2 ms·
This provides an interesting counterpoint to one of the classic anti-free-market arguments, which is that the free market economics is based on the approximatio
by jerf 17y ago
This provides an interesting counterpoint to one of the classic anti-free-market arguments, which is that the free market economics is based on the approximation that customers have a lot of information about a product and can successfully use that information to negotiate price. The counterargument is that we do not have such perfect agents creating our system. The counter-counter argument is to observe that it often works even so.
(As you can probably guess from the shortness of that paragraph, I'm not actually making those arguments right now, just setting up some context.)
Having truly pervasive electronic agents in the market working on people's behalf changes that argument chain. Maybe I can't study everything about, say, a given brand of hard drives, but my agent can learn a lot more on my behalf. How does this change the way the market works?
Honestly, I have no idea, I'd need way more time to think about this than a single HN post can be given. I just thought I'd toss this out there, because I think it's a very thought-provoking question, to the point that I'd say that if you think you can figure it out in 5 or 10 seconds I feel pretty confident you're probably off base. (For one thing, there are clearly second-order effects that will emerge if this ever becomes pervasive.)
You can look to the stock market as an exemplar, but there are a lot of potentially-relevant differences between the stock market and an economy full of pervasive use of agents. Price aggregators are another exemplar, but there are also potentially-relevant differences there. I think a large population of people using these agents for a lot of consumer goods would have a new effect of some sort.