5 ms·
Man, I just learned to compliment actions rather than talent, and now I have to do it the other way around. I get why, though. Moral actions are choices. Being
by mcv 13y ago
Man, I just learned to compliment actions rather than talent, and now I have to do it the other way around.
I get why, though. Moral actions are choices. Being smart isn't. If you praise a kid for being smart, he won't be able to choose to be smart. Instead, he'll assume he's smart and won't have to work so hard. I suppose praising an innate tendency to work hard might be more effective.
- VLM 13y agoSome of the article seems more obvious if flipped around... watch some teens/kids tease each other, you'll hear a lot of language along the lines of one kid defining what the other kid "is", not much oblique talk about the success or failure of one individual purchase of clothing to match their current little tribal affiliation. Enforcement of conformity is enforcement of conformity, regardless of the morals/ethics of the conformity itself, so a study of it is incomplete if it only includes the behaviors of the happy sunshine people or only includes parent/child interactions. The interesting part of the article was the quantitative analysis of experimental evidence, not so much that evolution seems to have produced a species that's pretty good at tribal-scale interpersonal dynamics and learning everything by copying superiors. The qualitative analysis seems obvious given the model, so good experimental numbers indicates the popular qualitative model is likely correct.
- shellerik 13y agoYour comment really made me stop and think. It does seem like a contradiction at first: when your child does something good praise their character not their action, when your child does something well praise the action rather than calling them smart or talented. After some thought though I can see it as consistent since when they do something well you can praise them for being hard-working (character).
- Taek 13y agoHaving worked with kids a lot (long term, I would work with the same kids for 4-5 years and get a long term image of their development), it really seems to me like praising a kid for being smart is going to be better than praising a kid for working hard. This sort of gets coupled with the idea of 'work smarter, not harder.' When a child is praised more substantially for trying hard, you get things like staying up all night studying for a test. When you emphasize being smart and not needing to study, the child is more likely to push themselves such that they can land good grades without needing to study. And this usually manifests as greater attentiveness in class, greater emphasis on figuring out exactly what's going to be on the test, etc. But you also see behaviours like emphasizing getting the right teachers. And the same thing applies to sports. If you emphasize effort, you might get a child practicing repeatedly something that they are already good at. When they are really bad at passing, you get thought patterns like 'at least I'm trying.' When you emphasize being good, the child is more devastated by the idea that they are bad at passing, and they focus their energy on being not bad. The point is that things like being 'smart' and being 'good' are things that you can actually learn, and a lot times, working on what's important is much more important than the overall volume of effort.
- vanderZwan 13y agoI'm sorry, but what you are saying just does not match my personal experience, nor what the empirical studies suggest, which is the exact opposite: > When a child is praised more substantially for trying hard, you get things like staying up all night studying for a test. When you emphasize being smart and not needing to study, the child is more likely to push themselves such that they can land good grades without needing to study. The way I've heard and personally experienced it, kids who get praised for being smart are more likely to procrastinate ("eh, I already get that anyway"), then try to cram everything in in the last minute. > And the same thing applies to sports. If you emphasize effort, you might get a child practicing repeatedly something that they are already good at. Similarly, studies suggest that by praising talent, you teach kids to stick to what they are good at immediately ("that's what I'm talented at"), instead of putting in the effort to learn stuff that they don't get immediately. EDIT: Perhaps it depends on whether you praise below-average, average and smarter-than-average kids?
- Taek 13y agoI don't mean to de-emphasize effort, it's still important to try hard, but I've seen a lot of cases where effort was focused on as the only thing that counts. For the smartest kids, that's not usually where the parental emphasis lies. It depends on how you emphasize being smart. If you emphasize overall smartness, the kid will be more self-conscious about their weak points, which is what I wanted to convey. If you emphasize particular moments where they are good, they will be encouraged to repeat that specifically. It's a difference between emphasizing being good at [subset like shooting hoops] vs being good at [basketball as a whole]. Academically, the emphasis should be on the grades instead of on being good at taking tests. Or if you're more high-level, the emphasis should be on learning what's going to be most useful to you later in life as opposed to specifically effort or grades. As for procrastination, in my experience the smarter kids procrastinate substantially more. But for the most part this doesn't come back and bite them. They leave exactly as much time as they need to pull off the good grade and most of the time it works out.
- dubya 13y agoHow can children "push themselves such that they can land good grades without needing to study"? I can see not needing to cram for an exam, because a child has already put the effort in, but learning seems to require some form of study. I think the real danger with this strategy is that when kids are praised for being smart, they seek out things where they are smart, and avoid things that would require hard work. Most worthwhile things require hard work at some point.
- calcsam 13y agoMy fiance made the point that praising a child for his hard work (rather than smarts) is actually praising his tenacity -- a moral virtue.
- lilsunnybee 13y agoYou just praise the kid personally for displaying values that are healthy and helpful to internalize and base an identity on, while for other behaviors (mostly negative ones), you express disappointment (or some other emotion) about the behavior not the person. Looking at it that way it seems pretty intuitive to me. Try and minimize the amount of therapy the kid's going to need as an adult. It's fine to make occasional mistakes, but if you find yourself constantly wanting to put your kid down or praise them for innate but effortless strengths, maybe you're not being quite fair to them and need to reexamine how you approach the relationship. But for most people (and a lot of good parents already), I'd think that most of these prescriptions are pretty natural and mostly effortless.