3 ms·
Hey! I was always fascinated about energy, but am not too knowledgeable, so I would like to ask you something about oil production: would it be possible/efficie
by tomp 13y ago
Hey! I was always fascinated about energy, but am not too knowledgeable, so I would like to ask you something about oil production: would it be possible/efficient/economical to grow plants (e.g. algae or photosynthesizing bacteria) instead of using CO2 extracted from the sea? I.e. build huge pools in sunny areas, grow algae, harvest them occasionally, and extract CO2 from them or, even better, process them, essentially speeding up the natural oil-producing process.
- mikeyouse 13y agoThere are dozens of companies that are working on this (I work for one) in a variety of media including bacteria, yeast, algae, switchgrass, etc. It's a very hard problem made more difficult by the drop in the cost of oil from $150 -> $75 since most of these companies were funded. A partial list of people working on it: * Amyris * Solazyme * KiOR * Algenol * Sapphire * Aurora * Synthetic Genomics * Cellana * PetroSun Notably, most of the companies on that list have taken hundreds of millions of dollars from domestic and foreign oil companies hoping to create their own supply. Maybe more notably, several of the companies on the list went public, then lost 80-90% of their market cap. Most are pursuing other, higher value products as a first-order business, with promises of biofuels down the road.
- dredmorbius 13y agoAs I commented previously: plant productivity simply doesn't scale to existing petroleum consumption levels. Even substituting for petroleum in niche uses (say: ocean shipping or aviation) comprising a few percent (I believe combined these are around 5% of total petroleum use, though aggregate global stats are hard to find), in which alternatives are unfeasible, would be a major challenge and require the allocation of tremendous acreages of land to biofuel production. Remember that the transition from wood to coal occurred largely because the world was running out of wood. Otherwise, wood had a lot to commend itself: it was locally available (coal comes from limited locations), doesn't involve mining dangers, and is easier to burn (some early coal proponents in the US were accused of fraud when the "rocks" they sold wouldn't burn in existing ovens -- anthracite coal is tough to ignite). Where opportunistic feedstocks exist, I suspect biofuels may supply some energy, but it's going to be a very small fraction of existing fossil consumption in advanced nations.
- mikeyouse 13y agoIn the short term, you're likely right, in the very long term, I think biofuels will make up the vast majority of liquid fuel (which will be helped as most transport moves to electric). There have been some interesting developments in biofuels lately with Algenol peaking above >10,000 gallons/acre/year rate and demonstrating a sustained rate north of 8,000 gallons/acre/year. There have been some murmurs of breakthroughs in genetically modifying the photosynthesis pathway as well, which could have a dramatic affect on per-acre productivity.
- dredmorbius 13y agoUnless (or until) human populations fall markedly -- to, say, 500m - 2b, the viability of biofuels simply doesn't add up. There's too much conflict with both other human ag demands, and with ecological systems. Is that algenol productivity associated with open-air production, or is that in an artificial controlled environment with UV lighting and a highly engineered grow space? Even if those production rates can be sustained, you're looking at 30 million acres for algae cultivation. Technical details are thin, but I've found their 9kgal/acre-yr release: http://www.biofuelsdigest.com/bdigest/2013/03/11/algenol-hits-9k-gallonsacre-mark-for-algae-to-ethanol-process/ http://www.biofuelsdigest.com/bdigest/2013/03/11/algenol-hit...
- maxerickson 13y agoBut 30 million acres is merely a vast amount of infrastructure. It's a big piece of land if you consider it at once (a few hundred miles on a side), but spread across all the places where there are people, it isn't that big an area. If you manage to build some of the infrastructure in the oceans, the area doesn't even matter (that doesn't mean it would be easy, there is just lots of room).
- dredmorbius 13y agoIt's a vast amount of land, no matter how you slice it. A few hundred miles on a side is the size of many larger states in the US, and that assumes a 100% fill factor. Add in requirements for access roads, equipment, human habitations and support, and that's going to increase, though I'm not sure by how much -- 10% to 30% wouldn't surprise me. Built as a corridor, 30 million acres is 1000 miles x 47 miles -- an assembly of grow tanks stretching 25 miles on either side of an highway running from Chicago to Denver. Though more likely it would be situated in a desert region (so as not to compete with existing agriculture), but where it would compete with alternative direct electrical (or electricity-to-fuel) alternatives. Even if the area doesn't require freshwater access, it will require water, and for that to be transported (likelihood of occupying thousands of miles of coastline are slim) considerable distances inland, and then back out again (waste streams and salt). All of which are both capital and operationally intensive. Building sea-based structures would similarly be insanely capital intensive. You'd be better off finding a way to create an inland salt lake (say: in the Dead Sea or Death Valley) and situate your grow-ponds there. Marine or even simply salt-water environments are very, very harsh and hard on structures (even concrete) and equipment.
