choice to make. Not sure how someone wants to be treated then ask them. What if the don't want you to ask them? Then they should have been actively assertive and wore a sign/shirt that says "Don't ask". (I realize that doesn't help the blind). Also, perhaps we should rephrase "how someone wants to be treated" to "how someone prefers you to act toward them"?
- logfromblammo 13y agoBut that wastes time in comparison to the interactions of two people who both subscribe to the same prenegotiated etiquette.