5 ms·
'Just "cutting your carbs" is probably a reasonable piece of advice on an individual scale, and probably a reasonable thing for a person who is worried about th
by jerf 13y ago
'Just "cutting your carbs" is probably a reasonable piece of advice on an individual scale, and probably a reasonable thing for a person who is worried about their weight/health to attempt.'
I've been sympathetic to the low-carb explanation, especially because of its hormonal explanations, but, irreducibly, if one goes to cut out a large portion of carbohydrates that implies a number of other significant changes in diet, and there's no particular reason why "what you intended" and "what actually happened" have to line up. While I'm not immediately switching to a protein view as in this article, I'd observe there's no contradiction between "I cut out a lot of carbs and lost weight" and "I lost weight because I increased my protein intake"... one would have to approach the problem with literally clinical precision to precisely balance carb removal with fat increase, with no change in protein intake.
There's also nothing stopping a bit of both from being the case; a protein-deficient diet of over-processed foods starts a process of excessive refined carbohydrate intake, which then causes metabolic syndrome, which results in great apparent improvement if you switch to a low-card diet specifically because of the metabolic syndrome even though it may, technically, be a secondary problem. I'm not advocating for that, but I can't disprove that; it fits a great deal of what we see, it seems to me, it just isn't unique in that way yet.
(My only strong position in this debate is that the current conventional wisdom is wrong, and the Puritan-inspired attitudes about how it's "just calories" and therefore the only acceptable explanations are a shocking degeneracy in the modern human, and also tutt tutt and shame on them, are double-wrong. The real science is interesting, and still surprisingly unsettled.)