3 ms·
UK Pirate Party registered as politcal party
- tome 17y agoSee also this Q&A: http://www.pcpro.co.uk/news/interviews/350728/q-a-why-the-uk-needs-the-pirate-party http://www.pcpro.co.uk/news/interviews/350728/q-a-why-the-uk...
- philh 17y ago>Q How do you respond to the counter argument that research costs are huge and patents help companies protect their investment? >A We're not trying to stifle innovation, what we're trying to do is set a legal framework that says 'okay, you can take a picture from the road, but pointing a camera at my bedroom window, that's not such a good idea'. Google Street View's a really good example of this. People were up in arms, saying 'no this shouldn't happen, yes it should happen'. We want to see laws in place before it happens, rather than after, so everybody knows where they stand. That doesn't answer the question at all. I hope this doesn't become a trend with them.
- _pi 17y agoThey are politicians, nonanswers are part of the game.
- jacquesm 17y agoI personally sympathize with most - but not all - points that the pirate parties of Sweden and the UK make, but I can't help it that I think that the name they've chosen ('pirate') is one of the worst names they could have picked. Traditionally politics is a game of words, if you enter the game with one leg tied to the other it is not going to help at all. Being a 'vertical' (single issue) is hard enough, to add a voluntary stigmatization to that does not help. Piracy is uniformly seen as negative, the 'opposition' (MPAA/RIAA) are the real pirates here, but they actually get the moral high ground for free this way.
- ErrantX 17y agoI know what you mean. With that said I think that one of the reasons it is that way (a game of words) is because all the players use the same rule book. I often wonder whether a party with a different approach would appeal to voters: I guess this is testing the waters a little :)
- tome 17y agoI think the party will get more votes with a name like "Pirate" because it's automatically assumed the party is not a full political party, but a single (or very few) issue pressure group. It will get free advertising in the form of media publicity this way.
- jacquesm 17y agoThe usual fate of a single issue party is that as soon as it starts to attract voters away from more mainstream parties they will update their programs to reflect the discontent felt by the voters, and like that the ideological element of the single issue party gets 'adopted' (some would say hijacked) by others. Then the voters will flock back, and hopefully some real change is enacted.
- swombat 17y agoThat would be pretty much ideal. If that happens, then the Pirate Party will have served its purpose.
- JonAtkinson 17y agoI agree with your point, but consider the 'Hacker' in 'Hacker News', that has very negative connotations in mainstream language (thanks, media industry!), but the type of smart, gets-things-done people who use this site can see through the language at the values behind it. Exactly the kind of smart, gets-things-done types who can make a difference in politics, I'd imagine.
- tome 17y ago
- jgrahamc 17y agoIt's sad that their FAQ only addresses the 'pirate' part of their name. http://www.pirateparty.org.uk/wiki/index.php5?title=Policies_FAQ http://www.pirateparty.org.uk/wiki/index.php5?title=Policies...
- jgrahamc 17y agoIt's worth reading Richard Stallman's piece about how the Pirate Party's position on copyright is damaging for the Free Software movement: http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/pirate-party.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/pirate-party.html
- sp332 17y agoMaybe we should institute copyleft as a first-class right, instead of hacking the copyright system.
- tome 17y agoSince the Pirate Party's proposals are never going to be enacted in law (or at least not without allowing a great deal of time for various interest groups to comment) I don't see that this will be a practical issue. It is interesting, though, to read Stallman reiterating that copyleft depends on strong copyright!
- swombat 17y agoFor what it's worth, I signed up, and registered as a member (that costs £10). That's not only for the file-sharing aspects of things, but also some of their other declared aims: • End the excessive surveillance, profiling, tracking and monitoring of innocent people by Government and big businesses. • Ensure that everyone has real freedom of speech and real freedom to enjoy and participate in our shared culture. I whole-heartedly support those goals and am disgusted by the fact that the "mainstream" parties don't even pay them lip service.