5 ms·
Credit to Wells for then saying: "They understand that it is a bloody muddle, but they regard your simple class-war antagonism as nonsense." I wonder if Wells
by arethuza 13y ago
Credit to Wells for then saying:
"They understand that it is a bloody muddle, but they regard your simple class-war antagonism as nonsense."
I wonder if Wells was one of the last people to disagree with Stalin who didn't end up with a bullet in the back of their heads?
- dominotw 13y agoNo. Lots of people disagreed with Stalin all the time. Famous example being Zhukov.
- arethuza 13y agoTrue, but didn't Zhukov (perhaps the greatest general of WW2) come perilously close to being tried in the aftermath of WW2 - largely due to his personal reputation and international standing?
- dang 13y agoThe Bolsheviks cultivated celebrity visitors from the Western left. It wouldn't have worked to shoot them. (Edit: Originally this comment had a moderation bit in it as well, but someone rightly pointed out to me that it isn't helpful to wear the moderator hat and make a regular-user comment in the same post. So I've edited that out. I considered restricting myself to only making moderator comments, but (a) that's never been how HN worked, (b) I was a user long before a moderator, and (c) I'd burn out from boredom.)
- arethuza 13y agoFor what it's worth, I apologise, mostly for the initial comment I made that mentioned the Ukraine - it looked very much like a partisan comment intented to reference the current conflict and, in all honesty, it wasn't. Sorry for any grief caused and keep up the good work. [I promise to engage more brain cells when posting on obviously highly emotive topics in future and, if I have any doubt, to not post].
- dang 13y agoThanks for being so kind about it. It means a lot.
- amirmc 13y agoTwo thoughts 1. Has anyone suggested making yourself a new moderator account? eg dang_mod for all mod-related comments. It might ease the mental burden for the reader (at the cost of increased mental burden and user-switching for you - so maybe not worth it). 2. As a simpler variant of the above, why not make two separate comments? I expect readers are capable of telling apart your user comment from the moderation if they're cleanly separated. Edit: The first option would also have the benefit of a user id with its own comment history.
- dang 13y ago1. That would be easy to do, but it feels wrong to me. Not sure I can articulate why, other than that it's not the way HN has always worked. 2 is more or less what's what I'm going to do from now on.
- gaius 13y agoStalin referred to his Western supporters as "useful idiots".
- firstOrder 13y agoMaybe that's why Churchill stopped being a supporter of him.
- firstOrder 13y agoWhat happened to Fred Hampton when he disagreed with how blacks were being treated like second-class citizens in Chicago? The Kent State students who protested the US invasion of Cambodia? The Jackson State students who protested the US invasion of Cambodia? And so on...