4 ms·
Hate that you are getting downvoted, as I think this is actually a discussion that needs to happen. Many people will have a hard time distinguishing these tech
by taeric 13y ago
Hate that you are getting downvoted, as I think this is actually a discussion that needs to happen. Many people will have a hard time distinguishing these technologies. Especially on paper.
My take is that this camera will have some major advantages in shutter speed and quickly taking successive pictures.
As an example, at my child's soccer practice, it is not uncommon to fire off about 5 shots in any 2 second interval. It is also not uncommon to have 4 of those shots be out of focus. Heck, all five.
This camera could solve that. The phone solution fails, as I can't take that many pictures that quickly.
Right?
- dingaling 13y ago> This camera could solve that. The Lytro still needs to be focused; the trick it uses is to focus to the hyperfocal distance as you zoom, and then it can capture the equivalent of focus stacking fore and aft of that point; but only on a finite number of focal planes ( fewer than 6 if I recall ). So... your photos could end-up being nearly in focus, but also lacking in detail ( low-res sensor ) and blown-out ( poor dynamic range ).
- taeric 13y agoThat makes sense. I'd be curious to know of any wiggle room available in that regard. Seems it would be nice to do a few focal points that are "close" to each other near where you are focused, combined with a few far away ones. If that makes sense. Would make it possible to do sort of HDR images from a single shot, right? And, regardless of that, this still goes a much farther way towards "solving" this problem than the camera phone. Right?
- slantyyz 13y agoThe simplest solution to your soccer practice photography dilemma is to get a camera that can focus quickly enough (or maybe to learn how to zone focus). There are many cameras that can do this, but the problem is that none of them are a smartphone.
- taeric 13y agoAs I noted in the sibling post, I have a decent enough (I think it is a dang good one, actually) camera for this. Right now, I just need more practice with my tools. We have only done three practices, my daughter is only four. :) The example was more to get an idea of what this could help with. In short, if you are taking pictures of things in motion, or multiple shots in succession, the camera app that was recently displayed is nigh useless. Right?
- georgemcbay 13y agoThe 5D Mark II is an awesome camera in a lot of ways but it has fairly slow autofocus speed for a camera in its class. It is outpaced quite a bit by even "lesser" (more consumer oriented) cameras like the 70D (though as with anything this is a trade-off since the 70D is a cropped-sensor, so IQ not quite as good under ideal situations, worse low-light performance, etc). Here's a photo I took a couple of months ago with the 70D, one of a series of 5 that were all pretty well focused (considering the subject was a cheetah running at nearly full speed) using the "AI Servo" autofocus mode: http://i.imgur.com/jMOKZk0.jpg http://i.imgur.com/jMOKZk0.jpg (To be fair, such photos still aren't exactly point and shoot on my 70D, you have to be fairly decent at panning at that speed) You do have a point though in that the current situation for me is needing to have multiple cameras (70D for fast action, Sony A7 for relatively still shots with very high image quality, Canon EOS M for carrying around everywhere). I don't think this Lytro comes anywhere close to changing that situation, though computational imaging in general will probably solve the issue eventually.
- taeric 13y agoYeah, I don't fully understand the tradeoffs yet. I know that it has much better noise level than my last rebel. And the full frame sensor is very nice. (Though, now I want a good 50mm lens). I'm definitely game for any advice I can get. I hate that I let that example detract from the discussion, which is for average photographers, something like this could help a lot. Doesn't sound like it is fully there, yet. But it is promising. Especially in tandem with the app idea. Exciting times are ahead for getting folks into photography.
- slantyyz 13y ago>> As an example, at my child's soccer practice, it is not uncommon to fire off about 5 shots in any 2 second interval. It is also not uncommon to have 4 of those shots be out of focus. I'm not sure Lytro's necessarily the right the solution for this either, at least not today. I know I'll get laughed at and mocked for saying this, but I bought an inexpensive Nikon One camera for a very similar use case. I got tired of carrying my DSLR around on doggie play dates, and while the Nikon One may suck at an incredibly long list of things, the one thing it still does better than just about every other mirrorless camera out there (even with the Fuji XT1 and Sony A6000 now on sale) is AF on moving subjects. It can track a dog running towards me (the hardest part about AF in this use case) just about as well as my DSLR. If you don't believe me about the moving subject AF, Thom Hogan agrees: http://www.sansmirror.com/articles/autofocus-systems.html http://www.sansmirror.com/articles/autofocus-systems.html
- taeric 13y agoOh, I should have made this clearer. I have not used this camera. I have tried my camera phone in frustration a few times, but I am usually only happy with the shots I get from my DSLR. To the point that I picked up a used 5D Mark II. I'm very happy with this camera, but getting focus on far away shots with a zoom can be difficult. Solving that would be nice. Which is why I think this conversation needs to happen. I'm not sure what the benefits are. I'm just not dismissive, either. Nor do I think the camera phone will completely destroy the DSLR any time soon. (I do think it will eventually happen. Maybe not the camera phone, per se, but camera sensors could advance such that having many different cameras will be for novelty more than utility.)
- slantyyz 13y agoOk, that's clearer. The 5DMKII isn't going to win any awards in AF speed (it is still a great camera, imo) but you can do some stuff to mitigate your issues. Try shooting with a smaller aperture to get more depth of field, and consider learning how to manually zone focus. If you know the distances for which your lens is "in focus" for a particular aperture, and can evaluate how far away your subjects are, you might get better results. I think this is how they did this in the "good old days". It is more work, requires learning (I think it's a useful skill, but that's just me), but if you've got AF limitations and don't want to throw money at the problem (i.e., get an MKIII), it doesn't hurt to try.