4 ms·
>Modern parenting literature seems largely to be about manipulating your child into being who and what you want them to be. That is not modern parenting, that'
by AndrewKemendo 13y ago
>Modern parenting literature seems largely to be about manipulating your child into being who and what you want them to be.
That is not modern parenting, that's just parenting. Aside from some fringe philosophies (Summerhill for example) I have yet to come across any seriously taken historical example of parenting advice that is not focused on shaping children into something the parent desires, even if that is a very loose mold.
Even your own example does this by assigning a direction to your actions based on how it will impact the child.
- bildung 13y ago> That is not modern parenting, that's just parenting. Aside from some fringe philosophies (Summerhill for example) I have yet to come across any seriously taken historical example of parenting advice that is not focused on shaping children into something the parent desires, even if that is a very loose mold. Try Emile from Rousseau. In general, what you are describing is the difference between the sciences of pedagogy an psychology. In one sentence, (since the enlightenment) pedagogy tries to find the optimal conditions for humans to develop their true self, while psychology usually observes a misguided development and tries to find a treatment. Psychology therefore has to have some model of what constitutes normality to compare against. These specific studies and treatments are easy to write about as a scientific journalist or parenting literature author. It's telling that practically none of the parenting books I've skimmed through are based on pedagogy. (that's no dismissal of psychology at all, but you have to use the right tool for the job).
- AndrewKemendo 13y ago>pedagogy tries to find the optimal conditions for humans to develop their true self "True self" is not a real thing - it's mystical psychobabble. In reality you are a product of your genetics and experiences, the ratios of which are still contested, however as of now the latter is much easier to influence than the former and as a result is really the only medium we have to work with if we want to influence outcomes.
- bildung 13y ago>>pedagogy tries to find the optimal conditions for humans to develop their true self >"True self" is not a real thing - it's mystical psychobabble. Yep you are right, but I don't speak English natively and did not have much time :) A better phrasing probably would have been the true potential of the species, not of an individual. But true potential sounds too elitist... I'll try more verbosely: Mostly since the enlightenment (let's say the second half of the 18th century, one landmark was Emile by Rousseau), most central-european theory of pedagogy has a specific vision of an ideal of a developed human being (or species) to strive for. It's centered around development of practical, cultural and emotional skills, reasoning, the ability to assess the own actions relative to the state and necessities of society as a whole. Something like the living according to the categorical imperative of Kant while not feeling deprived of the own needs.
- nevinera 13y agoThroughout most of history, parenting was largely focused on equipping one's children to survive. The idea that one could impart specific qualities onto one's children is very new - until recently one instead struggled to impart religious rules onto them, with sufficient impact that they would continue to be followed. If you think 'treat people with respect and dignity' is about manipulating other people to behave as you want them to, then you're doing it wrong.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Throughout most of history, parenting was largely focused on equipping one's children to survive. The idea that one could impart specific qualities onto one's children is very new - until recently one instead struggled to impart religious rules onto them, with sufficient impact that they would continue to be followed. That's a big pile of self-contradiction. Both survival skills and religious rules are specific qualities.
- nevinera 13y agoSkills are skills, and religious rules are behaviors or habits (depending). You can of course define 'quality' incredibly broadly if you want, but I meant it in the sense of 'personality characteristics' or 'character attributes'.
- dragonwriter 13y agoWhat is the objective distinction between each of the following: a skill, a behavior, a habit, a personality characteristic, and a character attribute? Seems to me that all of them, when they describe anything that is objectively meaningful, refer to patterns of action adopted in particular circumstances. The only thing that changes over time seems to be the name applied to the patterns of action that parenting seeks to impose on children, not the actual substance that parenting is about creating desired patterns of action.
- nevinera 13y ago