4 ms·
Yes, it does. This is to keep politics and other crap out of the site. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6120530 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=61205
by davidw 13y ago
Yes, it does. This is to keep politics and other crap out of the site.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6120530 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6120530
- Zigurd 13y agoThe "It's politics" thing is so very bogus. Snowden's revelations set off a broad distrust of US tech products and services and have a multi-tens-of-billions impact on the tech economy and investing. Whoever can fix this will make a more valuable contribution to tech than a smart watch or smart TV ever will. Questioning whether Tim Cook is capable of running Apple is OK because he didn't help start disastrous wars, but questioning the thudding tone-deafness of putting Condi Rice on the DropBox board is "political?" Or is it sensitivity over DropBox acquiring some YC companies? Because the politics of it is so intractable, it is very likely that the privacy issue will have a large technology component. That is, mass surveillance will be reconsidered only when mass surveillance isn't valuable. Overall, the biggest threats to tech and investing in the US are the surveillance/security state, over-militarization, wars, and the things like education they prevent being properly funded.
- zanny 13y agoI agree on this. But there is a distinction between tech news that involves government, and debating politics. The Snowden revelations and its ilk aren't the product of theoretical agenda debates between differently minded political ideologies,they were reality. And I wouldn't consider a discussion on what the (as an example) US government does to be politics, it is when you get into the "what the government should do under this hypothetical situation" theory that you approach a line. But then that still leaves the entire spectrum of tech related policies that would cause tremendous damage or benefit, which is still heavily tech related, at least as much as "is Samsung going to use OLED or IPS in their next smart phone".
- tptacek 13y agoThe fact that you just started a pointed, partisan political subthread in an otherwise boring metathread isn't at all evidence that HN should avoid politics. No, I don't see how anyone could come to that conclusion.
- Zigurd 13y agoPartisan? Which party do you think I registered for? You will almost certainly get it wrong. I am all for making money. I am not for wishing away problems, which many people here seem to think will work: if we wish hard enough, we can make believe we have privacy when we have none, so that we can continue to sell both "security" and "forensics." Pick one and go with it.
- wpietri 13y agoGreat point! Technology doesn't influence politics. Politics doesn't influence technology. And the way technology happens certainly isn't political. Ugh.
- davidw 13y agoDid you read the comment I linked to? Politics is way more important than anything we discuss here, by and large. You open the floodgates, and it'll crowd out articles about Erlang's concurrency vs Node.js. Few people care about that, but everyone has an opinion on things like abortion, gun control, health care systems, gay marriage and so on.
- Zigurd 13y agoWhat floodgates? We had a wave of "chemical weapons rotting in the Baltic Sea" posts this morning. WTF does that have to do with tech? Apparently the filters didn't recognize those as OT. And yet, HN survives.
- davidw 13y agoIf there weren't a lot of moderation going on, as well as flagging by wary users, HN would have long ago gone to the dogs.
- dang 13y agoHN does not have only to do with tech and startups. That's the reason why PG changed its name from "Startup News" ages ago. Chemical weapons in the Baltic Sea are an example of something (potentially, at least) interesting that might well be at home on the site. (Why there were two stories is a separate issue.) Another example is the Chinese irrigation system from the third century BC currently on the front page. Such a story is emphatically on topic for HN. Political stories aren't necessarily off-topic either. However, they come with the risk of degenerating into flamewars that violate HN's values. We can't afford to let that happen very much because it will change the community for the worse. How do we know that? Because it already has. The question of "politics on HN" is not primarily about defining what is/isn't on topic. It's empirical and practical: under certain influences, the site degenerates badly. Therefore, lessen such influences. We have a good definition of "degenerate": to violate HN's values. And we know what our values are: intellectual substance and personal civility. (The other thing we talk a lot about is signal/noise ratio, but you can derive that from the other two.)
- belorn 13y agoWhile that is good and all, maybe it would be more in the hacker spirit if they did it open an transparently. If reddit isn't destroyed by this move, maybe HN can survive too.
- davidw 13y agoIt's fairly transparent, but the exact triggers are not always disclosed; otherwise it'd be easy to bypass some things in a fairly trivial way.