5 ms·
Suburbs Try to Prevent an Exodus as Young Adults Move to Cities and Stay
- EC1 13y agoMaybe because renting forever is ultimately cheaper than buying a house, especially if you aren't able to save at a rate that you can buy a house at a reasonable time.
- w1ntermute 13y agohttps://www.khanacademy.org/economics-finance-domain/core-finance/housing/renting-v-buying/v/renting-vs--buying-a-home https://www.khanacademy.org/economics-finance-domain/core-fi...
- EC1 13y agohttp://www.theonion.com/articles/friend-who-sent-link-to-8minute-youtube-video-must,32442/ http://www.theonion.com/articles/friend-who-sent-link-to-8mi...
- this_user 13y agoWhat most people also don't take into consideration are the opportunity costs of buying a house and paying a mortgage for the next twenty or thirty years. If instead of buying you rent and invest the money you would otherwise pay for the house there is a good chance you will be much better off in the long run.
- WalterSear 13y ago~7 years in and my mortgage is cheaper than rent already.
- graeme 13y agoThat's great for you, but it doesn't tell us much about whether it's better to own or rent on average. Your testimony is like someone saying they bought one stock that's up 20%, so stocks must be better than bonds. There are other homeowners who have lost money, and some others who are doing even better than you. Individual stories don't tell us about aggregates.
- notajuggalo 13y agoSo what? The monthly payment is only a small piece of the puzzle
- pmorici 13y agoI think this has come up before when that video was posted here but when you consider buying vs renting you really need to do the calculations for your specific situation that should be the only take away from that video. Taken as general advice that you should always rent and never buy it's pretty horrible just as the opposite is horrible advice in general. It's pretty easy to get a rough idea of what is better in your area using a rent vs buy calculator the New York Times has a good one... http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/business/buy-rent-calculator.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/business/buy-rent-calcula...
- walshemj 13y agoSo tell that to the renters in SF who are learning a very hard enconomic lesseon about the downsides of not owning your own home
- DamnYuppie 13y agoWould you mind following up on this, specifically what lesson are they learning?
- drzaiusapelord 13y agoI'm not well versed in SF, but whats going on there is whats going on in Chicago. Due to a few factors like migration back into the city and gentrification, rent values have gone up pretty high in Chicago and much higher in SF. Renters are seeing rates that they simply cannot afford in the long run. Meanwhile, homeowners are seeing the value of their homes go up. Its a win for the owners and a loss for the renters. The decision to own isn't a static one. Its a relationship between what a house costs and what renting costs and when its appropriate to make the move. On top of that, one needs to worry about what happens in 20-30 years. I'll be retired with a paid off home and a low property tax load due to a senior exemption. Lifelong renters will still need to pay full rent until their dying day. This can affect when or even if you retire.
- malyk 13y agoRent for my 1 bedroom/1 bath, 1000 sq ft. loft in SF: $3200 Mortgage for my 2 bed/1 bath, 1200 sq ft. home in Oak: $1900* We had to pay ~$70k in closing costs, so it isn't /easy/ to just go and buy something, but one possible lesson is that if you spend your whole life renting you are subject to the whims of your landlord (especially if you don't have rent control) and could end up paying a lot more for a place to live then you would if you had bought. Of course, the buy to rent numbers alternate back and forth depending on market conditions, so that doesn't hold true all the time. * - Lots of confounding variables here though. SF vs. Oakland, $650 a month for property taxes aren't accounted for in the monthly mortgage cost. But we have a 40'x 50' yard, a garage, no shared walls, easier parking, etc. So it's an individual choice, but even all in my house is much cheaper than an equivalent rental unit in SF (maybe even if you factor in a new roof every 20 years, other maintanence, etc...at least in these market conditions.)
- brodney 13y agoHow is this a problem that needs preventing? Alternate title: "People like living in the city more these days"
- Zikes 13y agoEven better alternate title: "Urban Sprawl Finally Solved"
- cobrausn 13y agoThe one word answer is 'gentrification', depending upon how you feel about that.
