8 ms·
Nike fires majority of FuelBand team, will stop making wearable hardware
- nicholassmith 13y agoInteresting timing isn't it, Apple is rumoured to be making a wearables push and Nike has a cosy relationship there. Maybe they've realised they don't need to make the hardware to further their aims. Or, maybe Nike want to refine their product base and the Fuelband isn't a big enough seller to justify the ongoing cost. I think the wearables market is some what saturated at the moment and to stand out from the crowd Nike would need to make a large push. Shame as I liked their purposefully chunky aesthetics.
- interpares 13y agoNot a fortuneteller but my guess is they're giving up way too early. One of the few mass-market, non-tech companies that actually had a shot in wearables.
- k-mcgrady 13y agoWith the iPhone having the M7 built-in is there any need for the Nike FuelBand? I find data from the M7 to be quite accurate. Seems like they can just create the software and let Apple (and eventually Android device makers) build the hardware.
- Jtsummers 13y agoBut you can't always have your phone with you. It's not effective for the same use-case when you've handed it to someone else to use the phone or when you're out playing soccer (well some people might keep their phone on them on the field but I don't).
- danieldk 13y agoI use a Garmin Forerunner. Before I used an iPhone. Not only is the Forerunner a far more accurate GPS and has better battery life, it's also far more convenient to 'carry' during running, since it's a simple and compact watch. Also, it's easy to monitor your stats at any moment, in contrast to iPhone arm bands. In the end smart watches will probably eat this market. But the iPhone is certainly not a substitute.
- leoc 13y agoThe iPhone's still a heavy, bulky, expensive and fragile thing to take with you to the gym or out running, as are other smartphones. The screen is also not easy to interact with while you're exercising seriously. However, smartwatches or smartglasses with 5s-level-or-better motion sensing and the capacity to run apps independently of a smartphone do have to the potential to make dedicated fitness trackers mostly obsolete, though expense and fragility will still be concerns. EDIT: This Gruber reaction http://www.cnet.com/news/nike-fires-fuelband-engineers-will-stop-making-wearable-hardware/ http://www.cnet.com/news/nike-fires-fuelband-engineers-will-... heightens my suspicion that this is an early omen of an Apple smartwatch launch.
- userbinator 13y agostop making wearable hardware ...including shoes?
- smackfu 13y agoTotal market / large number of players = unsustainable business.
- jchrisa 13y agoOr maybe the first wave of the next set of things becoming smart. $12 phone http://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=3040 http://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=3040 means maybe we get shoe-phones after all.
- camus2 13y agoin my opinion wearables like that should look more like "classic looking" connected watches ,rather than a SciFi looking wrist band. But there is a market, definetly. the connected stuff should be a feature not the main point of the product. The point of a phone is to actually phone, all the apps/internet stuffs are features of that phone. At least that how i see how one can market these products.
- fidotron 13y agoI'm seeing this from the bottom up in other areas. The general question being asked is "Isn't this actually just an app? Do we really need the device too?" And very often the answer is it's just an app. The Google coming in factor is not to be underestimated, however, what appears to be going on there is Google effectively ensuring no one (except Apple) gets to make money on wearable hardware. Apple will steal the premium sector, again, (mix of iOS compatibility, prestige branding and likely a couple of out there features) but because Google seem to view it as a way to attach Google Now to your wrist first and potentially profitable app ecosystem very distant second they'll drive the price of the hardware down to the point Nike's decision here looks very wise indeed. The ad/search business is to Google what Windows is to Microsoft, and in order to create new profit centres they really need to forget it.
- nanowatcher 13y agoYou're reasoning is completely off. Google's Android wearables ensures nobody makes money on wearable OS i.e. software. Google has actually opened the door for companies to now make money on the wearables hardware since the software is standard. While Google launched wearable by focusing on the Now integration, there are still hints that fitness apps will be there at launch of the smartwatches. This is the first time Google and Apple are launching in a new category at the same time, it's a bit premature to conclude that Apple will capture the high-end (although they do have iOS customer captive in their ecosystem) Nike doesn't figure into this at all. The fuelband never even worked with Android devices (Tim Cook holding a spot on the Nike board for the past 9 years might do something with that). Mike's play is to get out of the wristband business before Apple jumps in while keeping their Nike+ integration with Apple via software and SHOES (Nike's real business) as done previously. However if this new upcoming Nike+ API can be used by Android devices it would represent the first real shift in Nike's strategy
- lnanek2 13y agoHonestly, Google does prevent almost anyone from making money off the hardware as well. I was at an Android OEM when Google first started sourcing their own Nexus line at cut throat prices and Android hardware projects were definitely canceled because we just couldn't compete with Google. Samsung is about the only one that can since they have massive economic advantages due to making most of their own parts. Other Android OEMs make very little numbers or profit.
