5 ms·
Heh, when ever I read these I think "So why do they care?" It reads as yet another "I don't understand so it must be {wrong | criminal | crazy | bad | what-hav
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
Heh, when ever I read these I think "So why do they care?"
It reads as yet another "I don't understand so it must be {wrong | criminal | crazy | bad | what-have-you }" kind of rant. Fair enough, but focus on the 'don't get it' part not the conclusion based on non-understanding part.
If company A's stock is 100x over valued, and they buy Company B with it for 100x more than Company B is "worth" has that changed anything really?
In the dot com bubble there was a serious problem, individual retail investors who had no idea how to value a company were buying stock in those companies at what ever price the market set. The market kept raising the price and the retail investors kept pouring in money. A seriously large transfer of wealth from people who didn't understand to people who took advantage of that. Once they were no longer willing to do that, poof the market makers took their money out and left. Boom!
As long as the folks doing the buying and selling are using their own money, why should anyone get upset if they are "over paying" ? When people ask me if they should invest in tech companies I tell them no. They should invest in index funds, they are low load, maximally diverse, and resilient. So billionaires are out competing with each other to buy companies, sit back, grab a bowl of popcorn and watch the show. But why get emotional over it?
- JonFish85 13y agoI'm not in finance, so this is just my uninformed opinion. I imagine it's at least partially because this does affect everyday people, even if they're not directly investing their own money. People's 401ks & pension funds are likely wrapped up in these (at least partially). Even if you have an index fund, say tracking the NASDAQ, these huge valuations are propping it up (in the FB case). And as long as the valuations stay high, things are great. But if/when it declines and suddenly money evaporates, it can really hurt if you're depending on it for retirement / college / whatever. Even the indirect parts of it.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoThe point of index funds is they change their composition when things go south, the S&P 500 index went from 447 in the early 90s to over 1800 today. If you're investing $50/month in that you did quite well.
- bcbrown 13y agoIs there a way to invest $50/month in an index fund? All the brokerages I checked charge $5-10 per transaction, making it prohibitively expensive to set up a recurring transaction at such a small amount.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoDo you have an existing brokerage account or were you trying to set up an account just for that? When I left Sun I rolled my 401K over into a self managed IRA and my broker doesn't charge me anything to add money to it.
- bcbrown 13y agoI don't have an IRA, and my funds invested in the stock market are under 10k. I set up an account with Ameritrade, and every so often put another $1000 in, so that the $10 cost is a smaller percentage.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- marincounty 13y agoYea, It does matter. As to 401's and pensions; I hope pension managers are getting out of tech stocks like Facebook, and Twitter--just until the bubble bursts. I hope some of the Bubble Boys who make billions on naive, greedy, and professional hedge fund managers help out the millions of Americans who will be close to homeless when it does burst? Do I hold them accountable--kind of--just because of quantitative easing. And the Bubble Boys must know they really don't have the companies they claim. I know I just use FB for posting, and never used my real name. I did reserve my real name because I thought one day it might be useful, but never use the site like FB thinks I do.
- dmbaggett 13y agoThe point of the piece is that one should care because it can affect the broader economy, including lots of people who didn't personally take on any tech-company-bubble risk. Sort of like when banks overpay for, say, mortgage-backed securities. Obviously you can disagree with the piece, but it is literally attempting to answer the question you're posing rhetorically here.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoThis is the entire argument of the piece: "When he [company CEO] doesn’t [make the valuation call], bankers and lawyers run the show. Valuations are derived from spreadsheets: some figure times earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA), down to five significant figures. Never mind that many of the assumptions are bogus. The lawyers and bankers argue with the target, fudging the assumptions back and forth. But these valuations are at least tacked to something in the mortal realm." "When the UMaster does care, the deal is just a made up number that he pulls out of his, er, pocket. All caution is thrown to the wind, and the bankers and lawyers scramble to back-fit the spreadsheets and assumptions after the fact. The back-fitting occurs because everyone needs to be covered. Everyone except the big guy, that is." The author's argument is that the CEO of a company is incapable of making a reasoned value judgement about the "value" of a potential acquisition. In my opinion, what he is actually saying is "I don't understand how these guys see value, it must be incompetence." And yet, somehow, the previous "stupid" valuation (of Instagram) seems to have paid off for Facebook, not only that but they are slowly and inexorably eating into Google's tender search advertising flank. How do you value that? How does Mark Zuckerberg? So does the article really answer any question? That too is an interesting way to analyze it. He claims it in the title, gives an actual (non-Tech) mechanism (quantitative easing and near zero interest rates that are known causes of inflation), and then rambles a lot about how he doesn't get the valuations being thrown around, labels those valuations as inflationary, and then backs off and hedges like crazy with "With billionaires now as thick as blackberries (the fruit), this type of overvaluation can’t be good for the rest of the economy. Only time will tell whether these fat birds come home to roost and we find ourselves buying chicken at $500 a pound." Except that it is expected that $500 a pound chicken will come about as a result of pumping a bunch of money into the economy, so how much of that can be laid at the feet of a tech company acquisition? How about even a smidgen of a hint as to how he might separate out the impact of his two "causes" ? As you can guess I think the complete article is, as I summed it up as, "I don't get how they got these values, they must be wrong or bad or both." and while I sympathize with his lack of comprehension, I never understood how lending money to people without a way to pay it back, to buy houses even passed the sniff test, I could give you some reasoning as to why I thought it was a bad idea. Clearly you read it differently, help me understand your reading of how it can effect the broader economy?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- pkaye 13y agoAre you old enough to remember the dot com bubble and bust?
- ChuckMcM 13y agoHeh, I joined Sun Microsystems as an engineer on the Monday after they went public in 1986 :-)
- notacoward 13y agoSadly, the lesson some people learned is not that they were part of something FUBAR. Rather, it's more like "get in earlier next time and hand off to some other sucker before reality sets in"
- ChuckMcM 13y agoI'm guessing that they didn't learn that, but we may get a chance to run the experiment again. Greed is greed. Growing up in Vegas I watched as people lost their savings more than once. The thought "this time I'll stop when I'm ahead" totally conflicted with "this isn't the peak, just a bit more." I learned to diversify more (event he "bluechip" tech companies had issues in the dot com bubble) and set reasonable performance targets for my portfolio. But mostly I learned that selling when you hit your target or your failsafes is essential to keeping sane.
- notacoward 13y ago#1: opportunity cost. When all of the incentive is to create paper value, many people who might otherwise have created real value don't. Since our whole economy depends on someone creating real value, that creates risk even for people who weren't party to the transaction. #2: their money? Facebook didn't invent money. They got it by making promises to large investors and banks, who in turn got it by making promises to small fry. If 90% of the people whose retirement money went into WhatsApp don't believe that's a reasonable decision and wouldn't have condoned it if they'd had any choice, somebody got defrauded. It doesn't matter whether it was a series of little deceptions or delusions instead of one big one. The people who will be left holding the bag most certainly do have the right to sound warnings and issue complaints.