3 ms·
I think I disagree with you on a few points. MongoDB might be adding features of SQL databases, and heading in that direction, but they are still missing joins,
by danpalmer 13y ago
I think I disagree with you on a few points. MongoDB might be adding features of SQL databases, and heading in that direction, but they are still missing joins, and that's a crucial part of relational databases.
Also, I'd clarify a little by saying it's trying to be a strongly consistent, distributed through replication and sharding database. Right now there are some bugs in the system, some improvements that need to be made, and definitely some default configurations that need to be changed before it's going to be a consistent database. It's definitely going for consistency instead of availability, but I don't think it can call itself consistent yet.
- justinsb 13y agoI don't think we disagree as much as you might think! I'm trying not to critique MongoDB today, but rather thinking of what it will become. Today's implementation problems will hopefully be fixed. I agree that without joins, MongoDB querying is very limited. I credit them enough to believe they will end up fixing that and supporting joins in some way. But then, they have "SQL with a different syntax". And I definitely agree on the data-loss bugs. But again, presuming they fix those, they just end up with something very similar to a relational DB, in terms of the CAP theorem etc. In short, even when/if they fix all the bugs and add all the missing features, I worry that we'll just end up back where we started.