3 ms·
It's hard to sympathise with Airbnb if the facts as presented in the article are accurate. It is against the law in New York City to rent out an apartment for
by Silhouette 13y ago
It's hard to sympathise with Airbnb if the facts as presented in the article are accurate.
It is against the law in New York City to rent out an apartment for less than a month, a 2010 measure meant to curb unregulated hotels. [NY Attorney General] Mr. Schneiderman says 60 percent of Airbnb rentals in New York are illegal.
If that is the case, then it seems entirely reasonable for the legal authorities to seek the identity of those offering those rentals and prosecute them. These people aren't "regular New Yorkers", as Airbnb claim, if they're regularly and systematically breaking the law.
It might not be a good law in some people's opinion, but the correct solution for those people is to make a case for better laws, not to break the existing ones and just hope they'll get away with it.
Then, a few years ago, Silicon Valley had a collective insight: Better to ask forgiveness than permission.
Maybe not so much, as it turns out that laughable arguments about being a new category of "microentrepreneur" operator that is neither person nor business and is therefore somehow outside the law are treated with the contempt they deserve by the legal authorities.
In a blog post, Airbnb said the regulators’ plan was to accuse Airbnb hosts in court “of being bad neighbors and bad citizens.” It added: “They’ll call us slumlords and tax cheats. They might even say we all faked the moon landing.”
Indeed, it's hard to imagine why people who say things like that don't get taken entirely seriously.
I'm all for disruption, and I sympathise with the little guy start-up trying to compete against big guy established players, but that's the game. You don't get to win by just ignoring the rules. This summed up the whole situation for me:
Micah Lasher, Mr. Schneiderman’s chief of staff, fired back that “being innovative is not a defense to breaking the law.”
- GVIrish 13y agoYes it's hard to feel sympathy for Airbnb when they openly flout the law then ridicule regulators whose job it is to uphold the law. These guys are ignoring the law because it is profitable to them, not because of a fundamental belief that the laws are unjust and they're doing the "right thing" by breaking them. Why are they any different than any other business that ignores the law for profit? Seems a bit like Youtube's playbook back in the day where they turned a blind eye to rampant copyright infringement so they could secure a big exit. Or even Uber right now that has been skirting taxi laws. The 'grow fast, law be damned attitude' might be good for getting rich quick, but can also permanently damage some nascent business models.
- orky56 13y agoIf the majority of your users are engaged in illegal activities, then you are encouraging such activity. There's a huge difference between YouTube and illegal torrent sites. YouTube takes the necessary actions to ensure that copyright material is not put up in the first place and definitely taken down when there is a complaint. Illegal torrent sites have a hands-off policy, which naturally encourages illegal activity. So the question is have all these sharing economy companies done everything in their control to prevent illegal activities? Right now they are caught red-handed for not holding up their end and refusing to divulge the negative information.