6 ms·
I think the real problem is that Reddit's core mod tools are pretty woeful and age-old problems haven't been fixed. /r/modhelp is basically full of the same pr
by bane 13y ago
I think the real problem is that Reddit's core mod tools are pretty woeful and age-old problems haven't been fixed.
/r/modhelp is basically full of the same problems and issues that mods have been having for years.
Some examples:
* Want to run your sub without downvotes? Sorry (you can hide the button via css, but people can still hotkey it)
* Have a sockpuppet downvote brigade screwing up your sub? Message the reddit admins and hope they bother reading your message and doing anything about it. Because you have no idea who's doing it and can't really do anything about it. Current best advice is (this is not a joke) "wait for them to get bored".
* Somebody was granted admin access, kicked the rest of the mods off and has turned the sub to private (and the sub creator is incommunicado?) Tough luck.
* Want to delete a sub I created? Too bad.
* Fuzzed numbers, votes, subscribers, current people on the sub, etc. Some mods don't want it in their sub. Too bad.
* want to ban some URLs from your sub? try and use the spam filter, but good luck otherwise.
and on and on.
I think practically what the sub's admins wanted to do was to just push down submissions on certain topics so a wider variety of things floated up, this happens on here all the time. But Reddit's tool set to do the same is pretty ham fisted. It's like changing the battery on a watch using a mallet.
Given the choice of using the mallet or not, they decided to go ahead and use it, I disagree with this and they're suffering the consequences of it.
- DanBC 13y agoThe only times I had to contact the admins (sex pest approaching children; sub linked to from other sub causing massive brigading) I got quick responses that took action. The sex pest was banned from Reddit; his sock puppets were banned. (I hope, but do not know, that the admins reported him to one of the law enforcement agencies. He was pretty clearly unpleasant and definitely breaking US laws). I had worse experience when I tried to report stuff to Tinychat, who appear to ignore their own TOS.
- arbitrage 13y agoYou got quick action because the admins faced a legal and monetary penalty for not acting. And reddit has gotten massive bad press in the past for attracting kiddy fiddlers. If their necks aren't on the line, casual neglect and indifference seems to be the overriding M.O. from the reddit admins.
- bane 13y agoI've also had next to zero response from the admins on a few issues as well. My guess is that arbitrage is right, there was a legal issue they needed to address. But for run of the mill issues like downvote brigades, good luck getting anything useful out of them. I've usually just gotten something to the effect of "we're too busy for this" or "tough luck" The bigger problem is that mods should have log access themselves to up/down votes so they can root out bad behavior on their own and then have the tools to deal with it. Mod powers are incredibly slim on reddit and they arguably shouldn't be.
- sillysaurus3 13y ago(Using asterisks makes it a little hard to quote you. You may want to use - instead.) - Want to run your sub without downvotes? Sorry (you can hide the button via css, but people can still hotkey it) Downvotes have been in Reddit's DNA since the beginning. This is a reasonable stance. - Have a sockpuppet downvote brigade screwing up your sub? Message the reddit admins and hope they bother reading your message and doing anything about it. Because you have no idea who's doing it and can't really do anything about it. Current best advice is (this is not a joke) "wait for them to get bored". Good advice! What else are they going to do? You can't punish a crowd. - Somebody was granted admin access, kicked the rest of the mods off and has turned the sub to private (and the sub creator is incommunicado?) Tough luck. Maybe a way to transfer sub ownership would be good. Though if the creator decides they're not interested in the sub they themselves created, maybe creating your own and sticking a redirect message on the frontpage is in order. - Want to delete a sub I created? Too bad. A sub isn't merely property of those who created it. It's community property. Personally I think even being able to set a sub to 'private' after it's been created is too much, because it's equivalent to a delete. People shouldn't be able to delete the hard work of a community. - Fuzzed numbers, votes, subscribers, current people on the sub, etc. Some mods don't want it in their sub. Too bad. If Reddit were to show the actual number of upvotes per post, people might feel a little daunted. Right now people think a mere 2,000 upvotes are all that's needed to get to the front page of a default sub, rather than the more realistic 80,000+. They may lose interest the same way most people aren't interested in the presidential elections: they feel their vote doesn't matter. - want to ban some URLs from your sub? try and use the spam filter, but good luck otherwise. AutoModerator seems pretty good for this, isn't it? I think practically what the sub's admins wanted to do was to just push down submissions on certain topics so a wider variety of things floated up, this happens on here all the time. But Reddit's tool set to do the same is pretty ham fisted. It's like changing the battery on a watch using a mallet. I don't know why this story keeps floating in regards to /r/technology, but this isn't it. Some moderator of /r/technology, when responding to censorship claims, responded roughly "Reddit is a place for cat pictures and insulting people. Stop getting so worked up." They didn't take their job seriously, and no one could do a thing about it. That's what pissed people off, and it became pretty clear there was no accountability internal to their mod team.
- 13y ago
- baby 13y ago> * Somebody was granted admin access, kicked the rest of the mods off and has turned the sub to private (and the sub creator is incommunicado?) Tough luck. Reminds me of the takeovers in IRC (quakenet). There are so many channels/subreddits that admin can't deal with all the problems.
- bane 13y agoYeah, it's the same phenomenon. Reddit should make administering all the little fiefdoms the responsibility of the mods and should only have to step in under extraordinary circumstances. But right now they're needed for relatively trivial/banal/stupid issues constantly and it's been that way for too long.
- dredmorbius 13y agoThere are a lot of limitations to subreddits, so long as they're public. You _do_ have the option of creating a private subreddit, which limits exposure to certain behaviors. I agree that stronger subreddit controls would be useful. All I can say is that reddit serves a function, it doesn't serve all functions, and the site's resources are limited (reddit itself isn't profitable). That said, I've found it useful as a space in between a discussion site and a blog with a personal subreddit on which I tightly monitor and manage activity. Doesn't keep the downvoters from showing up occasionally. The automoderator bot is supposed to make a lot of automated mod tasks much easier.