4 ms·
'True artistic expression comes from honest interpretation. We don’t get all up in arms when a musician covers a song and releases it as a single.' 'But how to
by dragontamer 13y ago
'True artistic expression comes from honest interpretation. We don’t get all up in arms when a musician covers a song and releases it as a single.'
'But how to distinguish between what is homage and what is outright theft?'
Pretty simple actually. When musicians cover a song, they pay for a license (and possibly pay for royalties as well) to the original author.
When people make game clones, they give no royalties, no financial support to the original. There-in lies the difference between the Game world and the Musical world.
The system works poorly in general, but this area of IP law, moral debate, and so forth needs to happen. Clones are fine as long as the original work is properly compensated... but ensuring proper compensation puts a hamper on small businesses through insane IP Law and regulations.
Maybe the solution is something totally different...
- nimblegorilla 13y agoStudent musicians often cover professional music without paying royalties. I think there is a lot of "creativity" in trying to mimic other people's work even if there is no profit motive.
- sp332 13y agoIf a student in an art museum copies one of the old masters (as happens every day), no money changes hands either. The problem is, for many of the game clones, there is a profit motive.
- watwut 13y agoOriginal Flappy Bird was removed from store and its creator never complained about clones. After all, flappy jam was organized to show support to him. So, in this aspect, he is more in the "old masters" then in the "lost profit" in that. The other things is that if it takes 3 days from start to finish, then it should not be patentable/copyrightable. It is too simple too little work to warrant years long monopoly. On the other hand, no one is going to clone Grand Theft Auto or Oblivion in three days. It is like demanding copyright on sunset picture. There are milions of sunset pictures, some free some paid and no one can claim monopoly over them. One of them is super successful once in a while, but that does not mean all subsequent artists should stop making them. Then again, some even accuse Flappy Bird of being clone. And then again, given some people standards, every single game can be accused of being clone of something.
- wvenable 13y agoI disagree. I think this is the slippy slope of intellectual property. Many people have come to believe that every idea and abstract concept no matter how mundane must become a protected monopoly. For example, the whole Three's vs. 2048 debate: the issue isn't copyright as no code, artwork, or even gameplay rules were directly copied. But people seem up in arms that someone dare create a new game involving shifting numbers. That 'idea' has been consumed. And it doesn't matter that someone could build a product on that idea in a day or two and feels no need to be compensated for it.