16 ms·
So if I understand this correctly, the casino alleges: 1. The casino was using cards which, when viewed edge-on, were not rotationally symmetrical. (A separate
by Terr_ 13y ago
So if I understand this correctly, the casino alleges:
1. The casino was using cards which, when viewed edge-on, were not rotationally symmetrical. (A separate complaint against the card supplier.)
2. Over multiple rounds of play, as players handled the cards, they rotated them to encode a high/low value before returning them to the dealer.
3. The players requested an automatic shuffler so that the cards rotations were not randomized by the shuffling process.
4. Players observed the edges of the "shuffled" card stack to determine whether incoming cards were high/low, using this information to improve their odds.
- ryan0x00 13y ago5) profit you understand it correctly.
- lowboy 13y agoThat was my understanding as well.
- ronaldx 13y agoMinor technical correction: Players are not typically allowed to handle the cards in punto banco, so would have needed the dealer to turn the cards for them. This, I understand, is one reason they preferred a Mandarin-speaking dealer. Sometimes you're given the option to deal out the cards yourself, but this would be more likely to break Ivey's careful edge sorting. If it was offered, I would strongly tend towards declining it. Other thoughts: Traditional card counting might still have been useful, assuming only the top card would be readable. Finally, this is only what Ivey has admitted to. I politely suggest that there are other ways of getting an advantage.
- dlss 13y agoThis. A previous article stated that Ivey and his friend talked the dealer into rotating some cards (6s 7s 8s and 9s) prior to the first shuffle.
- gojomo 13y agoI don't think any dealer or casino would agree to a total re-orientation before the first shuffle/game. My impression from prior coverage was that the rotation occurred as the cards were revealed during play, so that on each next shoe, more and more (potentially all ) of the intended cards were reversed.
- ronaldx 13y agoThe way dlss suggests is the safest and most sensible way. Usually you'll start play by breaking the seal on new decks which will be fanned out to check them: it's effective and efficient to get the dealer to turn a few sequences of cards here while they're still in the right order. Otherwise, you have a lot more work to convince the dealer to rotate the cards one-by-one: "rotate that 9 of clubs, not the other 9 of clubs" is way more suspicious. Having said that, it is a bit surprising that "dealer collusion" spidey-senses were not tingling. This is the first thing that casinos should watch out for. Maybe they realised something was going on but couldn't figure out what, or how it would be effective, in time.
- gojomo 13y agoSure, if the dealer/pit agrees, that'd be the best way... it just seems even more blatant, and the idea the casino would comply even more outlandish. Whereas, making requests during the game, that seem a bit erratic (or triggered by in-round results, like "let's flip that one so it doesn't burn me again!"), seem like they might escape scrutiny longer.
- mzs 13y agoCards almost always come pre-shuffled in the packs that casinos use for baccarat.
- imjk 13y agoCan you link me a source to that article? Phil Ivey is perhaps the greatest living card player in the world. Do not underestimate the near autistic savant level of perception and mental capacity that he and other genius card players have. I can imagine Ivey still being able to gain an exploitable edge merely by simply recognizing the direction in which specific cards are returned into the deck.
- downandout 13y agoPlayers were not allowed to handle the cards. In this case, they were playing mini-Baccarat. In traditional Baccarat, players are allowed to touch the cards and even bend and turn them all they want, but all 8 decks are thrown out after every shoe (i.e. touched cards are never played again). In mini-Baccarat, players do not touch the cards, and the cards are reshuffled instead of thrown away. This type of scheme only works in mini-Baccarat (and Punto Banco - a mini-Baccarat variation), and the casino would only comply with the unusual requests that made this scheme possible for very big players. Casinos are very tolerant of high rollers - Caesars Palace was fined $250,000 a few years ago for allowing a man to jump up on a Baccarat table and dance before placing his bets. In this case, Ivey had an Asian woman with him, and she told the dealer that she was superstitious and asked that the dealer turn cards of certain values a different direction. That she was Asian was important because the casinos are claiming that Ivey requested that his dealers speak Mandarin Chinese, and that the instructions to turn the cards were given by the woman in Mandarin so that supervisors wouldn't hear and immediately object to the request. In any event, the dealers complied. This incredibly simple strategy apparently worked at Borgata and Crockfords in London, to the tune of over $20 million in combined winnings. Because the casino could have simply said "no," I find it extremely unlikely that the Borgata will prevail here. This was much more of a social engineering hack than anything else. Interestingly, because of this issue, casinos (at least in Las Vegas) have purchased cards with a new type of background that looks like pixelated noise - much harder to do this with.
- dfc 13y agoDo you have any links to the pixelated cards? This dancing story is nuts: > A complaint filed by the board against Caesars Palace says a customer was > playing baccarat in the high-limit baccarat room on Oct. 10, 2009. On three > separate occasions, the man climbed onto the baccarat table from his chair, > walked on the table and made a bet before returning to stand on his chair, > eventually sitting down, according to the complaint. > > On the second occasion, the player performed a dance on the table before > returning to his chair, the control board said. The three incidents took > place over a 45-minute period, according to the complaint. (I think this is what you are referring to. But it is from 4 years ago.) Link to complaint: http://gaming.nv.gov/modules/showdocument.aspx?documentid=3062 http://gaming.nv.gov/modules/showdocument.aspx?documentid=30...