3 ms·
I'd love to agree with your idealism but I think it's a bit irrational. It's impossible for us to KNOW whether a given person has the ability to innovate, or t
by kevingadd 13y ago
I'd love to agree with your idealism but I think it's a bit irrational.
It's impossible for us to KNOW whether a given person has the ability to innovate, or the potential to be brilliant. That's absolutely true. However, we have no concrete evidence to support the idea that any given individual CAN innovate, or has the potential for brilliance.
Quite the opposite: We already know of many heritable traits that impair an individual's ability to compete in the workplace, or perform effectively in difficult fields. Most of these are classified as diseases or mental disorders, but regardless...
Acknowledging that not every person is necessarily born with identical talents and capabilities is important if we want to empower these people to do good things and achieve what the rest of us can achieve. Claiming that everyone has equal potential implies that those who don't overachieve are simply not trying hard enough.
(I say this as a person who, due to environment or biology, ended up with an unpleasant assortment of conditions that impair my ability to compete in the workplace.)
- Ygg2 13y agoI don't think it's irrational. Schools don't nurture creativity. They destroy it. Rather effectively. However I might be wrong, can you name the traits impair the general populace? If people can't compete in the workplace, maybe we need a better workplace.
- kevingadd 13y agoWho said anything about schools? Anyway, to name a few that afflict people I know (or me, for that matter) and all have devastating impact on productivity (often in different ways) Chronic fatigue, ADHD/ADD (yes, it exists in adults; sometimes it's adult-onset), clinical depression, bipolar disorder, dyslexia, dyscalculia, etc. It's true that workplace improvements can help people with disadvantages be able to participate and achieve good things, but this is exactly what I mean when I say that people do not have equal potential and capability. To assume otherwise, or blame these disadvantages solely on schooling or some other controllable factor is hopelessly naive. We have to accept that we can't apply our own experiences universally to everyone, and that we have to understand them and recognize their challenges so we can help overcome them.
- Ygg2 13y ago> It's impossible for us to KNOW whether a given person has the ability to innovate, or the potential to be brilliant Sure it's possible to guess, people will innovate depending on their creativity coefficient. That coefficient goes down drastically once kids finish education. If you want more creativity, then you need to address that major hurdle first. I think a large number of those listed aren't real illnesses (dyslexia, dyscalculia) or are often misdiagnosed (ADHD/ADD). I think there might be a way to actually get those people using some means to be useful to society at large.