I didn't miss that part. That's where Jeff posts the criteria _he_ looks at. His assumption is that those criteria are not just good for _everyone_ who uses a

I didn't miss that part. That's where Jeff posts the criteria _he_ looks at. His assumption is that those criteria are not just good for _everyone_ who uses a user-generated-content site, but for _all_ user-generated content. Mr. Atwood thinks that users should receive more for their efforts, and backs it up by giving more at the sites he runs. I respect that. Try running his criteria past the user of a typical MySpace user. I'd bet the answers run a lot like this: * my friends can see it * my name is at the top, so it is me * I don't care (excepting serious artists, who should know better by now) * yes, if I'm a jerk * All I care about are my pictures, and I have copies * are they killing children in Rwanda, or something?