- changdizzle 13y agoEven more amazing is that it was first reported on Secret a week ago: https://www.secret.ly/p/uxaztevdcicghcabkkczuzkpkz https://www.secret.ly/p/uxaztevdcicghcabkkczuzkpkz
- seivan 13y agoThis is what happens when a bunch of MBAs and Non Engienering Produxt/UX snake oils salesmen play around too much time and money. They were one of the firsts on the field, and had every chance to make something amazing, but all I saw was mediocrity. Useless features, half-done stuff. I still use Nike+... it has the the potential to be awesome. Give me their engineering staff and 1/3 of the budget.
- amirmc 13y ago> "This is what happens when a bunch of MBAs and Non Engienering Produxt/UX snake oils salesmen play around too much time and money." That's uncalled for. Engineering teams are just as capable of wasting time, money and resources. That leadership may have been at fault doesn't mean the engineers were all saints. Edit: My point is that bad leadership is bad leadership, irrespective of background. Slamming people simply for being 'MBAs' or non-engineering is ridiculous.
- rch 13y ago> Mostly because the execs committed gross negligence, wasted tons of money, and didn't know what they were doing This was my impression of how things were going even last year when they had that app development contest. It seemed a little desperate, right out of the gate.
- fudged71 13y agoSo funny. I was at a conference just two weeks ago where RGA was talking about their success with the Nike FuelBand. In reality, nobody used it and the whole team got fired. Brilliant.
- tomwilson 13y ago
- Theodores 13y agoThese gadgets might make a nice 'halo' product for a big Nike Town store, however, from a general retail perspective these fairly standalone electronic gadgets are a pain to stock, sell and process when they come back as returns. They just don't sell the units to justify the floor space or the capital for the stock. Plus there is always someone online that can sell them cheaper without the hassle of a customer cluttering the shop for an hour whilst they evaluate the purchase. Staff are not knowledgeable on such items and, in the time that one gadget is sold, that member of staff could help untold other customers on products that are core business. I am sure that Nike could take on all comers with 'first mover advantage' with wearable gadgets. They could even do a Facebook and buy out the likes of 'strava'. However, these gadgets don't sell too well through the normal retail channels that Nike rely on for most of their sales.
- napoleoncomplex 13y agoIt's surprising to see it so early, but they probably see the writing on the wall. Once Android Wear and Apple wearables start rolling out, it's going to be a slaughter out there. Apple and Nike teaming up for the iWatch launch is probably a safe bet now too.
- ben1040 13y agoWorth mentioning too that Nike has several job openings in PDX for Android engineers to work on Nike+, so clearly they're looking to shed their Apple exclusivity thus far.
- smoyer 13y agoOr perhaps their website hasn't kept up with the restructuring? On another note, why are these reports saying the engineers were "fired"? It's one thing to be let go when a project was discontinued but nobody wants the stigma of being fired on their record.
- walshemj 13y agoUnfortunetly a lot of people slopply use fired as an exact synonym for redundancy or layoffs Its not! One would have hoped that a suposedly jounalistic endevour would use correct language for fear of beiing sued for "professional slander"
- 0x0 13y agoInteresting to note that Tim Cook is on the Nike board, while iOS8 is rumored to feature a new "healthbook" type app, plus all those iWatch rumors.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Once Android Wear and Apple wearables start rolling out, it's going to be a slaughter out there. For Nike, its already a slaughter -- FitBit has the lion's share of the market for activity trackers, Nike was in third well behind Jawbone UP. [1] [1] http://mobihealthnews.com/28825/fitbit-jawbone-nike-had-97-percent-of-fitness-tracker-retail-sales-in-2013/ http://mobihealthnews.com/28825/fitbit-jawbone-nike-had-97-p...
- menzoic 13y agoTim Cook is on Nikes board...
- interpares 13y agoWhere's Carl Icahn when you need him?
