5 ms·
My argument is really that the notability guideline in general serves no constructive purpose on Wikipedia; everything useful that it purports to do is covered
by ubernostrum 17y ago
My argument is really that the notability guideline in general serves no constructive purpose on Wikipedia; everything useful that it purports to do is covered by other policies or guidelines, which leaves only the non-useful things it does, like cause flamewars.
- tptacek 17y agoThe notability guideline supports the non-negotiable verifiability principle. In the absence of WP:N, the amount of random content on WP rises. With it, the amount of difficult-to-verify content. With that, the amount of blatantly false content. The burden of weeding out that content falls on people who could otherwise be improving articles on subjects of note. I think something people miss about WP is the fact that, at the end of the day, all the articles on this massive free volunteer project are published under an encyclopedia's masthead. It really is an actual encyclopedia. It's not the Internet. If something survives in WP, it's supposed to be good. The project is fundamentally opposed to bogus articles; in fact, the project is about not having bogus articles.
- ubernostrum 17y ago"In the absence of WP:N, the amount of random content on WP rises. With it, the amount of difficult-to-verify content." Absolutely not. The difference would be as follows. With the notability guideline, ten million monkeys bang on their keyboard: "Delete, NN" "Delete, NN" "Delete, NN" "Delete, NN" etc. Without the notability guideline, the same ten million monkeys who are already reviewing these articles at least enough to type a brief vote in a discussion will bang out: "Delete, not verifiable." "Delete, not verifiable." "Delete, not verifiable." "Delete, not verifiable." While the latter requires more keystrokes (and thus in aggregate represents significantly more effort on the part of the monkeys), it is otherwise not distinguishable in purpose or effect from the former. At least, it isn't distinguishable so long as WP:N is only used for articles which cannot be verified by referring to reliable sources (hint: that's a bad assumption to make).
- tptacek 17y agoThat argument isn't just false, it's prima facie false. In the WP:V case, some articles are stricken for being nonverifiable. Others are kept despite being nonnotable. Wikipedia is now charged with the task of maintaining and article about Thomas Ptacek. That article is fine right after the AfD, of course. But 3 months later, it claims that Thomas Ptacek is the inventor of ketchup salt. Some WP volunteer has to catch that and scrub it out. That overhead doesn't exist in the WP:N encyclopedia we have today, because a Thomas Ptacek article wouldn't survive AfD for notability reasons. This problem is the whole point of WP:N.
- ubernostrum 17y ago"But 3 months later, it claims that Thomas Ptacek is the inventor of ketchup salt. Some WP volunteer has to catch that and scrub it out." And with the notability criterion, lots of WP volunteers have to spend lots of time trawling AfD and typing "Delete, NN" over and over and over again. Meanwhile, unverifiable information pops up and must be removed from articles about notable subjects just as much as non-notable subjects. So how, precisely, does Wikipedia save effort under this plan? Or, more accurately, why do you believe that more effort is involved in: "Nominated for deletion due to: not verifiable/does not cite sources" than in: "Nominated for deletion due to: not notable/does not assert notability" In both cases, research must be done by multiple volunteers to assess the claim and come to a decision. But in one case the criterion is relatively objective; in the other it's an invitation to highly-subjective flamewars.
- tptacek 17y agoBecause WP:N cordons off a whole huge swath of human knowledge and says WP doesn't have to bother keeping articles about it accurate; it can just be removed wholesale from the encyclopedia. WP says, Pokemon yes, Thomas Ptacek no. Pikachu must be yellow, not green, but it doesn't matter if Thomas Ptacek invented ketchup salt, because WP doesn't have to cover it. I feel like you're kind of having to go through contortions to avoid this fact, James.
- 17y ago
- njharman 17y agoDeletionist rational that makes sense. "not having bogus articles" that one statement is causing me to seriously doubt my inclusionist position.
- Kadin 17y agoAt what cost are you prepared to hold the "no bogus articles" line? Some of the deletionists are very far into 'burning the village in order to save it' territory. I.e., they're so obsessed over "quality" that they'll snuff out anything that might even be the slightest bit questionable, erring on the side of removing things. That strikes me as stupid and needlessly destructive. If bogus articles creep in, the solution is to correct them and move on. The obsession over Wikipedia's "reputation" is likewise misguided. Unless the entire concept of "an encyclopedia anyone can edit" is abandoned, it's never going to be a totally reliable source, and users will always have to be cautioned to fact-check before depending on the information. Outside of the Wikipedia community, this is pretty much taken for granted. The best compromise solution I can come up with would be to periodically 'fork' the WP articlebase, and let the deletionists go to town on the fork, honing it down into some subset of the working version, which users could then choose to browse if they wanted something with a slightly higher barrier to entry. However, my guess is that very few casual WP users actually care.
- tptacek 17y agoI don't think your logic holds. The fact that it's "an encyclopedia that anyone can edit" is why deletionism is a healthy force. If the deletionists let up, and WP spiraled out of control with vanity articles, it would likely stop being an encyclopedia anyone can edit. Again, I think people personalize this. The good deletionists don't care about you or your subject. It's the project they're sticking up for, not the non-notability of Trevor Blackwell. When the topic of debate is Trevor Blackwell, they'll lose. When it's Ketchup_salt, they'll win. There certainly are bad deletionists. A lot of them. But I don't think that's a symptom of deletionism. I think it's a symptom of editing-as-sport and status-seeking, and that those are the problems that are really poisoning WP.
- 17y ago
- gojomo 17y agoUnfortunately "improving articles on subjects of note" (as well as arguing notability) requires more contentious editing/lawyering compared to "developing new articles on marginal topics". The lawyering is exciting for one kind of old-hand contributor -- but turns off many others. So optimizing for "improving articles on subjects of note" may paradoxically serve to make total editor attention more scarce, and waste more of it on low-value disputes and incremental refinements. "Why bother," a newbie or loosely-attached casual contributor might ask, "when all these busybodies keep marking subjects of interest to me for deletion, and mangling prose with obsessive footnotes (or requests for same)?" !#@!@^% deletionists are ruining Wikipedia. They'll be the first against the wall when the revolution comes.