5 ms·
The article explores a few theories and none really make sense. The only theory that can explain why Yahoo can be worth $13 billion less than two of its three c
by danieltillett 13y ago
The article explores a few theories and none really make sense. The only theory that can explain why Yahoo can be worth $13 billion less than two of its three components is that the market believes that its management is so bad that they are going train wreck the group - the hp effect.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- PaulHoule 13y agoIt's great, the worst female ceos can destroy value as well as the worst men!
- danieltillett 13y agoI don't think we should be blaming female CEOs here as Yahoo and HP have certainly had more than their fair share of terrible male CEOs.
- nostrademons 13y agoI think that that's the OP's point; he's saying that bad CEOs may be both men and women. I still don't like his comment because it's bringing gender into something that really has nothing to do with gender, but a literal, factual reading of his comment makes exactly the point you do. Edit: relevant https://xkcd.com/385/ https://xkcd.com/385/
- tdees40 13y agoThe discount is presumably also due to the fact that no one in management - least of all Marissa Mayer - has any interest in making Yahoo smaller. Although this would likely be the right thing for the shareholders, it would make their domain (and thus their perceived importance) smaller.
- foobarqux 13y agoThe article explains that the whole is less than the sum of its parts because the businesses can potentially leech off each other when they are packaged together as a conglomerate ("the conglomerate discount").
- craigyk 13y agoor that the market is stooooopid
- coldtea 13y agoI hear that that's a heresy in some parts of the world that believe in the non-scientific "free market" cargo cult.
- logicchains 13y agoYes, support of the free market is non-scientific in the sense that Mainland China, Russia, Cuba, North Korea and similarly non-'free market' countries are much wealthier than historically pro-market countries like Switzerland, Singapore and Hong Kong. /s
- 1ris 13y agoYou are so scientific you don't even bother to reason about cause and effect.
- logicchains 13y agoNeither did the parent comment, so why am I the one you're calling out on it?
- 1ris 13y agoI can't see how the parent comment postulates a causality.
- logicchains 13y agoIt makes the implicit claim that people interacting freely will lead to worse outcomes under some metric then people interacting under the constraint that actions contravening some centrally determined directives result in punishment via violence or the threat thereof.
- cmsmith 13y agoTo me this idea conflicts with the fact that they are minority shareholders in the two international components. I'm not sure exactly what the management structure is, but if Alibaba really thought it might be run into the ground by Yahoo it seems that they could do something to kick Yahoo out.
- sunir 13y agoThe argument is not that Yahoo! will burn Alibaba to the ground. It's that their asset holding in Alibaba will have to be liquidated to make up for losses by Core Yahoo! That is, they might burn their stake in Alibaba to the ground.