3 ms·
The question is whether higher education should perpetuate pre-existing socio-economic disparities, or seek to compensate or overcome them. The vast majority of
by snowwrestler 13y ago
The question is whether higher education should perpetuate pre-existing socio-economic disparities, or seek to compensate or overcome them. The vast majority of educators believe in the latter.
Thus they need to see beyond the present circumstances of each applicant and discern which will be most likely to excel, taking into account the impact of their 4-year educational process.
Some students from great backgrounds will fail to keep up in college. While some others who come from disadvantaged backgrounds are able to "catch up" and pass others in achievement by the end of college.
How can they predict those outcomes in advance? That's the question that the SAT and ACT were created to answer, and now we're finding that they don't actually answer it better than alternatives. In part because it is becoming clear that there is more to success in life than how well a person solves word problems.
- gdwatson 13y agoCan you provide more background on your statement that the SAT and ACT are not achieving the goals for which they were designed? My suspicion has been that things are changing because aptitude tests are unpopular for socio-political reasons rather than for any want of predictive power.
- snowwrestler 13y agoBasically, the tests were supposed to provide an objective means to predict student outcomes. But they are no better predictors than high school grades alone. And the scoring shows significant correlations with factors like gender, race, language, family income, etc.--so they're not objective. From this article: > The University of California, Berkeley1 economist Jesse M. Rothstein has found that the combination of a student’s high school grades and demographic information predicted first-year grades in college about as well as her high school grades and SAT scores do. > DePaul is implementing their own tests for non-cognitive skills, with a series of essay questions. For the entering class of 2012, about 10 percent of applicants (or about 5 percent of the freshman class) chose not to send ACT or SAT scores. Instead they completed four short-answer questions, designed to measure their leadership skills and their ability to meet long-term goals. Systematically scoring the responses to those questions, DePaul reported that the freshman-to-sophomore retention rate was almost identical for those who submitted standardized test scores (85 percent) and those who did not (84 percent).