11 ms·
Piketty's claim is that, in a capitalist system, wealth disparity increases over time (measured in currency). I don't think he presented enough evidence to mak
by wyager 13y ago
Piketty's claim is that, in a capitalist system, wealth disparity increases over time (measured in currency).
I don't think he presented enough evidence to make that statement without a lot of qualifiers, but for now, let's just assume that it's correct.
What Piketty absolutely failed to account for is that capitalism's greatest strength (and even Marx thought this) is that it causes the marginal utility of currency to decrease over time.
That means that even if the dollar gap between rich and poor is bigger today than it was 200 years ago, the actual quality of life gap is just getting smaller and smaller.
A billionaire can afford caviar and ten lamborghinis.
A thousand-aire can afford hamburgers and a used civic.
The billionaire is not a million times better off, and every year, as brutal market forces push the development of better and cheaper technology in every field, the difference between the rich man and the poor man, measured in the quality of food, goods, and services they have access to, gets smaller and smaller. For the most part, billionaires can only buy more of the same thing that almost everyone has access to. The rich guy can buy a harvard education, and the poor guy can buy a cheap but effective online education. The rich guy can buy a gold-plated iPhone, and the poor guy can buy a cheap Android. It's all the same stuff, just with different levels of class.
Compare that to not so long ago when only the rich had cars, refrigeration, electricity, etc.
- DerpDerpDerp 13y agoAdvanced medical treatments, robotics unavailable to the average person, space flight, the ability to avoid pervasive surveillance, a greatly disproportionate ability influence politics, etc. There are lots of things you have access to by having a great deal of wealth that are simply unavailable in even a reduced form to the average person.
- tptacek 13y agoA homeless person in the US today has access to better health care than the President of the US did in, what? 1960? 1970? Maybe 1980? Are we really down to "lobbying power" and "spaceflight"? That seems like a weak argument against capitalism.
- RestlessMind 13y agoHow about having all of the following, only because you were lucky enough to be born to rich parents and no other reason: - better parenting - better education - better nutrition - better accommodation - better connections and countless other advantages over 99% of other people? Kids of billionaires having all that, and kids of poor people having nothing of that, seems to me the biggest injustice and the strongest argument against capitalism.
- tptacek 13y agoWhy must an income gap mean that only the rich have good parenting, education, nutrition, and housing? Which of those benefits can you allocate exclusively to the wealthy in an argument backed by evidence? Poor school districts spend enormous amounts of money on students. In the span of half a century, we've moved from a society where the poor lacked electricity to one in which families below the poverty line have air conditioning, a car, and Internet access. His argument is that this is a result of price pressure caused by increasing competition driven by a need to keep capital invested in order to achieve the 'r' that Piketty talks about.
- RestlessMind 13y agoI admire accomplishments of capitalism - like material progress enhancing lifestyles of everyone, or lifting millions out of poverty. But that was not the main thrust of my comment, which talked mainly about "injustices" caused by unchecked inheritance. If you want an example of the benefits allocated to wealthy, here is one - opportunities. I believe billionaire kids have a lot more opportunities in life compared to middle class kids, let alone poor ones. Edit: tptacek, since I cannot reply to you, I will reply here - one example of what poor people won't have access to "tomorrow" compared to rich people : ability to be rich. And I already explained the advantages of being rich over being poor are already (food/health/shelter/education/...). And yes, your questions certainly helped clarify my thoughts, so thanks :)
- tptacek 13y ago
- RestlessMind 13y agoI disagree with you. "The rich guy can buy a harvard education, and the poor guy can buy a cheap but effective online education" And what is the outcome of having Harvard education against having cheap online degree? I am sure Harvard graduates come way ahead of graduates of online universities, both in private job market as well as in influential government positions due to "cliques" and "networking". But the problem is much deeper than whether you can afford high quality commodities or not. Those with excess capital can accumulate assets, and then rent out those assets to those without capital. If this sounds too abstract, consider a concrete example - bay area housing market. Only those with capital can afford houses. Those with excess capital can buy additional houses and rent them out to those who cannot afford housing. Net result? The ones who cannot afford houses now have to keep paying rent to those who could, thus making homeowners richer. Piketty has elaborated this in detail. But the most salient question he raised was that inequality, per se, is neither bad or good, but whether it is justified? Today, Bill Gates or Mark Zuckerberg have billions more than I do. But I am OK with that because they took risks, invested their efforts (and yes, also got lucky). But I am don't think someone like Alice Walton or Paris Hilton deserve their billions - in their case, all they did was just to be born to rich parents. And they and their heirs are going to have a better life (education, nutrition, accommodation, entertainment, connections...) than almost everyone else. Why? Doesn't seem "justified" to me. Edit: Why the downvote? And while I respect your freedom of speech (to downvote), I am sincerely interested in knowing your counterarguments.
- tptacek 13y agoYou're missing his point a little bit. He acknowledges that the rich will keep getting richer, and places like Harvard will continue to act as gatekeepers. But the intrinsic value of education will largely be available both to the rich and the non-rich. The credential and social signal of Harvard won't be, but the actual learning of things will.
- RestlessMind 13y agoActual learning is only one of the multiple aims of college degree. One aim is also to improve career prospects in terms of better job opportunities and networking. And for that, Harvard has vast advantage over cheap online education.
- andrewfong 13y agoI think you're underestimating exactly what a billion dollars gets you over a thousand by several orders of magnitude. It's not about iPhone vs. Android. It's about having enough money to never need a phone vs. being unable to afford a data plan. It's not about caviar vs. hamburgers. It's about never having to cook vs. malnutrition from not having access to fresh produce. It's not about Lamborghinis vs. Civics. It's about having a ready replacement whenever you get into a wreck vs. losing your job because your car stalled on the freeway and you were late to work. It's not the physical goods but intangibles that makes a billionaire a million times better off than the thousand-aire. Some particular intangibles: Time. The billionaire never has to work again for the rest of his or her life and be assured that he or she has sufficient resources to not starve to death. Not so with the thousand-aire, who is likely living paycheck to paycheck. Freedom. If the billionaire does want to work, he or she can work on whatever he or she wants. Paris Hilton can be a singer / actress / celebrity because she wants to be that. If Paris Hilton was not a wealthy heiress, I think it's safe to say her career choices would be significantly more constrained. Influence. The political aspects of this are somewhat obvious, but it extends to practically everything else as well. The thousand-aire says, "It sure would be nice if my team won the championship this year." The billionaire can all but guarantee it.