3 ms·
> I mean, your first reply to my commentary was specifically against me saying that there are multiple factors in criminology. No, my first reply was that the
by gwern 13y ago
> I mean, your first reply to my commentary was specifically against me saying that there are multiple factors in criminology.
No, my first reply was that there very clearly was a high fit to the data, and so something is going on that is in need of explanation, be it lead or another confounding factor, and so it was nonsense to claim that it was nonsense that a single factor could matter.
> I've also presented graphs of Australian violent crime that don't appear to follow trends in each other, let alone the supposed 'lead-free' crime reduction that this theory presents.
I don't see any links, so you haven't presented anything. Here, have some graphs of preschool lead vs lagged crime in Australia: http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/35338/1/MPRA_paper_35338.pdf http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/35338/1/MPRA_paper_35338.pdf
> Exactly how many different factors do I have to present to potentially explain variability? To suggest that it's more than one factor that has a significant effect on crime?
You should present something. Otherwise you're engaged in know-nothingism: 'it could be something else! who knows? whoooo knooowwwwssssss...'