6 ms·
"thugs beating up journalists" and "afraid of being murdered by Islamic fundamentalists" fall under various laws which protect people from physical violence, or
by dalke 13y ago
"thugs beating up journalists" and "afraid of being murdered by Islamic fundamentalists" fall under various laws which protect people from physical violence, or threats of physical violence.
"when the "Ada Initiative" got that talk canceled at "BSidesSF" last year" and "I was attacked for my speech from OpenSSL defenders who want me to quietly submit bug patches rather than making OpenSSL look bad on Twitter" were not due to acts of physical violence. They are acts of social opposition.
I think it's a bad idea to mix the first two and last two as all being opposition to free speech. The "I was attacked" in the last case is indistinguishable from "I was criticized."
Not only are those latter two themselves protected under free speech rights, aspects of them also a protected under the right of free association under the same First Amendment that protects speech. ("Freedom of assembly" includes the right of free association.) A call for a peaceful boycott, rally, or protest march are completely within the letter and spirit of the First Amendment.
I believe that any essay which argues for an overriding moral basis for a more universal sense of free speech, must also argue why there isn't an equally overriding universal basis for the freedom of association. This essay did not.