3 ms·
I don't think that even really captures what Gabriel was getting at. The example he uses in the paper is from operating system design, where doing the "right"
by scott_s 17y ago
I don't think that even really captures what Gabriel was getting at.
The example he uses in the paper is from operating system design, where doing the "right" thing was too hard to implement. The "wrong" way is simpler to implement, and you get your OS written faster. Your OS now has a documented design flaw, and people have to work around it - but everyone does because you got your OS out first.
That is, he was more addressing design choices made when solving a problem. The full discussion is in his paper. It starts with the sentence "Two famous people, one from MIT and another from Berkeley (but working on Unix) once met to discuss operating system issues.": http://www.dreamsongs.com/WIB.html http://www.dreamsongs.com/WIB.html
- gruseom 17y agoIt's in fact hard to capture what Worse is Better was getting at, because it's sort of incoherent. I've tried 2 or 3 times to understand it over the years and concluded that, beyond the most general point (which you describe well, I think), it's not clear what he's really saying. I noticed Rich Hickey said this the other day, as politely as one possibly could: The arguments made in Worse is Better are very nuanced and I'm not sure I understand them all. http://www.computerworld.com.au/article/313989/-z_programming_languages_clojure?pp=2 http://www.computerworld.com.au/article/313989/-z_programmin... By the way, Dan Weinreb has an interesting piece in which he reveals that he was the MIT guy and Bill Joy the Berkeley guy: http://danweinreb.org/blog/the-worse-is-better-idea-and-the-future-of-lisp http://danweinreb.org/blog/the-worse-is-better-idea-and-the-... I recommend Kay Schluehr's comment on that page, which argues that arguments like WiB are drawing overly general philosophical conclusions from instances of success or failure in the market.
- scott_s 17y agoI think Richard Gabriel himself demonstrated that the points were nuanced, if not outright elusive, by writing a rebuttal to the essay with the title "Worse is Better is Worse" under the pseudonym Nickieben Bourbaki. Gabriel's full account of the essays he's written is on his website: http://www.dreamsongs.com/WorseIsBetter.html http://www.dreamsongs.com/WorseIsBetter.html
- gruseom 17y agoI went through a phase of reading all that stuff a number of years ago. Gabriel has a seriously pompous side, which I eventually couldn't bear any longer (probably after spending time and money tracking down his "Patterns of Software" book and then discovering how dreadful it was). But the piece you link to is refreshingly free of all that... until, amusingly, the last sentence, as if he falls off the wagon at the very end. I don't begrudge him for being unable to make up his mind whether he agrees with "worse is better". There are disadvantages to both approaches. But there's no need to be a drama queen about it ("One fellow was seriously nervous that I might have a mental disease") or inflate it into an artificially large "philosophical" question.