- NDizzle 13y ago"Help us Carl Icahn, you're our only hope." has a nice ring to it.
- joshdance 13y agoI liked the FuelBand, but never bought one. Hopefully Nike either partners with Apple or they make an App.
- stevekemp 13y agoMe too. I've yet to find a wearable device I can take to the gym and extract the data from myself. Most of them use online sites and proprietry/undocumented storage formats.
- e28eta 13y agoI'm surprised by this. To me, it makes a lot of sense that Nike, as a fitness company, produces a wearable device for exercising. It must be a failure of my imagination, but I don't see a smart watch (in the next couple years) being both attractive to the general consumer and solving the same problems as the FuelBand does. That's partly because I can't imagine what features would make me want to buy an iWatch. So I expect that Nike's going to be forced to compromise functionality to fit the limited capabilities of general-purpose devices. For example, Craig's proposed iRing doesn't even mention tracking motion activity: http://furbo.org/2014/03/13/wearing-apple/ http://furbo.org/2014/03/13/wearing-apple/ Also, maybe it's the specific app I use, but using the M7 kills battery life on my 5S.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> I'm surprised by this. To me, it makes a lot of sense that Nike, as a fitness company, produces a wearable device for exercising. I'm not surprised -- they've been pouring money into marketing, and yet not coming within a mile of the leader (FitBit) in the activity tracker market. > It must be a failure of my imagination, but I don't see a smart watch (in the next couple years) being both attractive to the general consumer and solving the same problems as the FuelBand does. They aren't getting out because of the possibility of future smartwatches, they are getting out because they are getting killed by what's on the market and popular now.
- katchja 13y agoI would agree, but hey Apple does have the brightest people on board to make the new iWatch both sexy for the masses and extremely useful. I was looking at either Fitbit or Misfits Wearable, both extremely well designed, and one of them is coming from te "hands" of an ex apple engineer
- e28eta 13y agoDoes that jive with their stated plan to do software only? Does the FitBit hardware have an open API that Nike could integrate with? Or are they stepping back and waiting for Google, Samsung, Apple, etc, to make a successful hardware device? Whether that's things like the M7 in smartphones or an extra device.
- jbuzbee 13y agoIs it just me, or does anyone else think the term "fired" is improper in cases like this? I think the more appropriate term for when a company is changing direction, leaving a market, etc. is "laid-off". To me, "fired" denotes wrongdoing on the part of the employee. Of course, when you're trying to get page-views, Fired is likely to get more readers at the expense of the terminated employees.
- rhizome 13y agoIt's at the expense of credibility, but it's CNet. These terms have actual meanings, "laid off" when the position is being eliminated, "fired" when it's not.
- dingaling 13y agoHaving a US head-office I'm frequently bemused / confused as to why companies in that country so readily lay-off the staff of canceled projects, instead of redeploying them internally to fill other vacancies. Particularly in large corps there's nearly always some other division crying-out for staff with hands-on knowledge of their industry and product, instead of spending $50,000 to hire someone out of college and then train them.
- Philadelphia 13y agoBecause American companies don't do any training.
- osteele 13y agoI don't know the particulars of the Nike position. In general it can be because of geography (if the cancelled project was run out of a different region, which can be especially true for skunkworks or acquihired teams), or job specificity (it's not clear how many sensor engineers, low-power engineers, or even hardware and software engineers Nike needs if it's not dong projects like this).
- krschultz 13y agoMy guess is because the decision is made at a high level that a whole project is to be killed, and in order to keep that decision compartmentalized the decision is made to lay off the entire staff rather than bringing in mid-level managers to make decisions on who should stay and who should go, which would probably cause the news to leak early. It also makes it a bit better for the laid-off employees. If you keep 50% and fire 50%, the ones that got let go have a much harder sell to their next employer. If you can shrug it off and say 'the whole project got canceled', no negativity is cast on that particular employee. There is also some HR/legal things related to the difference between eliminating positions and firing people. It is easier to claim that the positions are eliminated if you axe the whole project. Then what typically happens swiftly after the lay off is the company offers to re-hire the best performers from that team immediately. I have seen that in 20 person startups and 100,000 person companies. The whole thing is always ugly. In my mind the worst part is when a company heavily recruits a top performer from elsewhere in the company or externally to come work on this project when it is 80% of the way to the cliff, generally by mis-representing the situation, and then axes the whole thing 3 months later. I have seen many people burned by that scenario.
