4 ms·
I think of the arrow of time like this. We started in an extremely exceptional state of very low entropy. The state space is very high dimensional. Therefore th
by im3w1l 13y ago
I think of the arrow of time like this. We started in an extremely exceptional state of very low entropy. The state space is very high dimensional. Therefore the entropy is much higher, pretty much everywhere we go. In this space we do a random walk.
Now, the mystery that remains to be solved is: Why did we start with such an exceptional (low entropy) state?
- cousin_it 13y agoOne possible answer is based on complexity: we were more likely to start in a low entropy state because it had a description with low Kolmogorov complexity, or something like that. (K-complexity induces a probability distribution on the state space that is very different from the uniform distribution.) If that reasoning works, it seems to reduce the question "why did we start in a low entropy state?" to the question "why do we often observe hypotheses with low complexity to be true?", which is pretty much the problem of induction. I'd love to know the answer to that. Another possible answer is anthropic: you see an ordered universe because otherwise it wouldn't create an ordered mind like you. Unfortunately, the anthropic answer seems to predict that we're in a tiny ordered bubble that will be swallowed by chaos any moment now, so the complexity-based answer looks more promising to me.
- coldtea 13y ago>Another possible answer is anthropic: you see an ordered universe because otherwise it wouldn't create an ordered mind like you. Well, DUH. This, so called, "anthropic" answer is still a naive non-answer. It's as if those that use the anthropic priniple in this sense have a very shallow understanding of Epistemology and/or Philosophy of Science. It's obvious that the question concerns at least one level deeper than what the "anthropic principle" attempts to answer. Now just "how come" (possibillity of it being observed by an ordered entity) but "why" (actual mechanism causing this).
- madaxe_again 13y agoBecause you can't distinguish maximal entropy from minimal entropy in a closed frame of reference.