3 ms·
There are reasons besides environmental ones to encourage use of biofuels (hopefully made from more than corn). One is that ~10% less oil has to be imported du
by mixmastamyk 13y ago
There are reasons besides environmental ones to encourage use of biofuels (hopefully made from more than corn). One is that ~10% less oil has to be imported during production shortages.
It's not a complete solution, but a minor part of one.
- gscott 13y agoMy wife started using E85 fuel her gas mileage went from 22mpg to 17mpg. Even though there was a subsidy on the fuel she ended up having to purchase more. She has since switched back to regular fuel.
- mixmastamyk 13y agoThe math is a bit more complex than 10% and why I put the ~ there.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- stephen_g 13y agoYeah, I did a project on this sort of thing in Uni with E10. We found that the few cents less it costs per litre at the pump was not enough to pay for the extra fuel you had to buy to make up for the fact that there is less energy in the fuel (this is in Australia - pretty sure that we have subsidies here too). It was a few years ago, but I remember looking at research saying something like it not being really sustaiable (despite being renewable) because it requires too much energy to produce it for what you get out of it.
- dredmorbius 13y agoBiofuels simply aren't scalable to any appreciable fraction of present-day petroleum utilization in advanced industrial nations. For crop-based fuels such as ethanol, productivity is well below 100 gallon/acre. Scale that to the billions of barrels of oil consumed annually, and you'd need several times the present-day arable land of the US to produce the fuel used now. Looking at primary productivity worldwide, humans already consume 14% of all plant growth. Our fossil fuel utilization would be another 21% of this, according to Jeffrey Dukes in "Burning Buried Sunshine", a 2003 paper (http://globalecology.stanford.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_ClimChange1.pdf http://globalecology.stanford.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_ClimChange...) I see some promise in the US Navy Research Lab's electricity-to-fuels project, using seawater as a feedstock for both hydrogen and carbon. That could scale to national levels of production with only a few square km of plant, and about 40,000 km^2 of solar arrays (about 200 km on a side). Given alternative proposals for fossil fuel replacements, it's vastly further into the plausible space. For some ballpark numbers: • Conventional crop biodiesel or alcohol typically cite about 100 gallons/acre-year • Typical algae biodiesel yields are 10x that, or around 1,000 gal/acre-yr • I've seen claims of 10x that, for 10,000 gal/acre-yr Assuming that last is possible, you'd need 124,000 km^2 (350 km on a side), or 30 million acres (about 7% of present US cropland) to supply all present petroleum use. That's a very highly engineered 350km square, mind, with a bunch of goop that needs to be fertilized, wastes removed, protected from pests, harvested, dewatered, and processed. Some incidental biofuels utilization? Sure. Most of our fuel from it at present volumes? Not gonna happen.