6 ms·
I'm honestly kind of surprised how little action there has been to assist with a migration away from the CA model. The technology is there, but people just don'
by wyager 13y ago
I'm honestly kind of surprised how little action there has been to assist with a migration away from the CA model. The technology is there, but people just don't seem interested enough to leverage it.
Systems like Namecoin could serve this purpose marvelously. Powerful devices have direct access to the entire cryptographically authenticated DNS and certificate database. Weak devices can specify whom they trust to provide them with DNS/certificate data, and even those devices get some cryptographic security guarantees thanks to technologies like SPV.
- dvanduzer 13y agoThere's been plenty of action, but you can't turn the whole world on a dime. Namecoin is fantastic in theory, but has the fatal flaw of using Bitcoin: the fastest number cruncher wins. Some would argue that the strength of Bitcoin's tech is that numerous currencies with different genesis blocks can flourish. That doesn't get us anywhere with naming, though. Dead horse flog: the CA model's problem is that you can't do federated (global) naming and federated trust in the same system.
- wyager 13y ago>the fastest number cruncher wins. What's the issue with that? It's reasonable to assume that the good number crunchers will always have more power than the bad number crunchers, and if that assumption ever fails, it's easy to detect and we're simply back to CA levels of security.
- dvanduzer 13y agoPhilosophically, "good number crunchers" just means "tyranny of the majority." Environmentally, that number crunching is a colossal waste of energy. We don't need to base our entire economy on that kind of energy footprint just because we occasionally want to make anonymous global barter convenient.
- sarahj 13y agoWhy have a single entity at all? Moxie Marlinspike proposed Convergence (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z7Wl2FW2TcA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z7Wl2FW2TcA) as a solution - I think that something like that has far more potential wheels to travel than a Namecoin based system. I should be able to choose who I trust, a notary system would allow me to do just that. No central CA systems. The biggest concern I can see is Identity management, but, as mentioned by Moxie, most of these CA don't do anything close to proper Identity management any more - I have a number of certificates bought from quite a few different CA's all made out to my rabbit, at no fixed address. Notaries can, of course, do additional verification - they could even advertise this as a premium. I don't see why this can't be extended to DNS lookup's either. I trust X notaries and pin the results I get, I can choose to trust a majority, or be hyper paranoid and require everyone to agree. No need to run a power hungry blockchain, no single point of technology failure. Technically, all of that is feasible today. And I imagine we will see a number of different technologies combined to form a proper, decentralised, system.
- dvanduzer 13y agoWant to help us work on this problem at http://telehash.org http://telehash.org?
- sarahj 13y agoI remember reading something about that before. I just had a quick look around and, while I don't believe I have fully groked the concept it would seem to me that Telehash is solving a different, but related problem. The web, as a technology is probably not going anywhere for a few more decades at least - people have gotten very used to opening up a web browser - very few actually understand the technology beneath. The CA/DNS issue is one based solely around them - can I type the domain name I saw on the tv/ my friend gave me/I heard about into a web browser (and these days) and it can direct me (securely) to the page where I can do business. Telehash seems to fit in on another level. Perhaps one which we are heading towards - a world of machines securely finding and communicating with each other to achieve a goal set for them by some human actor. This space is becoming more crowded and no good contender has emerged - and I think there is a good reason - they are either too radical as so they can't find a footing, or they are too conservative. The documentation is slightly lax, but I feel telehash is the latter - it doesn't seem to be solving any problems already solved: * Space/Storage/Data Transfer - I don't care what anyone says, the blockchain model is simply no scalable, any system where are full client has to hold onto/download gigabytes of information is a non-starter for me. But still, in any new system - hopefully decentralised, we need to distribute information. Any kind of system we build must be tolerant of partitioning - I think the solution to this is injecting some trust (ala Convergence) * Speed - Computers work in nanoseconds, the web currently operates in seconds (some sites in milliseconds) - we can't beat the speed of light, but we can certainly start removing the cruft from our communications - HTML, XML, JSON, CSV - are all formats designed for people. We need tools that let us manipulate formats designed for machines. Our networking protocols are like this as well - as much as people hate ASN.1 it solved some problems decades ago allowing the phone system to scale on just duct tape and wd40 * Power - Blockchain bashing time again - we live in a world of limited, expensive power. We are getting much better at producing low power devices, people like wireless devices. Why should our networks be so power-hungry? Just a few, rambling thoughts.
- jrockway 13y agoThe migration away from the CA model is called "certificate pinning". Chrome uses it for high-value sites, and you use it whenever you ssh somewhere and the key's fingerprint is in your .ssh/known_hosts file.
- wyager 13y ago>The migration away from the CA model is called "certificate pinning". TOFU/POP is not an effective model for the web. There are simply too many sites for it to be useful. It's pretty much an everyday occurrence that I go to a site I've never been to before, and certificate pinning won't help at all there.
- tptacek 13y agoFirst, "TOFU/POP" has a real name; it's "key continuity". Second, certificate pinning as implemented in Chrome doesn't depend directly on key continuity. Third, key continuity destroys the incentive to attack sites by compromising CAs, because even if you're hitting a site for the first time, many of the 10,000 other people hitting it from the same browser at around the same time aren't, and they'll detect the bogus cert. That only has to happen once for Google to put a gun to the rogue CA's temple.
- wyager 13y ago>First, "TOFU/POP" has a real name; it's "key continuity". I am aware of both names, thank you. >That only has to happen once for Google to put a gun to the rogue CA's temple. Google can't really help in every single case. There are many situations where Google's revocation scheme can't keep up. You also have to put a lot of trust in Google. You think Google is going to issue a revocation if they're under legal pressure not to? As you are aware, human factors are frequently the weakest parts in a cryptosystem.
- tptacek 13y agoI don't understand your comment. Google doesn't revoke keys. It revokes whole CAs.
- rwallace 13y agoIf Namecoin is anywhere near as insecure as Bitcoin, it's a nonstarter. Yes, I know the cryptography underlying Bitcoin is secure, but as a matter of practical fact, Bitcoin itself as an end-user technology is hopelessly insecure. It's one thing having an endless stream of people waking up to find their bitcoins are irrevocably gone because someone hacked the computer, but we can't have domain names being irrevocably lost in the same way. Does Namecoin actually work like that? If so, is there a similar alternative that doesn't?