3 ms·
It's interesting that many alternative energy related ideas tend to emphasize more localized facilities whilst computing moves to huge centralized data centers.
by fauigerzigerk 17y ago
It's interesting that many alternative energy related ideas tend to emphasize more localized facilities whilst computing moves to huge centralized data centers.
It gets even more ironic considering that one of the popular examples for the long term trend towards outsourcing/centralization is that auto makers stopped generating their own electricity long ago :-)
- donaldc 17y agoIn both computing and electrical power there's a tension between localization and centralization. As the technology evolves, the relative trade-offs shift. Right now, the rapid development of ever-higher-bandwidth connections tends to favor centralization of computing power (though there's still good reason for a lot of it to be localized in the laptop and cellphone). With electrical power, the economics have long been mostly in favor of centralization. This started shifting a little with the development of ever-cheaper solar panels, and would shift a lot more were any sort of effective localized power storage possible. And unlike bits, there is a transmission loss for watts. Though I'm dubious that this technology will ever see the market. When it's for sale to the consumer, then I'll know it's real.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoIf solar panels become cheaper they become cheaper for centralized facilities as well. So how does that change the equation?
- ph0rque 17y agoTransmission and distribution costs of electricity are ~30% of the total cost, so if solar panels become cheap enough, the transmission and distribution costs for centralized facilities will become a large part of the cost. Of course, if we get room temperature semiconductors by that time, those costs will come down.