10 ms·
I happen to know the author of this. This was a really tough thing for him to read, but he's taking it as constructive criticism. I would add to the people com
by jgrahamc 13y ago
I happen to know the author of this. This was a really tough thing for him to read, but he's taking it as constructive criticism.
I would add to the people commentating here on HN: tptacek's review is tough; you do not need to lay into the author of this book any more.
- nailer 13y agoIt's a tough thing for anyone to read: it's browserWidth wide and monospaced. Here's a readable version: https://gist.github.com/mikemaccana/10847077 https://gist.github.com/mikemaccana/10847077
- andor 13y agoit's browserWidth wide I like that, because my browser window is resizable.
- Sae5waip 13y agoI don't. So is mine, but resizing it for each individual website is unnecessary work. And some websites have a legitimate need for a wider format, so you can't even say "all websites should be like this".
- jacquesm 13y agoI think the tone is what makes it tougher than it needs to be, not the factual content. Props to the author for just looking at the content and not at the way in which it was delivered. Props to Thomas for taking the time to review the book.
- znowi 13y agoThis condescending tone seems to be mandatory for karmic users of over 100K points :)
- StavrosK 13y agoYou're being downvoted, but I agree that a greater amount of tact would have been warranted. Phrases like "I am not making this up", "argh!" and "huh?" add nothing to the review, but only serve to make it more personal, and I say this as a guy who also has very little tact.
- stcredzero 13y agoThere has been a cultural shift in recent years. None of tptacek's observations are adhominem. But there is now an expectation that one tone down the description of one's own reaction. I suspect this is often a conflict between the expectations of the children of helicopter parents and my generation. (1) Sorry, but I have a right to an emotional reaction to your content and a right to describe it, especially if the reaction is grounded in objective technical reality. I suspect that younger people have this idea that online descriptions of emotional reactions are fictional and purposely crafted for effect -- mostly having to do with emotional aggression. It's true that sometimes "passion" over a subject is used as a pretext for such aggression. That doesn't mean that it's always true, however. In some cases, it's honesty. That said, "arrrgh" reactions in a technical discipline often indicate a frustrating failure of outreach, education, or communication. I learned things from reading tptacek's review. Maybe he could supervise the ghost-writing of his own undoubtedly excellent book? (1) - I was riding the bus and this young man had his sneakers tied to the back of his backpack, the soles of which he was pressing into my chest. I tried discretely hinting to him by pressing back, but he was oblivious, so I brought this to his attention. I was amazed that his first priority wasn't to apologize or help me out, rather it was that I recognize that he didn't mean any harm. Be correct first, then worry about your own ego second.
- scott_s 13y agoRegarding the shoes: making it clear to you that he did not mean any harm is a way of apologizing and defusing a potentially explosive situation. I hesitate to read too much into it. Regarding tptacek, I suspect that if he had sent this to the author, or posted it as a formal review, I suspect he would have toned down the description of his reactions. I'm not sure where this review came from, but my impression is that he did not think of it as a published review that the author would see. Certainly doing such would be advisable, as people are more receptive to criticism that way. Perhaps I am wrong regarding how tptacek would have responded had he known the review would be, essentially, published. But I know I phrase things differently in such situations.
- VeejayRampay 13y agoWell tell him that's a great reaction to have in that situation. I find it mature and I wish more people would act that way.
- Jabbles 13y agoIt's unfortunate that it was too big for an HN comment, which would probably have prevented it being posted again as a topic. People who are genuinely interested in the book could have searched HN and found the original review. This thread just exists to bash/watch further bashing of the author/book.
- shocks 13y agoAgreed. I don't often flag submissions but I'll be flagging this one. Most of us already read the review anyway.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dvanduzer 13y agoThis is an incisive criticism, but it's extremely educational in its own right. I would not have read it otherwise. When working through basic knowledge to mastery of a topic, attempting to teach someone else is an extremely effective way to organize your thoughts and learn yourself. This is why graduate students teach undergraduate students. The author of the original book shouldn't feel shame for making the mistake of working toward mastery of the topic. But racing to publish is dangerous when the topic is as serious as (heart surgery or) cryptography. A stern warning is worth repeating.
- mikeash 13y agoIt's fortunate that it was posted again as a topic, as I didn't see the original comment thread and wouldn't have read this review otherwise, and I learned things from it.
- rbanffy 13y agoI have faith the next edition of the book will withstand tptacek's criticism much better.
- conformal 13y agoDISCLAIMER: i know and have worked with kyle (the author). while the factual content of tptacek's review may be spot on, his overall tone is very negative and smacks of "only experts allowed" logic. while he could have easily helped improve kyle's book and shared these comments privately, he instead chose to lambast kyle publicly, which doesn't really help anybody: tptacek looks like a total jerk and kyle now has a lot of negative attention on (this version of) his book. this pervasive "experts only" attitude is a big part of why "secure" open source projects have hard times getting and keeping contributors. it is par for the course for people to be super rude and negative to new participants instead of trying to encourage them to improve and learn. this lack of contributors then has a whole array of negative secondary effects, like less people reading the code for the project.
- dvanduzer 13y agoOpen source security projects have a hard time getting and keeping contributors because the expertise for this particular kind of work is difficult to develop. Publishing a book like this sends a strong public signal of deep expertise. I have not found tptacek to be overly rude or negative when offering advice to journeyman cryptologists. But a journeyperson should not necessarily be publicizing their how-to guides yet.
- nuser 13y agoI firmly believe that you shouldn't author a book in something if you lack the appropriate expertise. If you do so, you risk disseminating misinformation at scale, causing enormous harm. Sometimes expertise is actually required.
- ominous_prime 13y agoI understand where you're coming from, but the author is the one who put this out in public. Publishing a book like this sends a strong message of "I am an expert, take what is written here as fact". Maybe the tone could have been a little softer, but this should not have been done privately. The criticism of the work needs to be just as public as the work itself, so that people who might have been misled have a chance to see why.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 13y agoHow many books has he authored? This is very valuable data, and he stands to make an even better book even if all he does is change diffie hellman to appease tptacek and perhaps other readers.