- dredmorbius 13y agoThe basic problem with virtually all biofuel proposals is scale. Given present populations and energy utilization, biofuel simply doesn't add up. The world uses 100 million barrels of petroleum daily, the US about 20 million (slightly less). Even small uses of petroleum such as aviation (about 2% of the total) represent vast amounts of fuel. And with projected population and energy utilization growth, demand will increase above this. The basic maths are laid out in a paper I've found to be a tremendously useful reference, Jeffrey Dukes, "Burning Buried Sunshine": http://globalecology.stanford.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_ClimChange1.pdf http://globalecology.stanford.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_ClimChange... Briefly: present human consumption of net primary productivity (plant growth) is about 14% of Earth's total. The fossil fuels consumed in 1997 (the date analyzed by the paper) comprise the equivalent of another 21% of NPP (and the actual period over which the fossil fuels accumulated is far greater: 400 years of growth, accumulated over ~5 million years, due to inefficiencies in the process of coal, oil, and gas formation and accumulation). You can look at biofuels on an energy per unit area basis. There's roughly 1 KW/m^2 of incident sunlight. Current PV solar cells convert around 20% of this, and tend to capture the equivalent of 8 hours of sunlight per day, which is to say, a 30% capacity factor. Maximum PV efficiency (with far higher costs of production) is around 85%. But with present commercially available means, you can capture 20% of 1 kW for 8 hours each day, or roughly 1.6 kWh per day. A kilowatt (kW) is a unit of power, a kilowatt-hour is a unit of energy. US electrical production of roughly 4,000 TWh would require 7800 km^2 of area to produce, or a square 88 km on a side. That's for electricity. Plants and algae have an efficiency of from 1-10%, with conventional crops and plants generally in the 1-3% range. We can do the same area calculation as above, or work from yields expressed as gallons of fuel per acre. A high-yield crop such as canola is generally given as 100 gal/acre, hemp advocates claim as much as 300 gal/acre (though this is generally disputed), and algae biofuels as much as 1000 gal/acre. Given the 7.3 billion barrels of oil consumed, lets work out acreage requirements for algae. GNU Units is one of my favorite tools for this: You have: 7.3 billion barrels / (1000 gallons/acre) You want: million km^2 * 1.2407662 That is, we need 1.24 million km^2, or a square 1113 km on a side (that's 479,000 mi^2, or a square 692 miles on a side, or a bit more than 300 million acres of land. There are presently slightly more than 400 million acres of land under agricultural production in the US. Three quarters of that would have to go to fuel production under one of the most productive biofuel processes we have. Moreover, algae require ponds, which is to say, a LOT of water, pumping pesticide, fertilizer, and a lot of processing. Say you figured out a way to move all of this off-shore, and could set up grow-ponds in the oceans off the Atlantic and Pacific coasts? They're roughly 1000 miles long each, so to figure on the width of our algae grow structure, we divide 479,000 by 2000 and find ... the ponds would have to extend only 239 miles off-shore. That's from Key West, FL, to Eastport, ME, from San Diego, CA, to Port Angeles, WA. And they'd have to survive freezing and nor'easters and hurricanes and ... Yeah, sounds kinda tough. If the US population and per-capita energy utilization were far less, say maybe 10% of present levels, this might be conceivable, but as things stand, not really. And then there's the rest of the world. Even more modest proposals to, say, supply aviation fuel from halophyte + aquaponics farms, described by Boeing as the biggest breakthrough in biofuels, really doesn't add up: http://redd.it/1wo2hl http://redd.it/1wo2hl (Another interesting fact I discovered in researching that was that the US hit Peak Aviation Fuel in 1999, and present flight activity is more than 30% below what projections of that time suggested. Passenger miles are up somewhat given increased load factors -- more bumped flights and less legroom due to cramming more people onto fewer flights. Kopits points this out also in his presentation, confirming my observations.) Which is why I find the NRL's project so interesting. The magnitude of its plant and scale requirements is far, far less than competing biofuel alternatives.