3 ms·
If an airline can't differentiate between a teenager goofing around and a credible threat, then that's the airline's fault. A girl posting nonsense on twitter g
by javajosh 13y ago
If an airline can't differentiate between a teenager goofing around and a credible threat, then that's the airline's fault. A girl posting nonsense on twitter getting arrested just shows that "the system" is inhuman and it just chews people up and spits them out. I won't be surprised at all if this girl gets a long prison sentence and her life gets ruined. Nor will I be surprised when legions of pundits come out of the woodwork exclaiming it wasn't punishment enough, and all the copycats should be treated the same way.
The thing is, if you think for 30 seconds about the problem of defending infrastructure from crazy people, your best bet is to lurk where crazy people congregate, and keep a finger on the pulse of the ones who are poised to "do something". How often do these people actually make a threat? Don't they normally just execute the attack? Of course, even this is imperfect, and the best response is to rebuild when something gets blown up. Hurricanes happen, earthquakes happen, crazy people who hate you happen, and in every case your best "revenge" is to just outproduce entropy.
Overreaction to human threat is a symptom of a much deeper illness, and one that plays directly into the hands of real terrorists. The lives and treasure lost on 9/11 was trivial to the number of lives and treasure we've spent trying to prevent the unpreventable. We could have built the Twin Towers 10,000 times over for the money we've spent on war and the TSA and the NSA. It's fucking stupid, and I'm tired of it.
- arrrg 13y agoThis happened in the Netherlands. I don’t think anything much will happen to her. The police showing up and asking questions is enough of a deterrent. The only irrational overreaction I could think of is being put on some no-fly list. That would be awful.
- lupinglade 13y agoSo prank calling 911 or pretending to rob a bank would be cool too?
- FLUX-YOU 13y ago>If an airline can't differentiate between a teenager goofing around and a credible threat, then that's the airline's fault. I don't really want the airline making that assessment because they don't have the people/experience/knowledge/training/ability to accurately assess that threat. I would rather them make the time-wasting call to the FBI and have the FBI on record and clear it. The situation is dumb, but sometimes you have to follow procedure for dumb situations. It's easier to cover your ass than change our litigious and terrorism-fearing society, so while I agree that it shouldn't be necessary, it unfortunately is. That said, AA's twitter response was dumb and they'd be dumber if 'respond publicly to any threats' was the status-quo.
- baddox 13y ago> I don't really want the airline making that assessment because they don't have the people/experience/knowledge/training/ability to accurately assess that threat. Is it really that hard of an assessment to make? Is the threat from a Twitter account? Yes? Okay, is there any reason to think the Twitter account is controlled by someone with the intention or ability to carry out an attack? No? Okay then.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jebblue 13y ago>> is there any reason to think the Twitter account is controlled by someone with the intention or ability to carry out an attack? You can't know that, that's why it's not OK and it's not legal. A threat is a threat. OK then.
- gagaga 13y ago>Okay, is there any reason to think the Twitter account is controlled by someone with the intention or ability to carry out an attack? How does the person who controls their Twitter account decide that?
- PakG1 13y agoIt's far easier to miss than hit, and it gets really grey. Look at any of the mass shooters in recent history. Some of them look a bit dysfunctional, but harmless. Others, not so. Would you REALLY have been able to differentiate shooters from harmless, outcast, social misfits? It's easy to criticize, that's all I'm saying. Let's accept that this is a difficult situation to be put in, and I think notifying the FBI was the right thing. Whether or not the FBI has what it takes to make the right call, who knows. But AA does not.
- agersant 13y ago> Nor will I be surprised when legions of pundits come out of the woodwork exclaiming it wasn't punishment enough, and all the copycats should be treated the same way. No need to look very far, those people are right below the article (in the comments section). I rarely expect much from commentators on news sites but these ones are especially appalling. Samples: > "The feds need to put together a database of teens who post threats online and make them available to future prospective employers. I would have no issue if their lives get ruined." > "It's high time we treat 10-14-year-olds, boys and girls alike, as severely as adults until they get the message. This means throwing them in maximum security prisons with violent hardened career criminals."