3 ms·
> In general, people who bring themselves to power tend to be extremely competent. Traditional classical Greek "tyrants" had a deserved reputation for solid, ef
by rat87 13y ago
> In general, people who bring themselves to power tend to be extremely competent. Traditional classical Greek "tyrants" had a deserved reputation for solid, effective rule, but things would quickly fall apart after they died.
Millions of famine deaths under Stalin are attributed to some mix of malice and incompetence. I am not saying that he was totally incompetent. He helped usher in a ton of industrialization that helped the Soviet Union win WWII. He was also quite good at ruling through fear. But the utter incompetence of the agricultural collectivization makes me unable to label him competent on average.
- thaumasiotes 13y agoThis is a fairly general issue if you're looking at "competence". Without disagreeing with anything you said, let me ask the following: Assume you're going to collectivize agriculture. How well do you think that will go? What's the best achievable outcome?
- AnimalMuppet 13y ago"Competence" might mean that you don't collectivize agriculture...