6 ms·
TL;DR: User got spam from a website hosted by GoDaddy. User reports spam. GoDaddy wants to be good guy and asks spammer if user opted in (by providing spammer w
by tomp 13y ago
TL;DR: User got spam from a website hosted by GoDaddy. User reports spam. GoDaddy wants to be good guy and asks spammer if user opted in (by providing spammer with the user's email). Spammer stops spamming, but harasses user by posting her photo online, which s/he probably got using the email address GoDaddy provided.
In retrospect, I'm sure there are better ways for GoDaddy to investigate such complaints, but I think they didn't do something very evil - an email address is hardly "personally identifiable information". On the other hand, if you don't want your photo to be posted online, don't post your photo online.
- samastur 13y agoSo email address is not personally identifiable information even though it was all the spammer needed to identify her? Right. In some parts of the world (e.g. Slovenia) personal email is very much considered a personal information and any operator divulging it in such manner would pay a steep fine.
- tomp 13y agoSo if I forward your email, I'm committing a crime? There's too much law about the internet... > In some parts of the world (e.g. Slovenia) Slovenia is rather crazy about everything computer-related. A while ago Google was forbidden from collecting Street View data. I really hope that has been reversed by now...
- dingaling 13y ago> Slovenia is rather crazy about everything computer-related. A while ago Google was forbidden from collecting Street View data whispers That was Austria.
- tomp 13y agoSlovenia as well - full article (in Slovenian): [1]. In 2010, information commissionaire first rejected Google's request for recording [2], but it was finally approved in 2013 [3]. [1] http://lendavainfo.com/google-street-view-za-slovenijo-je-koncno-delujoc/ http://lendavainfo.com/google-street-view-za-slovenijo-je-ko... [2] https://www.ip-rs.si/varstvo-osebnih-podatkov/iskalnik-po-odlocbah-in-mnenjih/odlocbe-in-mnenja-varstvo-osebnih-podatkov/?tx_jzvopdecisions_pi1%5bshowUid%5d=1943&cHash=40b3fc486d https://www.ip-rs.si/varstvo-osebnih-podatkov/iskalnik-po-od... [3] https://www.ip-rs.si/novice/detajl/snemanje-ulic-za-storitev-google-street-view/?cHash=2113761ece703e0badf20352fa2faa35 https://www.ip-rs.si/novice/detajl/snemanje-ulic-za-storitev...
- samastur 13y agoYou wouldn't in common cases because as an individual you are not required to care. However if you are an owner of a database containing personal information (where database means collection, not a particular technology), then rules are different. You then are required to collect only what you need for purposes granted by their owners and have to take care of not disseminating it without approval to others. Google wasn't allowed to collect Street View data until they could conform to our privacy laws which mostly meant not making photographed people easily identifiable. This requirement is in no way specific to Slovenia (e.g. I think Germany has the same one) and Google complied which is why you can use street view in Slovenia now. I would not describe our computer-related laws crazy. They are lacking as laws everywhere are and certainly sometimes in uniquely our way. However it is often the enforcement (or lack of) that is the problem, not laws themselves.
- snowwolf 13y agoYou didn't wonder why the poster mentioned Slovenia specifically? It's a bit of an odd choice for an example. It's like the poster knew something personally identifiable about you.
- tomp 13y agoI'm guessing it's because he's from Slovenia (as well).
- bryans 13y agoIs an e-mail address really any different from a phone number? I can't imagine anyone arguing that it would be okay for an intermediary in a dispute to disclose one party's phone number to the other, regardless of the reason. It is simply not GoDaddy's place to expose such information. And I don't think her problem was with the photo being on the internet. It was more that her photo was sandwiched between blatantly defamatory content.
- masklinn 13y ago> an email address is hardly "personally identifiable information" Except for it being PII according to NIST, that is: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personally_identifiable_information#Examples http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personally_identifiable_informa...
- whatisinaname 13y ago> an email address is hardly "personally identifiable information" Are you sure about that Tom from Slovenia? Hint: google yours...
- grkvlt 13y agoOK, so the following happened: 1. User got spam 2. GoDaddy ... provid(es) spammer with the user's email 3. Spammer ... using the email address GoDaddy provided But wait, how did step one happen? Spammer must have had user's email, as a pre-requisite to sending said spam via email (presumably) in the first place? I'm confused. Or am I missing something important?