- _pmf_ 13y agoDamn these people for executing the "vision" of some inept executive.
- mdturnerphys 13y agoI went to a meetup this week where the senior director of this program spoke. It was a little surprising to see that his bio had changed from his Nike affiliation to "innovator at large" when I got to the event, but I didn't think too much of it at the time.
- scholia 13y agoNike Denies FuelBand Shutdown, but Layoffs Could Reveal New Cracks in Wearables Market http://recode.net/2014/04/18/nike-denies-fuelband-shutdown-but-layoffs-could-reveal-new-cracks-in-wearables-market/ http://recode.net/2014/04/18/nike-denies-fuelband-shutdown-b...
- notastartup 13y agoThis is my biggest nightmare. Consumer choice being limited due to corporate politics and killing innovation for bottom line because of old school corporate thinking. Imagine working on a product, getting bought out, and seeing your hard work being dumped in the garbage because that was already their plan. Sure, you might have millions, but did you really make a change in the world? I think it would be an empty experience.
- kjhughes 13y agoUpdate: Nike confirmed a small number of layoffs but denies FuelBand shutdown, according to re/code: “The Nike+ FuelBand SE remains an important part of our business,” the company said in a statement emailed to Re/code. “We will continue to improve the Nike+ FuelBand App, launch new METALUXE colors, and we will sell and support the Nike+ FuelBand SE for the foreseeable future.” http://recode.net/2014/04/18/nike-denies-fuelband-shutdown-but-layoffs-could-reveal-new-cracks-in-wearables-market/ http://recode.net/2014/04/18/nike-denies-fuelband-shutdown-b...
- dang 13y agoAll: should we change the url of the post to this one? It's not clear which is better. Edit: there are arguments on both sides. Since the Cnet article seems to be the original source, let's stick with it.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoI would say yes. Fixing misinformation (even honest misinformation) on the front page is a good thing.
- notatoad 13y agoi don't think it's clear that there's any misinformation in the cnet article. Nike is officially denying killing the product, but they aren't denying that they've laid off the majority of their hardware team.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoIt says they will stop making wearable hardware in the title, which Nike is flatly denying.
- clarky07 13y agonot really. They said they will continue to sell the current device and support it with software. They make no claims to possibly making any new hardware as far as I could see.
- skc 13y agoHmm, so nobody has brought up the possibility of some sort of Apple + Nike collusion (for lack of a better word) here? Cook sits on the Nike board. Who's to say he didn't let the folks at Nike in on what Apple were working on and the two companies decided to make some sort of deal seeing as the two products would have areas of overlap. I can see a scenario where Nike features prominently as a partner for Apple's wearable products.
- thinkling 13y agoIt's possible that there won't be an Apple iWatch as such, but instead a platform like Google Wear for others to develop on. But such a thing is hard to keep secret once you've told a dozen partners about it.
- tnash 13y agoI wouldn't be surprised if a bunch of the laid-off employees end up working at Apple.
- sandieman 13y agoNot sure I'm totally convinced of this software only argument. I think of Nike as a brand that stands for high performance equipment. Shoes, T-shirts, Golf Clubs, etc. The software they have built around Nike+ has always felt second rate compared to software focused companies like Runkeeper. I enjoyed my Nike Fuel band and was always hoping to see more innovation on this front from them. I suppose they had to pick one or the other. This move allows them to have a fitbit software integration which will be big. I would have stuck with high performance health monitoring hardware and integrated with every software vendor.
- Splendor 13y agoI returned my FuelBand once Nike broke their promise of developing an Android app. It seems like there was a lot of confusion on the team.
- mafuyu 13y agoShame too, as it was a nice piece of hardware. You can see a great teardown and explanation of the internals from mike at mikeselectricstuff here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7xdajSS_cOU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7xdajSS_cOU
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ejain 13y agoI'm guessing Nike isn't abandoning the FuelBand (or Nike+), just their in-house hardware team. Wristbands are commodities now, so someone in management might have decided to outsource.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jmelloy 13y agoMy wife finds the FuelBand so ugly she almost finds it offensive. She's a pretty normal woman, and I'm not suggesting all women feel that way, but it bears reminding that anything worn on a wrist is actually a fashion accessory for a lot of people.