- anon1385 13y agoWell my own personal perspective is that I'd like to live somewhere that I can do gardening, grow veg[1] and sometimes go for a walk and see some wildlife. I'd also like to live in a place where the average age isn't 40 years older than I am so that I could have some kind of social life without driving for miles (ideally I don't want to drive at all). Which is all very unrealistic, and I'll probably end up living in the middle of nowhere with no social life if I ever have enough money to afford a house. I don't think it's good for the social makeup of small towns and villages. Healthy communities need people of all ages, not just retirees. [1] this is kinda possible in a city, but usually costs a fortune. I used to live near allotments in Edinburgh but they were super expensive to rent.
- pnathan 13y agoThat's essentially my situation as well (I live in the US). I'd like a few acres, live near a national forest, and work a tech job that isn't at the only company within the nearest 500 miles. :-S
- josephhardin 13y agoCheck out northern Colorado. Between Denver, Fort Collins, and Boulder there is a fair bit of tech, cost of living is decently low(outside of Boulder), and you can live right next to a national forest.
- chris_mahan 13y agoYou mean paying $900,000 for a house in a suburbs isn't a great investment?
- cobrausn 13y agoI would argue that paying $900,000 for any house isn't really a great investment.
- seizethecheese 13y agoThere are tons of houses where that would be a great investment.
- saraid216 13y agoHow is a house an investment at all?
- Stubb 13y agoYeah, I look at my residence as a depreciating asset that consumes time and money. We'll see how the so-called investment aspect works out for people once interest rates start returning to historical norms.
- specialp 13y agoI think people have the wrong idea viewing a home solely as an investment. It is indeed a form of investment that you get the benefit of living in. Sure if you look at the amount of money I put into a home vs the amount of money I could invest in S&P 500 it is then a terrible investment. But there is a tangible result here where I am able to live in a home and do whatever I want to my home while as a small side effect I have an investment.
- dmm 13y agoIf you generate income from it by renting it out.
- 13y ago
- bigdubs 13y agoI'd love to own a house in the country eventually. The problem with moving to a city for the excitement and the job opportunities is that it's very hard to save the money for the down payment when you're spending > 30% of your take home income on rent.
- pmorici 13y agoMove to Baltimore it is cheaper to live in the city than the suburbs.
- rayiner 13y agoThe wife and I are moving to Baltimore this fall. The 45 minute Amtrak ride to work will be more convenient than commuting in from Great Falls, Vienna, or Reston, which can easily take an hour+ each way, despite being only ~10 miles from the city.
- robgibbons 13y agoThe problem with the city (for me, at least) is the people. Not the rent prices, but the people. Guess I'm a suburbanite for life.
- ebiester 13y agoFunny enough, that's my problem with suburbia. :)
- itg 13y ago"The people" is the exact reason I prefer urban settings to suburban.
- sp332 13y agoHow about moving out into the countryside? Then people would bother you even less :)
- saraid216 13y agoJust do it properly. Build a fort, put a moat around it, only invite people you like, make sure there's a throne room, and any time you leave, do it from a horse-powered carriage carrying all of your essentials with you. Castle doctrine that.
- Tiktaalik 13y agoTo stay relevant to young people suburbs need to transform themselves from sprawling, car oriented strip malls to compact, walkable, transit oriented, complete small cities and towns.
- swombat 13y agoAgreed. There's plenty of people leaving around Greater London who only commute for work. A place like Wimbledon might be a solid 40 minutes trip out of London (at the end of a tube line) but if you live there, there's everything you want nearby and you don't have to go anywhere else to find a nice little town that you can walk about and enjoy yourself in. A suburb that isn't a place where you can actually live - there's a name for that in french, we call them cités dortoirs - dormitory towns. No one wants to live there.
- a3n 13y agoIn English in America they're "bedroom communities." Just a place to sleep. (The metaphors run deep on that one.)
- saraid216 13y agoThere's a point at which saying, "The Matrix has you," is no longer amusing.
- rayiner 13y agoThere's towns like that in the U.S. I used my car about once a month in the New York suburbs 20 miles north of Manhattan. All those little towns are on the train line, and have walkable downtowns where you can get whatever you need.
