4 ms·
I agree with OP's assessment of the enterprise world; I do not come to the same conclusions. I have been on both sides of the enterprise software sale many tim
by edw519 17y ago
I agree with OP's assessment of the enterprise world; I do not come to the same conclusions.
I have been on both sides of the enterprise software sale many times and have concluded that a) it always sucks and b) it's rarely in anyone's best interest.
So instead of examining the current model and making suggestions for accomodating or improving it, I prefer to suggest an alternative.
I believe the best way to crack the enterprise software market is the same way to eat an elephant: one bite at a time through the soft underbelly...
Find a critical business function being done in Excel and provide an alternative web app.
Find a "business within a business" and automate it with modern technology. (Examples are small independent business units, warehouses, job shops, sample shops, anything a user has set up that can be autonomous.)
Provide a modern satelite system to augment and integrate with an existing enterprise monster. (A separate module for one function like payroll or fixed assets, special processes for marketing, engineering, manufacturing, etc.) The possibilities are endless. Somebody is not getting what they need out of SAP, Oracle, or whatever.
Provide a separate business unit with everything they need. This may be cheaper than the customer adding more licenses to their ERP system.
The key to this approach is staying under corporate IT's radar. The way to do that is by keeping your prices below your customer's boss's threshold.
How do I know this can work? Because it has, many times. I have implemented dozens of apps in enterprises that they thought they could never have because of the existing software and sales model.
And I remember history. At one time, IT departments were very threatened by PC's. They challenged their ivory tower with a mainframe and dumb terminals. So users just bought their own PCs from their expense budgets and forced IT's hand.
Lightning can strike twice. Users are once again tired of waiting 18 months for a fix and are ripe for a custom 37signals type of solution. Let the app rush begin.
- run4yourlives 17y agoGreat points. I'd just like to add that the key here is to be cost conscious - i.e. cheap. One of Joel's better articles for those that haven't read it explains why: http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/CamelsandRubberDuckies.html http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/CamelsandRubberDuckie...
- jpwagner 17y agoGood article for pricing in general, but Joel doesn't seem to understand enterprise software sales. His analysis of bad idea #2 ignores ROI. This model works when there is real customer pain being solved by the application.
- run4yourlives 17y agoThis model works when there is real customer pain being solved by the application. I think the point here is that that is rarely the case. Mainly because the "customer" that buys is disconnected so much from the "customer" that will use the software that both the pain and the ability of the application to solve said pain are woefully misunderstood.
- jpwagner 17y agoSounds like you misinterpreted your customer requirements, but that doesn't mean everyone has to. If I make an investment, say in a mutual fund, I am "using" my money even if the mutual fund is "using" my money. The "use" in each case is different, but the value needs to align with the buyer. If a child wants candy, it's up to the candy manufacturer to realize that they have to sell "healthy" candy, because the buyer is the parent. But the parent "uses" the candy in giving the child a treat, making them happy, and not hurting their health. That has to come across in the marketing.
- akeefer 17y agoThe most difficult part here is probably around integrations. As you point out, piggy-backing on some existing system is one way to make that easier, but it makes it hard to replace core parts of the system, and it makes the SaaS model far less attractive. I think it's a great idea where it can work, but you're not going to replace the SAP/Oracle deployments themselves that way, or the legacy mainframes.
- edw519 17y agoRight. Until the economy sours and vice presidents look to cut budgets to save their asses. Once one of them asks, "Why are we paying $100K per month in Phoenix when we have almost the same thing running in Cleveland for $10K?" That's when you have to be ready for a "corporate mandate".
- thomaspaine 17y agoI had an experience like this in college. A friend of mine worked as an administrative assistant and his job was to take a PDF that was several hundred pages long, and go through page by page and save it into several hundred individual pdfs based on one or two variables. I wrote a python script to do this for him, wrapped a gui around it, and compiled it into an exe (this is how I taught myself python by the way). We sold it for $200 a piece to a couple of the departments at our school. When we went to the oracle rep to talk to her about automatically integrating this into the system's workflow, she told us that this feature already existed. Maybe it did, but apparently nobody knew about it or how to use it. We probably could have pursued it further, but then I graduated and moved across the country.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]