3 ms·
The best solution I have heard is from Adam D’Angelo at Quora. The idea is to grant options that are exercisable for 10 years from the grant date, whic
by x0x0 13y ago
The best solution I have heard is from Adam D’Angelo at Quora. The idea is
to grant options that are exercisable for 10 years from the grant date,
which should cover nearly all cases
That is an awesome idea, and really classy on Adam's part.
- codezero 13y agoIt's a great idea, and Adam is classy for a number of reasons, but having just left Quora, I only have 90 days to exercise my options, so it's not something Quora is doing right now, which is what the article seems to imply.
- jayp 13y agoI think you should hit up Adam and see if he can provide you with a 9-year 9-month extension. If not, you should let Sam know so he can provide an update clarification on the article. There is also a precedent for such type of clarification updates in YC family. YC founding partner, Jessica Livingston, provided a clarification with respects to Sabeer Bhatia of Hotmail vs. DFJ ventures based on the statements Bhatia made in an interview with her for the book "Founders at Work".
- JonFish85 13y agoFrom a company's point of view, wouldn't that really suck, having all of these outstanding shares in limbo? I'd imagine at least part of the 90-day thing is just so that the company knows the status of those shares. For an employee, the company is holding those out as a carrot for you: someday those shares might pay off, if you work hard. For a former employee, he/she gets 90 days to decide whether to pony up the cash for the company (who gets money in exchange for the shares), or they get the stock back to give to other employees. Having to keep track of "large" (unsure of how to quantify that) percentages of the company that might be purchased at a later date seems like a liability that the company wouldn't want to have to track, especially as a startup with other things to focus on. They're useless to the company, the only upside is for the employee.
- ProblemFactory 13y agoIs it really more difficult to keep track of than regular shares? It's easy to decide if the stock might be purchased: if the IPO/acquisition is priced above strike price, then they obviously will be bought, and otherwise will not. It is indeed not useful to the company, and a great upside for the employee. Out of all suggestions in the article, this is probably the most employee-friendly. But that's not a bad thing if it helps recruit good employees, or otherwise seems like a fair thing to do. The usual 90-day limit makes employee vesting almost meaningless. They either wait for an acquisition (and get all their options accelerated), or leave before that (and lose all of them). Few employees have enough spare cash to buy out their shares.
- bambam12897 13y ago"IPO/acquisition" that's not the only option. The company could remain privately owned - in which case you want to have below 100 shareholders so that you can remain a C corp
- 001sky 13y agoThey're useless to the company, the only upside is for the employee. Don't agree: the company already got the benefit.
- lettergram 13y agoI think 180 - 365 days seems far more reasonable. It's ridiculous to have the company shares tied up with the inability to give them back to other employees.
- rickyc091 13y ago180 / 365 will pose the issues as 90 days. I had to let go of my stocks since the price to exercise was too high when I left. I wasn't sure when the company would ever IPO or get bought. Though had it been 365 days, it would have worked out for me. My company got acquired 8 months after I had left.
- x0x0 13y agoAnd that's why options are (mostly) a scam. If you leave before a liquidity event for any reason (they may not come, they take a long time, life circumstances, poor career growth, employers like to give shitty raises), you're stuck either investing often tens of thousands of dollars into an illiquid investment while paying taxes on it right now, or giving up your options. Sweet deal for employers either way. So when they hand out those option grants they probably get to apply a 50% discount or more to exercise. Not to mention employers often try to avoid even telling employees what fraction of the total company their options represent, and definitely don't care to share their participation multiples. They're often very happy to let you think that in the case if a liquidation event, you get (exit amount) * (your ownership fraction) which just isn't true. @apta: see [1] for a numerical example. You get taxed twice (or three times if someone is stupid) on typical ISOs: 1 - on grant, if the strike is less than the fmv (there are huge tax penalties for this, both for you and your employer, so it oughtn't happen) 2 - on exercise when you convert the option to a stock, on the spread between fmv and strike (but probably amt, depending on the type of option; it's mildly complicated) 3 - on sale of the stock, on the spread between the sale price and your basis [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7611512 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7611512
- apta 13y ago> you're stuck either investing often tens of thousands of dollars into an illiquid investment while paying taxes on it right now I am not really familiar about this area. It is a one time price to pay to purchase the stock options, is that correct? Furthermore, where does tax come into play? Don't you only get taxed if you decide to sell the stocks to generate income?