- jarrett 13y agoI believe that's the major reason. (Based solely on my anecdotal evidence.) Most young folks I know don't want to be car-dependent. They often cite gas prices as the primary reason. Gas is already expensive, and the young people I know expect prices to go much, much higher. Some of them also mention exercise as a reason.
- yypark 13y agoIf we look at the actual population growth trends, the suburbs are experiencing plenty of growth, not a decline, even if cities are doing well too (especially compared to the 70s/80s). In the New York City metro area, 29% of the population growth took place in NYC proper, as opposed to the rest in the suburban counties. One demographic of 20-somethings and a few interviewed people does not offset the rest of the population. There are plenty of people moving into suburbs today and they make up most of the fastest-growing areas of the US. The pattern of growth barely seems to have shifted, and doesn't match the rhetoric of suburbs in decline. http://www.joelkotkin.com/content/00406-cities-and-census-cities-neither-booming-nor-withering http://www.joelkotkin.com/content/00406-cities-and-census-ci...
- specialp 13y agoI think this is a change in the New York area mostly. Back in the 70s-mid 80s NYC was a much more dangerous place and living in the suburbs was cheap. Young people in the city then moved to the suburbs to escape rents and high crime. However now the suburbs like Westchester, Long Island have become very expensive with very high taxes. Since these suburbs are comparatively wealthy the citizens fight against high density development. So if you are a young person that grew up on Long Island you have the choice of paying $1400 to live in someone's illegal basement apartment, living in one of the few decent complexes for $2000+ or move to NYC. It is easy to see why moving to NYC is very attractive then. When you are single or a couple it is good to live in the city as there are plentiful jobs and entertainment options. So I think that there is not a massive landslide of people leaving the suburbs I think it is just that people are having children much later, the city is now safe, and there are no cheap options for singles/childless couples in the suburbs in the NYC metro area. People still move from NYC to the suburbs. And in cheaper metro areas the suburbs are growing very fast because they are much like the situation that existed in NYC in the 70s-mid 80s
- Zigurd 13y ago> New York suburbs are not the only ones getting somewhat grayer. In three Maryland suburbs outside Washington, Chevy Chase lost 34 percent of its 25- to 34-year-olds, Bethesda 19.2 percent and Potomac 27 percent. The declines were comparable for Kenilworth, Winnetka and Glencoe outside Chicago... These are all very expensive suburbs. They are "graying" because it takes more time to accumulate the money to live there. The same is happening to my town. A better comparison would be suburbs that younger people can afford vs. cities. I'd bet you find the same trend, but these examples are not informative.
- apendleton 13y agoBethesda's not cheap, but most of DC proper is more expensive, and anecdotally (as a DC resident), most DC-resident friends of mine could afford to live in the nicer DC suburbs if they wanted to, but choose to live in the city instead. The population that's the focus of this article isn't deciding between downtown and some Hagerstown or whatnot.
- JPKab 13y agoI think DC is actually a bad example of this, in the sense that people whose kids reach school age leave very quickly. A quick look at the demographic data of the public school population shows that the newcomers aren't adding to the public school population. Either they don't have school age kids, or they are putting their kids in private school. Other cities won't have this issue though.
- anishkothari 13y agoWell said. I also have a feeling that many of the younger people who are staying in these well-heeled suburbs are either living with their parents or have been given their childhood homes as their parents move away in retirement.
- bradleyjg 13y agoNot only do the NYC suburbs have an expensive cost of entry (rentals are nearly non-existent in many of them) they also have high ongoing carrying costs. If you have more than one school age child, you may come out ahead versus paying for private school, but for those without school age children you are paying a lot of money for not much in return. It is for this reason many people are waiting until their children are actually ready to start school before moving out into the suburbs. That can easily be mid to late 30s for the demographic that can afford these suburbs in the first place.
- chiph 13y agoI just don't want to cut grass any more. I did it in high school for spending money, and just had enough of it afterwards.
