8 ms·
dang and kogir tuned the algorithms to make some downvotes more powerful. We've been monitoring the effects of this change, and it appears to be reducing toxic
by jseliger 13y ago
dang and kogir tuned the algorithms to make some downvotes more powerful. We've been monitoring the effects of this change, and it appears to be reducing toxic comments.
That's interesting to me because I find myself downvoting much more often than I used to. But the comments I downvote are not that often toxic in the sense of being nasty. They're more often low-content or low-value comments that don't add to the conversation.
The jerks and trolls are out there but I'm not positive they're most pernicious problem.
- Siecje 13y agoWhen do you get the ability to downvote?
- arjie 13y agoOnce you get 500 karma, you are able to down-vote (with certain restrictions).
- chavesn 13y agoYes, the restrictions are interesting -- I've personally noticed (corrections/additions welcome): - Cannot downvote comments in threads older than 24 hours - Cannot downvote comments in response to you
- dang 13y agoThe threshold has been 500 karma for years. We've got some ideas for lowering that, actually.
- ajiang 13y agoI wonder whether being able to downvote makes you a more thoughtful commentor. Perhaps run an analysis on quality of comments (maybe as simple as avg. karma per comment) 400 to 500 vs. 500 to 600?
- cbhl 13y agoOne of the things I noticed was that when I was just over the threshold I was more choosy about downvoting because each downvote reduced your karma by one (so over-zealous downvoting would result in you losing the ability to downvote).
- jamesbritt 13y agoI don't think I've ever seen this. I don't downvote all that much but my karma seems to stay the same if I do.
- tlb 13y agoBeing on both sides of the table is always instructive. I'm sure voting has made me more thoughtful. Hours spent considering comments that combine a useful insight with snarkiness and deciding whether to up- or down-vote them has made me lastingly less snarky on the internet.
- Mz 13y agoPerhaps not a good thing to admit: I have a couple of handles* on HN. One of them is this one, which has enough karma to downvote, and the other has too little karma to downvote. After being really thoroughly raked over the coals for a time, I began mostly logging in under my other handle in part because some people had been really horrible to me and I found myself going "YOU ARE AN ASSHOLE -- DOWNVOTE!" I didn't like interacting with the site that way and was also worried it would have negative consequences for me personally, especially since pg was not handling things in a transparent manner and there was no clear, easy way to get with a mod and sort anything out. I returned to active use of this handle at a point where I was less bitter and also the culture seemed less toxic and I no longer felt like I was just being consistently shit on, all the time. So that isn't an issue for me anymore. And my main point is that moderating is a human thing. Karma and other technical tools are just that -- tools. There are no magic solutions. Algorithms and what not have their uses but we are all human and building community is more about how people treat each other and making judgment calls and all that then about any specific technical anything. * This is not a secret and there is no reason to believe they cannot be readily connected to each other -- it was not done to fool anyone here, it was done for other reasons.
- dbloom 13y agoIt's actually 501. (I spent a few days at exactly 500 wondering why I couldn't downvote yet...)
- dang 13y ago(> (karma user) downvote-threshold*) Right you are.
- danford 13y agoIs HN open source?
- benaiah 13y agoNo, but dang's a mod, so he has access to the source code.
- alecdbrooks 13y agoIt was open-sourced at least two years ago[0]. I believe it hasn't been since to prevent gaming of the system, but I don't remember where I heard that. [0] Based on this handy Github repository: https://github.com/wting/hackernews https://github.com/wting/hackernews Original: http://arclanguage.org/install http://arclanguage.org/install
- roghummal 13y agoSo security through obscurity? "Hacker News" always struck me as a misnomer. "VC-Startup-MBA-someone-will-come-post-interesting-things,because-the-site-is-simple-and-you-lynx/links-using-weirdos-love-that-shit-and-maybe-we-can-capitalize-on-that News" There we go. It's cool seeing how the other half lives but there's a reason I don't usually comment here. HN comments are on par with Slashdot (now, not then). This post gives me the impression that a foamy circle-jerk is the _objective_.
- chavesn 13y agoAre you saying the are not as pernicious because they are not as common? I down vote the same as you, but I would hesitate to assume that the algorithms are tuned one way or the other. In reality it's probably more about velocity or even the voter. I have noticed the absence of low value comments near the top (except in fresh threads) so to me, it's working.
- PaulHoule 13y agoI think the hardest behaviors to manage are the marginal ones, such as the mechanical turk who calculates how little work he can do and not get kicked.
- pitnips 13y agoI think he's agreeing with the absence of low value comments near the top but suggesting that comments that may add value are being forced from the top.
- pg_is_a_butt 13y agoPG IS A BUTT
- whiddershins 13y agoI am very circumspect about downvoting, and rarely do it as I am still unsure of the criteria. I rarely have the opportunity to downvote vitriol and trolls, as others have usually done that and there seems little point in piling on. I personally have a much higher threshold for comments which are worded aggressively, sarcastically, or humorously. I occasionally find myself upvoting comments which have been downvoted by the community due to "tone," if I think the core statement has a bunch of validity. Where I am most tempted to downvote is statements that repeat sticky memes that have been repeatedly disproven, but "sound true" within areas I have the most expertise, especially when they are presented as fact. Those kinds of comments lower the bar more than any other, IMO, by forcing a debate over whether the sky is in fact blue every single time the community attempts to discuss weather patterns and cloud formation. However, it is unclear to me whether that is valid criteria for downvoting, so I rarely even do that. TL;DR I am unsure when to downvote so I mostly don't.
- ritchiea 13y agoI tend to downvote when someone is mean spirited, overly pedantic or takes the discussion off topic in an unproductive manner. Or if it appears that the commenter has not read and considered the comments/article that preceded his/her comment.
- vacri 13y agoThe criteria for downvoting is simply "do you feel like downvoting". pg stated a while back that it is perfectly HN-acceptable to use the downvote as a mere statement of disagreement. I haven't noticed any forum staff mention otherwise. I've seen downvotes on my comments even when they're neutral statements of fact ("dang is a moderator, recently announced" got a downvote from some HN denizen). Most people seem to follow the criterion you lay out though. Ultimately if a good comment gets a downmod that makes it less visible (why, oh why, does only one single downmod do this?) someone else usually comes along and 'corrects' it back to normal visibility.
- pbreit 13y agoSome original guidelines suggest it was ok to down vote for disagreement but I'm not sure "perfectly acceptable" would be the best way to put it. And more recently I believe he was even less encouraging of the practice. My own view is that down voting should never be used for simple disagreement (as long as argument is decent and good faith).
- illuminate 13y agoYeah, lower-content posts, narcissists, etc. I find more harmful in watering down the content than the obvious trolls or "cruel" posters, which don't tend to last as long. The community is nice, but I'd rather focus on the interesting comments and stories I wouldn't see on any other site.
- roghummal 13y agoYou might be holding on to 'outdated' definitions. Here they are as they stand now: Troll: Disagrees with individual or community. No/little/inadequate attempt to soothe egos potentially damaged. Toxic: Disagrees and presents an alternative that is dangerous to the ego of the individual or community. This comment is now considered "trolling" and I, a "troll". Edit: An especially correct "troll" (as above) can be promoted to "toxic" without presenting an alternative if the disagreement is particularly damaging to the ego of individual or community.
- illuminate 13y ago"Troll: Disagrees with individual or community." It's not that they disagree or "hold an unpopular opinion", it's how they express said opinion. Some people can champion unpopular opinions in insightful and interesting manners. Others are kneejerk contrarians and collect opinions that are likely to get themselves the negative attention they seek.