7 ms·
Nuclear plants release less radiation into environment than coal plants (2007)
- iprashantsharma 13y agoholy fuck, I am working in power plant.. what should i do? this is insane! Fly ash, bottom ash, coal ash every thing is here.
- evanb 13y agoThe dose you receive is very likely negligible compared to your other routine activities. http://xkcd.com/radiation/ http://xkcd.com/radiation/
- ch4s3 13y agoI love that chart, I always show it to people who are afraid of Nuclear power.
- subdane 13y agoLearn to code?
- ams6110 13y agoIf you read the article, you would know that your exposure is a small fractional increment over normal backgroud radiation exposure.
- m1 13y agoDid you just read this on the Guardian too?
- ch4s3 13y agoNo, I saw it on reddit, and though it might be HN worthy, despite the bad headline. I'm not sure how meaningful the dose of radiation is, but the comparison it super interesting.
- personZ 13y agoIgnore the "waste" element of the title and understand that they're saying that if you're living in the shadow of a nuclear power plant, and everything operates ideally, you'll undergo less radiation than near a coal plant. Which is quite reasonable. Yet the waste of nuclear plant isn't the harmless water vapours coming out of cooling towers -- which is what this article bizarrely focuses on -- but instead the used fuel that will need to be contained and managed for tens of thousands of years. Further the fear of the nuclear industry isn't ideal situations, which is manageable, but situations like Chernobyl and Fukushima Daiichi: The "super promise 100x never going to happen triple safeguard" sort. A single major incident suddenly undoes much of that good many times over.
- hga 13y agoWell, civilian reactor "waste" is potentially very valuable stuff, but we're rather stupid in our approach towards it. And the "tens of thousands of years" is grossly overstated, at least if you apply the metric that after 600 years it'll be no more radioactive than the ore from which it was mined. The Chernobyl RBMK design is criminal, and literally so in the US, where Edward Teller made sure reactors with positive void coefficients were outlawed (one reason we don't do CANDU, although the proposed Advanced CANDU reactor addresses this). The Japanese demonstrated long before Fukushima Daiichi that they don't have a nuclear safety culture at the level they should be allowed to run serious reactors, and that incident prompted me to look at boiling water reactor designs for the first time, and I don't like them at all. Yeah, the above is in danger of the No True Scotsman fallacy, but we have heck of a lot of counter experiences, including the pressurized water reactor worst case incident at Three Mile Island which harmed no one and was never in serious danger of doing so. As for what you poise as a bizarre focus, every coal plant in the world is pumping out a lot of nasty stuff, they're inherently dirty, and totally cleaning them up is not in the cards. As in, right now, every day one is running, it's potentially doing harm....
- personZ 13y agoAnd the "tens of thousands of years" is grossly overstated, at least if you apply the metric that after 600 years it'll be no more radioactive than the ore from which it was mined. http://www.ccnr.org/hlw_graph.html#gr http://www.ccnr.org/hlw_graph.html#gr EDIT: Some have penalized me under the notion that hga's "apples and oranges" comment was a retort (despite the fact that the chart also has concentrated uranium near the bottom). It is not. HGA is apparently unaware that uranium tailings are effectively worse than uranium ore, containing 85%+ or the original radioactivity of the ore, but concentrated and exposed. If you had the choice between holding a handful of uranium ore or uranium tailings, you'd do better to choose the former. There are a lot of grossly misleading claims from the pro-nuclear lobby, one of which is that if you only count the product of fission (and not the actinides), and you compare it against post-processed yellow-cake, it's all the same. In no universe is it equivalent to naturally existing uranium after 600 years. every coal plant in the world is pumping out a lot of nasty stuff, they're inherently dirty But despite the ridiculous lead-in to the linked article (no, the common notions of nuclear power does not come from the Simpsons), everyone knows that coal is dirty. Most areas are phasing it out (here in Ontario we have effectively eliminated coal power, from it comprising 25% of our power not too many years ago). Is nuclear power the best alternative? That's dubious, not only because of "exceptional" events that yield enormous ecological damage, the waste product that we just push to future generations, and economics that seldom make sense over the life of the project.
- notahacker 13y agoIf ever a headline deserved to be changed from the original statement on HN, it's this one. Not only is it linkbait, it's also a lie. Even the footnote introduced by the publisher admits the headline is, at best, misleading. Sure, it's true, in a trivial sense, that nuclear waste when stored in a manner that effectively shields it from emitting radiation into the surrounding environment emits less radiation into the surrounding environment than a relatively benign substance emitted indiscriminately into the surrounding environment. If the article were trying to claim that coal dust in itself was particularly harmful that might still be an interesting comparison. But as it is, for those of us that know that properly-functioning nuclear plants don't pump nuclear waste into the surrounding atmosphere but do create storage hazards, it's about as insulting to the intelligence as a headline claiming that shandy[1] is more likely to cause alcohol poisoning than absinthe[2] [1]ingested [2]not ingested.
- slashnull 13y ago"Coal-fired plants emit more radiation in their immediate environment than their nuclear equivalents". There. I once tried to find other facts that could support this dumb-ass title, and I was unable to. Coal mining produces a tiny tiny amount of radioactive contamination, and the amount of radiation in fly ash seems to dwarf the amount of radioactive stuff we lose in the nature because of accidents and nuclear waste storage and that kind of stuff. Even if you state that premise as "coal power has some radioactive waste issues", it's still a lie.
- afterburner 13y agoFalse dichotomy, it's not a choice between nuclear and coal. Cheap solar is here, yes, cheaper than coal even: http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/04/15/rising-sun http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/04/15/rising-sun http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/18/opinion/krugman-salvation-gets-cheap.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/18/opinion/krugman-salvation-... Not to mention any number of other renewables (wind, wave, tidal, thermal, etc...)
- TeMPOraL 13y agoCheap solar is here, but it's enough only for a small part of our energy needs. http://www.withouthotair.com/c18/page_103.shtml http://www.withouthotair.com/c18/page_103.shtml
- afterburner 13y agoThat book was written in 2009. Since 2008, the cost of solar energy has dropped 75%.
- lemming 13y agoThe cost isn't the problem (well, it's a problem, obviously, but it's not the main problem). Take a look at this chapter: http://www.withouthotair.com/c27/page_203.shtml http://www.withouthotair.com/c27/page_203.shtml. The issue is the sheer size of the installations required to provide energy for a modern country. As he says in the book - to provide renewable energy for a country, you need country-sized installations to do so. In his examples, to provide energy for the UK you'd need installations approximately the size of Wales, if I remember correctly. If you haven't read the book you really should do - it's truly excellent. He's not anti-solar or anti-renewable, in case you got that idea, but he forces the reader to be realistic about what switching to clean sources actually entails.
- afterburner 13y agoSo, you're telling me nuclear is the way to go?
- hernan604 13y agothat article is from 2007. Nowadays everyone knows NPP are the worst technology human has invented and doesnt knows how to use and decomission. See whats happening at fukushima, its killing the pacific ocean. And making a lot of seals sick in california. If you heard about it you know the details. And its only the begining because man made radiation does not go away, it stays and its bleeding radiatiation as i type.. that means years from now, it will be more acumulated. Cesium is a fission product that emits radiation. Has a half life of 30yrs and when you consume it, you body thinks its Potassium because of similarities in structure. Therefore accumulates on the muscles, specially the heart and emits radiation on closeby cells. Strontium, another fission product that emits radiation is similar to Calcium. Once consumed is transfered into the bones. Sites like enenews.com can tell better news about NPP.