5 ms·
Do not HN also use a very similar list? I know they don't get deleted, but I remember their position decaying faster compared to threads without those keywords.
by belorn 13y ago
Do not HN also use a very similar list? I know they don't get deleted, but I remember their position decaying faster compared to threads without those keywords.
- baby 13y agoI know a lot of domains get deleted directly. HN uses a heavy moderation, way heavier than reddit, and it works.
- falcolas 13y agoFor some definition of works. I come here from hckrnews.com, which displays all submissions in chronological order, and it surprises me how much very interesting stuff gains 20-30 upvotes and still falls off the front page before older content with similar upvote counts. Of course, it's ycombinator's web site, so it's their choice, but a lot of interesting articles and discussion are just... lost.
- baby 13y agoWhen you have one post every minute in /new it is inevitable that a lot of interesting articles will get lost.
- falcolas 13y agoI'm not talking about /new, I'm talking about articles which received a non-trivial number of upvotes (enough to land on the front page in the first place), which are pushed off the front page while an older story with an identical, or lower, number of upvotes remains on the front page. Whatever the mechanism, good posts and discussions are being lost.
- dang 13y agoCan you provide some examples of such very interesting stuff?
- Houshalter 13y agoI don't think that's true. I have showdead on and very few comments and articles are dead. Reddit has a lot of moderation, you just don't usually see it because it's done in secret.
- minimaxir 13y agoHN has a penalized domains list. (one such penalized domain is medium.com -- stop writing posts there if you want your post to hit the front page) [0] Unlike /r/technology, it's still possible to hit the front page with a submission from a penalized domain, it's just much more unlikely. (will only really happen on the weekends when it's a slow news day) [0]: http://www.righto.com/2013/11/how-hacker-news-ranking-really-works.html http://www.righto.com/2013/11/how-hacker-news-ranking-really...
- ZenPro 13y agoWhy is Medium penalised?
- minimaxir 13y agoBack in its heyday (Summer 2012), Medium submissions had a very low signal-to-noise ratio, with everyone jumping on the pseudointellectual bandwagon, with a high dose of pseudo. Nowadays, the number of medium.com submissions is lower, but the ratio of quality remains the same.
- ZenPro 13y agoThanks for that. That seems a shame because my only exposure to Medium is the quality posts that actually are shared to me or make it to the first/second page of HN. I had assumed the quality of most writing on the platform was quite high.
- minimaxir 13y agoAnd that's where the confirmation bias and halo effect come in. :P Many startups use Medium to do the same low-quality content marketing that they could do with a normal Wordpress blog, but most Wordpress blog don't have giant header images and a serif typeface.
- tzs 13y agoThere is also something beyond just penalizing domains. I tried submitting a link to something at chess.com and it was immediately marked dead. I emailed the admins, and found out that chess.com submissions were indeed banned from HN. They said that they unbanned it, and told me to go ahead and submit the link again. I had, by the time, decided that the story wasn't actually all that interesting, so never did resubmit it.
- davidw 13y agoYes, it does. This is to keep politics and other crap out of the site. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6120530 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6120530
- Zigurd 13y agoThe "It's politics" thing is so very bogus. Snowden's revelations set off a broad distrust of US tech products and services and have a multi-tens-of-billions impact on the tech economy and investing. Whoever can fix this will make a more valuable contribution to tech than a smart watch or smart TV ever will. Questioning whether Tim Cook is capable of running Apple is OK because he didn't help start disastrous wars, but questioning the thudding tone-deafness of putting Condi Rice on the DropBox board is "political?" Or is it sensitivity over DropBox acquiring some YC companies? Because the politics of it is so intractable, it is very likely that the privacy issue will have a large technology component. That is, mass surveillance will be reconsidered only when mass surveillance isn't valuable. Overall, the biggest threats to tech and investing in the US are the surveillance/security state, over-militarization, wars, and the things like education they prevent being properly funded.
- zanny 13y agoI agree on this. But there is a distinction between tech news that involves government, and debating politics. The Snowden revelations and its ilk aren't the product of theoretical agenda debates between differently minded political ideologies,they were reality. And I wouldn't consider a discussion on what the (as an example) US government does to be politics, it is when you get into the "what the government should do under this hypothetical situation" theory that you approach a line. But then that still leaves the entire spectrum of tech related policies that would cause tremendous damage or benefit, which is still heavily tech related, at least as much as "is Samsung going to use OLED or IPS in their next smart phone".
- tptacek 13y agoThe fact that you just started a pointed, partisan political subthread in an otherwise boring metathread isn't at all evidence that HN should avoid politics. No, I don't see how anyone could come to that conclusion.
- Grue3 13y agoYes, the difference is, most HN readers aren't stupid enough to complain about this. Or just remember how terrible the site was when every other article was about NSA/Snowden.
- bane 13y agoIt does, but for obvious reasons (access to the source and effectively a single "sub"), the HN mods have a much finer degree of control over how this works. From "decay a tiny bit faster than normal" to "complete ban"
- dang 13y agoThere is such a list, but there is almost nothing on it. At this point we could probably get rid of it, since it was only created when the site was being overwhelmed—I mean front-page-entirely-about-one-thing overwhelmed—and that deluge has since receded. From that, you can probably guess the entire list. :)