- drzaiusapelord 13y agoJust bought a house, but in the city, not the suburbs. I was pleasantly surprised to see that non-corded electric mowers exist. My mower weighs next to nothing, is whisper quiet, and one charge lasts me several cuts. Granted, its a small yard, but the hassle of moving heavy equipment, mixing gas and oil, dealing with loud noise, dealing with exhaust, pull start pain, etc are long gone. Now I'm just waiting on the affordable electric car. Gas, even in the best of circumstances, is just too much of a hassle and requires much more complex machines than electric.
- mikestew 13y ago> My mower weighs next to nothing Really? Because my electric is hugely more heavy than an equivalent gas mower. Granted, that's mostly battery, and probably lead/somethingorother at that. Not that it matters much, because it's self-propelled, but weight is not one of its features. Not that I'd give up my electric mower. It's like my Nissan Leaf, only for cutting grass: push the switch and it runs w/o having to fiddle with gasoline. Quiet. Won't run as long as gas-powered, but gets me where I need to go.
- mgkimsal 13y agoThey exist in suburbs too.
- joshuacc 13y agoYou can take it a step further with an old-fashioned reel mower. They work quite well as long as your yard isn't ridiculously large or weedy.
- drzaiusapelord 13y agoThey just need to be sharpened too frequently and heaven forbid you put off mowing for a while or have a few rainy days in a row. The resistance is pretty strong if the grass is remotely tall. Of course, this could all be a case of me getting old and lazy, which I suspect it mostly is.
- hawkharris 13y agoI'm surprised this article attributes the "exodus" to high housing costs in the suburbs. This may be true in select areas, but as a whole, I think housing is much more expensive near city centers. As a wise man once said, "The rent is too damn high." I love living in the city, but pouring tens of thousands into rent each year isn't a smart long-term investment. To me and most of the people I know, urban housing costs are a reason to leave the city, not to move there.
- rayiner 13y agoYeah. I grew up in the DC suburbs, and even with a kid there's no way I'm moving back. I'd rather live in a smaller, cheaper city than spend all day in the car.
- keithpeter 13y ago"...she now pays $3,500 in rent, but she has a four-bedroom, 2,400-square-foot bungalow with its own laundry and a balcony overlooking the beach." UK: That is less than half what I pay for a 2 bedroom house a couple of miles out of the centre of a provincial city. This house is what people in the US would call 'rent controlled'. Commercial rents twice to three times as much. Housing cost is ridiculous in UK but no-one seems to want to acknowledge that. Those 500 square feet railway apartments. What are they like? I wouldn't mind one of those!
- mgkimsal 13y agoI'll acknowledge it. You pay > $7000/month for rent? 4200 pounds per month?
- keithpeter 13y agoOK, I thought those where annual rents. So still another fact of difference. UK outer-inner city rent around £800 per month (£7200 per year) plus about £1k property taxes for two bed apartment in new development.
- mgkimsal 13y agoNo, they're paying $3000+ per month in the US. Whew - I didn't think the UK had gone up THAT much ;) The £800/month isn't out of line with a lot of US rents either - that's around $1300/month. You'd get a lot of room for that in some areas, but in others like NYC, that's almost nothing.
- Mvandenbergh 13y agoReally? I pay £1800 a month for a privately rented three bedroom house 20 minutes from central London. Friends of mine pay maybe £2000 for a similar sized place in zone 2 North London.
- josephschmoe 13y agoYoung adults don't spend time in their houses. I'd rather have a 2 bedroom apartment within walking distance of several restaurants and bars than a house in the suburbs, even if they were the same rent. The suburbs are made for single families - a shrinking demographic, even among homeowners.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Homunculiheaded 13y agoI've personally found a great alternative to living in major cities is not the suburbs but smaller cities. I grew up in the Northeast and now live in a smaller city in the West (pop ~250,000). I can get to SF in a few hours, but locally I still have most of the things I'd want from a city: great restaurants, art, fun tech community, music, easy to access airport etc. I also have many of the perks of living in a smaller community: very little traffic, incredibly affordable cost of living, get to know the owners of most restaurants/businesses I frequent etc. The crazy thing is that living in a house 10 minutes from the center of downtown I pay a fraction of what my friends and relatives back East do to live in a suburb so far away from the metro area they live near that they visit it only once or twice a year. Especially with more and more remote work becoming available, if you're getting sick of living in a major metro area I highly recommend checking the diverse range of smaller cities across the US, imho it is a vastly superior experience to living in an expensive suburb.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoDes Moines. Here me out! I live in the Chicago suburbs; I commute to the West Loop every day. Traffic! High costs! And so forth. This weekend, I was in Des Moines for a wedding. I met people in their historic East Village. Great bar scene, great craft brew scene. Everyone was friendly! Everyone bicycles around! I would actually consider picking up from Chicago and living in Des Moines, as it seems to be the midwest version of AshvilleNC or perhaps Ann Arbor, but before Ann Arbor blew up and got expensive. I would have never thought I'd say, "Des Moines is pretty fucking awesome, and I could live here."
- acjohnson55 13y agoYou should check out Lexington, KY as well, if you like Des Moines. It's a similar sized city and a similar distance from Chicago. It's got a lot of culture and history. It's also quite close to other cities, so you kind of get to collect on the benefits of living in a larger metro. Not sure it's quite as cheap as Des Moines though.
- contingencies 13y agoMy great alternative was leaving the west at 19, and trying out different cities overseas. Now 33, I've had multi-month to multi-year stints in five different cities in mainland China (~100,000 - 24 million), Bangkok, London, Los Angeles and Taipei. Like you, I've found that the smaller ones appeal more to me, with maybe bi-weekly trips to a larger city. With kids on the way, after an exploratory trip for the serious consideration of buying some forest in New Zealand, my wife and I now look forward to checking out France. If I had invested in a mortgage, there's no way I'd be this mobile, with such rich experience. I've never owned a car, or driven one (legally), but for one slab of my self-managed 'weekend' spent five hours yesterday on a motorbike riding through some of the most spectacular scenery I've yet found, the upper https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanpan_River https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanpan_River ... no regrets with this path, life is fantastic!
- marknutter 13y agoMy wife and I moved out of a 3rd ring suburb into the City (a first ring suburb) here in Minneapolis and have been very happy so far. Most of my friends have either done the same or plan to in the near future. I lived my whole life in a quintessential suburban city and had my fill. Suburbs have everything you need and nothing you want. You can go months without ever leaving. Now, enjoying stuff in the city is no longer a long trek. I expect this trend to continue.
- sq1020 13y agoIn the suburbs, there's no sense of community or character, nothing unique that distinguishes one suburb from another. It's truly a shame that the vast majority of the American population have been and will be deprived of a childhood that includes a chance to walk to school, take the train to a museum, and play with other kids in the neighborhood. Suburbs also play a central role in making car ownership absolutely necessary in order to perform even the most basic daily tasks. This, if you think about, amounts to discrimination against the elderly, children, and anyone who is not able to drive or afford a car.
- jk215 13y agoIll never understand the "allure" of living in the burbs other than having space. Cookie cutter houses in cookie cutter developments separated by long stretches of mini-highways and strip malls. Everything is brand new and completely sterile.
- jobu 13y agoThis seems like it's just a byproduct of people waiting longer to have kids (or not having kids at all). I know if I didn't have kids I would prefer to live in an urban area vs a suburb. Am I wrong? Are people that live in dense cities having kids? (And if so, how they make it work? The city seems terribly inconvenient for raising kids.)
- BadassFractal 13y agoThis rings true to me. If you're going to be actively dating all the way into your 30s, living in the suburbs is going to make things much harder.
- the_watcher 13y agoFor me personally, not having to use my car often is the single biggest appeal of city life. I love walking to dinner, coffee, a friend's place, and bars.
- tthomas48 13y agoThere are a lot of us with kids in the cities, though. Many of us think the schools are good enough and don't want the super-stressful "good" schools of the suburbs for our kids. If my kid can read, write, and get into a good college, plus have the varied experiences of living in a city that's the best of all worlds.